{ "title": "Tŷ Mawr — The Great House Farm Story", "description": "A source-linked documentary account of the Williams/Buckler family and Great House Farm (Tŷ Mawr), Llandough-juxta-Penarth, told scene by scene in date order. Each scene distinguishes the received account, its source wording and what the records now support; the proposed 1877 Parcel A/B division remains a working model pending a site-matched conveyance.", "ordering": "Scenes are presented in chronological sequence. \"when\" is the human-readable date label; \"date\" is an ISO calendar date where available (null for the approximate BCE context scene and present-day epilogue scenes); \"order\" is the running sequence number; \"ref\" is act.scene.", "parcels": { "A": "House parcel (A)", "B": "Fields (B)", "AB": "Whole farm (A + B)", "?": "Not yet known", "x": "Not Great House Farm land", "": "" }, "source_of_truth": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/", "formats": { "player": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/", "storyboard": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?view=storyboard", "cast": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?view=cast", "script": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/story/", "transcript": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/story/transcript.txt", "llms": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/llms.txt" }, "version": "v0.0.0.68", "last_updated": "2026-10-19", "total_entries": 169, "acts": [ { "id": "P", "label": "Prologue", "title": "To 1857", "span": "Late Iron Age – 1857", "logline": "The earliest archaeological context at Llandough, then the house and manor before the quarry." }, { "id": "I", "label": "Act I", "title": "Division", "span": "1858 – 1915", "logline": "The limeworks, the 1877 division of the farm, and Marconi's wireless trials at Lavernock in May 1897." }, { "id": "II", "label": "Act II", "title": "Tenancies", "span": "1916 – 1948", "logline": "The 1916 and 1939 tenancies, the 1928 rent, and the 1938 sale to Western Ground Rents." }, { "id": "III", "label": "Act III", "title": "Possession proceedings", "span": "1949 – 1968", "logline": "The 1949 tenancy, the papers, the 1955 and 1962 orders, and the tenancy offers." }, { "id": "IV", "label": "Act IV", "title": "BP", "span": "1969 – 1983", "logline": "The sale to BP, a name moved on the map, the 1972 permission, the 1974 survey, the revived 1962 order, the licence letters, the 1975 conveyance and first registration." }, { "id": "V", "label": "Act V", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler", "span": "1984 – March 1988", "logline": "The writ, the judgments, and the amalgamation of the titles." }, { "id": "VI", "label": "Act VI", "title": "Eviction and demolition", "span": "April – December 1988", "logline": "The eviction attempts, the listing decision and the demolition." }, { "id": "VII", "label": "Act VII", "title": "Development", "span": "1989 – 2019", "logline": "Planning, the sale to Ideal Homes, the cemetery excavation and the houses." }, { "id": "VIII", "label": "Act VIII", "title": "Records", "span": "2025 – 2026", "logline": "The family's records requests and complaints, and the replies." }, { "id": "O", "label": "Stating the obvious", "title": "Stating the obvious", "span": "Plainly", "logline": "What should have been said out loud all along." }, { "id": "E", "label": "Epilogue", "title": "Today", "span": "Now", "logline": "The sequence, the site today, and the family's requests." } ], "cast": [ { "id": "mary", "name": "Mary (Nancy) Williams, formerly Buckler", "years": "1913 – 1983", "role": "Born in the farmhouse in 1913 and died there in 1983. Refused the tenancies offered in 1959 and 1965 and the 1974 letters; pleaded ownership in 1974." }, { "id": "john", "name": "John Williams", "years": "d. after 1949", "role": "Mary's father. Tenant of the house and fields from 1908; paid the last rent on the house in 1928." }, { "id": "frederick", "name": "Frederick Buckler", "years": "c. 1908/09 – 1967", "role": "Mary's husband. Held an unwritten yearly tenancy from 1949; the 1955 and 1962 orders were made against him." }, { "id": "billy", "name": "William \"Billy\" Buckler", "years": "1948 – 1990", "role": "Mary's son, born at the farm. Defendant in BP Properties Ltd v Buckler; evicted in November 1988." }, { "id": "branwen", "name": "Branwen Buckler", "years": "", "role": "William's wife; mother of their three children." }, { "id": "eldest", "name": "Frederick and Mary's eldest son", "years": "b. c. 1937–40", "role": "Left the farm in 1968. A cousin's account records a sale of \"our land parcel\"." }, { "id": "thomas", "name": "Daniel and Alfred Thomas", "years": "", "role": "Quarrymen. Daniel Thomas bought Parcel A from Bute in 1877; Alfred Thomas took the last rent on it in 1928." }, { "id": "bute", "name": "The Bute Estate", "years": "", "role": "Freeholders from the early 19th century; sold the farmhouse parcel to Daniel Thomas in 1877 and their remaining interest to Western Ground Rents in 1938." }, { "id": "wgr", "name": "Western Ground Rents Ltd", "years": "", "role": "Bought Bute's interest in 1938; brought the 1955 and 1962 actions; conveyed Parcel B, and an interest in the 1962 order on Parcel A, to BP Pension Trust in 1969." }, { "id": "bp", "name": "BP Pension Trust / BP Properties Ltd", "years": "", "role": "Acquired from Western Ground Rents in 1969; registered the land in 1982–83; obtained possession in 1986–88; demolished the buildings in 1988; transferred the site to Ideal Homes in 1993." }, { "id": "hmlr", "name": "HM Land Registry", "years": "", "role": "Registered titles WA231076 and WA240304 in 1982–83 and amalgamated them in 1987." }, { "id": "cadw", "name": "Cadw", "years": "", "role": "The Welsh heritage body. Considered the house for listing in July and December 1988 and did not list it." }, { "id": "ggat", "name": "GGAT (now Heneb)", "years": "", "role": "The regional archaeological trust. Advised the planning authority and worked on the site, 1982–1995." }, { "id": "rcahmw", "name": "Royal Commission (RCAHMW)", "years": "", "role": "Recorded the house in part in 1974 and examined the rubble in 1988." }, { "id": "courts", "name": "The judges", "years": "", "role": "Judge Temple Morris QC (1962), Mr Justice Hollis (1986), Dillon LJ, Mustill LJ and Sir Edward Eveleigh (1987), Mr Justice Anthony Evans and Judge Norman Francis (1988)." }, { "id": "mps", "name": "Members of Parliament", "years": "", "role": "Ted Rowlands (1980), Alun Michael (1988), Stephen Doughty (2026)." }, { "id": "ideal", "name": "Ideal Homes Wales", "years": "", "role": "Built the twenty houses of Church View Close on the farm." } ], "redirects": { "ghf-12150102-1": "ghf-12000101-1", "ghf-12150101-1": "ghf-12000101-1", "ghf-11000101-1": "ghf-12000101-1", "ghf-15430101-1": "ghf-15520101-1", "ghf-15390101-1": "ghf-15520101-1", "ghf-15360101-1": "ghf-15520101-1", "ghf-14440101-1": "ghf-15520101-1", "ghf-16770101-1": "ghf-16670101-1", "ghf-17700101-1": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-17940101-1": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-18180101-2": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-18180101-1": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-18200101-1": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-18210101-1": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-18240101-1": "ghf-18000101-1", "ghf-18800101-1": "ghf-18400101-1", "ghf-18800101-2": "ghf-18700101-1", "ghf-18771106-1": "ghf-18770101-1", "ghf-19050223-1": "ghf-19080101-1", "ghf-19240515-1": "ghf-19280101-1", "ghf-19100101-1": "ghf-19360101-1", "ghf-19370101-1": "ghf-19360101-1", "ghf-19530101-1": "ghf-19521010-1", "ghf-19610329-1": "ghf-19621211-1", "ghf-19630101-1": "ghf-19630601-1", "ghf-19680901-1": "ghf-19640101-1", "ghf-19700616-1": "ghf-19720725-1", "ghf-19741031-2": "ghf-19741031-1", "ghf-19740919-1": "ghf-19741031-1", "ghf-19780101-1": "ghf-19821001-1", "ghf-press-19800417-n05": "ghf-19821001-1", "ghf-19830313-1": "ghf-19821001-1", "ghf-19840113-1": "ghf-19840522-1", "ghf-press-n15-01": "ghf-19880429-1", "ghf-press-n07": "ghf-19880429-2", "ghf-press-n15-02": "ghf-19880429-2", "ghf-press-n15-03": "ghf-19880512-1", "ghf-19880503-1": "ghf-19880512-1", "ghf-press-n14": "ghf-19881130-1", "ghf-press-n15-04": "ghf-19881130-1", "ghf-press-n09": "ghf-19881130-1", "ghf-press-n15-11": "ghf-19881201-1", "ghf-press-n15-05": "ghf-19881202-1", "ghf-press-n08": "ghf-19881202-1", "ghf-19881130-2": "ghf-19881209-1", "ghf-press-n15-06": "ghf-19881209-1", "ghf-press-n15-10": "ghf-19881209-1", "ghf-press-n10": "ghf-19881205-1", "ghf-press-n11": "ghf-19881206-1", "ghf-press-n15-07": "ghf-19881206-1", "ghf-press-n15-12": "ghf-19881206-1", "ghf-19881211-1": "ghf-19881206-1", "ghf-press-n15-08": "ghf-19881208-1", "ghf-press-n15-09": "ghf-19881208-1", "ghf-press-n15-14": "ghf-19890320-1", "ghf-press-n15-15": "ghf-19890323-1", "ghf-press-n15-16": "ghf-19890323-1", "ghf-19890115-1": "ghf-19890323-1", "ghf-press-n15-13": "ghf-19890323-1", "ghf-19891108-1": "ghf-19891107-1", "ghf-19891010-1": "ghf-19891107-1", "ghf-19900208-1": "ghf-19900313-1", "ghf-19920515-1": "ghf-19900529-1", "ghf-19901015-1": "ghf-19900801-1", "ghf-19931213-1": "ghf-19931203-1", "ghf-19940421-1": "ghf-19940504-1", "ghf-19950628-1": "ghf-19941110-1", "ghf-20051222-1": "ghf-20050101-1", "ghf-20260123-1": "ghf-20251117-1", "ghf-20260213-1": "ghf-20260323-1", "ghf-20260602-1": "ghf-20260730-1", "ghf-20260918-1": "ghf-20260917-1", "ghf-20261005-1": "ghf-20260929-1", "ghf-20260922-1": "ghf-20261006-1", "ghf-20261003-1": "ghf-20261006-1" }, "entries": [ { "order": 1, "ref": "P.1", "id": "ghf-02000101-1", "act": "P", "date": null, "when": "Late Iron Age (approx. 2,200 years ago; exact date uncertain)", "title": "Iron Age farmstead at Llandough", "place": "Llandough Roman Villa site (separate site)", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Archaeological record", "narration": "Excavations in 1978–79 at the separate Llandough Roman Villa site identified earlier Iron Age occupation. A curvilinear feature and postholes may represent a round hut; associated pottery is in a late Iron Age tradition. This is evidence for early occupation at Llandough, not evidence that a round hut stood on the Great House Farm parcel.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": {}, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Heneb's record for the separate Llandough Roman Villa site describes an Iron Age farmstead and a possible round hut, represented by a curvilinear feature and postholes. The pottery indicates a pre-Conquest tradition, but the record does not establish an exact date of c. 200 BC or show that the hut stood on Great House Farm itself.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Heneb HER GGAT00768s — Llandough Roman Villa (Iron Age farmstead / possible round hut)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT00768s" }, { "type": "National monument record", "title": "Coflein NPRN 400051 — Roman Villa Site, Llandough; excavation in 1979", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fcoflein.gov.uk%2Fen%2Fsite%2F400051%2F" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-02000101-1" }, { "order": 2, "ref": "P.2", "id": "ghf-06500101-1", "act": "P", "date": "0650-01-01", "when": "c. 650 (approximate)", "title": "St Dochdwy's", "place": "Llandough churchyard, beside the farm", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Archaeological record", "narration": "Beside the farm stands St Dochdwy's, Llandough. It is thought to have been an early monastery, founded around the year 650; the churchyard and the ground north of it hold the burials later excavated in 1994.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": {}, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The church and its early burial ground sit next to the farm; the 1994 cemetery excavation north of the church took place on former farm land.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-06500101-1" }, { "order": 3, "ref": "P.3", "id": "ghf-12000101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1200-01-01", "when": "12th – 14th century", "title": "Medieval occupation", "place": "Great House — north-east slope", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Archaeological record", "narration": "In 1962–63 E. J. Beare reports pottery of the 12th to 14th centuries on the slope north-east of the house. The Royal Commission classes the house as sub-medieval, probably 17th century, possibly with a medieval core.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": {}, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "An old farmhouse of no special note.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"sub-medieval\"", "note": "A technical dating term, later read as \"not old enough to matter\"." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A house of the 17th century or earlier, on a site occupied since the Middle Ages, possibly with a medieval core.", "cast": [ "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-12150102-1", "ghf-12150101-1", "ghf-11000101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-12000101-1" }, { "order": 4, "ref": "P.4", "id": "ghf-15450101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1545-01-01", "when": "1536 – 1793", "title": "The lordship of the manor", "place": "Manor of Llandough", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "Llandough belongs to Tewkesbury Abbey until the Dissolution of 1536–39. Cardiff Records states that in 1543 Henry VIII granted the manor to Lord Clynton and Say and Robert Turwitt, and that by 1545 it was held by Sir George Herbert. The Western Mail letter states that the Herberts held the lordship until the Earl of Bute bought it in 1793; Cardiff Records places William Hurst and others in the account from 1767. The same 1974 newspaper record identifies Mary (Nancy) Williams's family as occupying the manorial home since 1667. That occupation and the lordship are separate from the farmhouse freehold. The family's case is that the Williamses were virtual freeholders under the 1877 bargain while quarrying continued, and that Parcel A's freehold passed to them when quarrying ended (1928 in Mary's recollection; the quarry's plant was catalogued for sale in November 1925).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor: Sir George Herbert (by 1545) and his family" }, "title_moves": [ "Great House (one farm)" ], "received_account": "The lord of the manor owned the farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"since 1667\"", "note": "The 1974 newspaper records the Williams family’s occupation of the manorial home; occupation is a separate matter from the lordship and the freehold." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Lordship of a manor and ownership of the farmhouse parcel are separate interests. The 1974 newspaper records the Williams family’s occupation of the manorial home since 1667. The family’s title case is not occupation alone: it is that the 1877 bargain entitled the Williamses to Parcel A’s freehold when quarrying ended, identified by Mary as 1928, when the final rent was paid. On that account, the Williamses were virtual freeholders while the quarrying arrangement ran and became freeholders in 1928. The 1877 deed and final receipt have not been located, so the 1928 transfer remains the family’s asserted title history rather than a fact determined by the 1974 newspaper or a court. The manorial sources also differ over 1767–1793; the Herbert estate papers have not yet been checked.", "cast": [ "mary", "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Western Mail, 'Grievous loss' (1974 letter giving manorial descent and the Williams occupation)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n04" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — the sale", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#sale-1877" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — takes effect in 1928", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#takes-effect" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Llandough (Penarth): Cydfin / Tŷ Mawr and pre-1877 manorial evidence", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/anomalies-register/llandough-penarth-cydfin-ty-mawr-manorial-evidence/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-15450101-1" }, { "order": 5, "ref": "P.5", "id": "ghf-15470620-1", "act": "P", "date": "1547-06-20", "when": "20 June 1547", "title": "A 1,000-year lease of Cydwin", "place": "Manor of Llandough — Cydwin", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Archival catalogue", "narration": "The National Library of Wales catalogue describes a lease for 1,000 years dated 20 June 1547 from Sir George Herbert of Swansea to Edmund Vaughan of a farm called Cydwin in the manor of Llandough; the record names fields. This long leasehold interest predates the later Bute estate narrative. The affirmative Cedwyn thesis asks whether those named fields belong to the older Cydfin/Ty Mawr holding later catalogued as a 107-acre farm, and how that interest passed from the Herbert/Vaughan line into subsequent estate records. The instrument and field boundaries must be examined before the lease can be equated with the whole Great House site.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor: Sir George Herbert (by 1545) and his family" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The Bute estate is the beginning of the land's title.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "An NLW catalogue entry for a Herbert–Vaughan lease (not a record of Tŷ Mawr; under forensic examination) names a Cydwin farm in the manor of Llandough and a 1,000-year lease from Sir George Herbert to Edmond Vaughan. That is a specific pre-Bute interest and an archival route to follow. It does not yet identify every field with the later Great House boundaries; the lease and its named fields must be compared with D 219 and historic plans.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "National Library of Wales, L 11 — assignment of a lease for 1,000 years of Cydwin in the manor of Llandough", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchifau.llyfrgell.cymru%2Findex.php%2Fassignment-of-lease-for-1000-years-of-cydwin-in-manor-of-llandough" }, { "type": "Estate papers", "title": "National Library of Wales, Bute Estate Records D 219 — Llandough manorial leases and agreements", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchives.library.wales%2Findex.php%2Fllandough-manorial-leases-and-agreements" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "GHF-E178 — Cydwin lease (under forensic examination) lead", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/ghf-e173-cedwyn-cwm-cedwyn-place-name-notes/ghf-e178-1547-sir-george-herbert-grants-vaughan-a-1000-year-lease-of-cydwin/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Llandough (Penarth): Cydfin / Tŷ Mawr and pre-1877 manorial evidence", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/anomalies-register/llandough-penarth-cydfin-ty-mawr-manorial-evidence/" }, { "type": "Research annex", "title": "Cedwyn Estate — title-chain reconstruction", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/research/cedwyn-estate-title-chain.html" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-15470620-1" }, { "order": 6, "ref": "P.6", "id": "ghf-15520101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1552-01-01", "when": "1552–1824 (Bute catalogue range; not a Tŷ Mawr date)", "title": "Manorial leases", "place": "Llandough manorial leases", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Estate papers", "narration": "The National Library of Wales holds a Bute Estate bundle of Llandough manorial leases and agreements (D 219), catalogued as one bundle, its application to Tŷ Mawr and its dating under forensic examination. Its catalogue identifies leases of \"Cydfin Farm or Ty Mawr Farm, (107 a.)\", ; the heading is the cataloguer’s, not a dated mention of Tŷ Mawr, and its application and dating are under forensic examination.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Farm (Cydfin or Tŷ Mawr, 107 acres): Bute catalogue heading (application and dating under forensic examination) · lordship of the manor: the Herberts" }, "title_moves": [ "Great House (one farm)" ], "received_account": "A farm let on ordinary leases.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Tŷ Mawr is first named in the record in the 1824 David Stewart survey (EV-0211). Earlier Bute catalogue dates are not records of Tŷ Mawr and have their application and dating under forensic examination. The 1829 end date belongs to the bundle as a whole, not to the farm, and no event in 1829 is recorded. The individual deeds have not yet been inspected; they should show who granted the leases and on what terms.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Estate papers", "title": "National Library of Wales, Bute Estate Records D 219: Llandough manorial leases and agreements, 1552–1829", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchives.library.wales%2Findex.php%2Fllandough-manorial-leases-and-agreements" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Name & Location Variations", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/great-house-farm/name-variations/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-15430101-1", "ghf-15390101-1", "ghf-15360101-1", "ghf-14440101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-15520101-1" }, { "order": 7, "ref": "P.7", "id": "ghf-15600101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1560-01-01", "when": "Mid 16th – late 18th century", "title": "The Vaughans", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "From the mid-16th to the late 18th century the Vaughan family hold Great House as the chief freehold farm of the parish. The lordship of the manor is a separate interest, held over the same period by the Herberts.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Farm freehold: the Vaughans · lordship of the manor: the Herberts (a separate interest)" }, "title_moves": [ "Great House (one farm)" ], "received_account": "One chain of owners: the Herberts, then the Vaughans, then Bute.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Two separate lines. The lordship of the manor: Tewkesbury Abbey, the Crown, the Herberts from 1545, Bute from 1793. The ownership of the farm: a freehold within the manor, held by the Vaughans until the late 18th century and by Bute from the early 19th. How the farm passed from the Vaughans to Bute is not yet documented. Parcel A's title descends from the farm freehold, not from the lordship.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Bute Estate (Vaughan chief freehold farm)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bute-estate/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "1990 GGAT Assessment — transcription (Vaughan phase)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1990-ggat-archaeological-assessment-great-house-farm-llandough-transcription/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-15600101-1" }, { "order": 8, "ref": "P.8", "id": "ghf-16670101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1667-01-01", "when": "1667", "title": "The Williams family at Great House", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's c.1974 statement records that her family had lived and farmed at Great House since 1667. A 1974 newspaper report also reports her statement that her family first acquired Tŷ Mawr around that date. The affirmative Cedwyn thesis treats 1667 as the opening of the family's own estate history and tests that statement against the Cydwin/Cydfin lease and farm-name records. The surviving statement and press report support the Buckler case; a 1667 conveyance has not yet been identified.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Farm freehold: the Vaughans · lordship of the manor: the Herberts · in the house: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [ "Great House (one farm)" ], "received_account": "Tenant farmers who lived on someone else's land.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"tenants\"", "note": "The estate's description of the family, repeated in every later account." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Mary's statement and the 1974 press report support the Buckler case for a connection with Great House from 1667 and treat it as a lineage claim, not a passing tenancy. The affirmative reconstruction now connects that claim to the older Cydwin/Cydfin/Ty Mawr lease records and asks whether later labels of tenancy concealed a longer-standing family interest. The surviving items do not themselves constitute a 1667 conveyance; the deed chain must be reconstructed from the leases, estate accounts, plans and the 1877/1928 evidence.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family — origins", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-16770101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-16670101-1" }, { "order": 9, "ref": "P.9", "id": "ghf-17400213-1", "act": "P", "date": "1740-02-13", "when": "13 February 1739/40", "title": "Vaughan assigns the Cydwin lease", "place": "Manor of Llandough — Cydwin", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Archival catalogue", "narration": "The National Library of Wales catalogues an assignment dated 13 February 1739/40 by Edmond Vaughan of Llandough to Thomas Mathews of Llandaf of the 1,000-year Cydwin lease (a Herbert–Vaughan document whose application to Tŷ Mawr is under forensic examination), for £1,066 13s. 4d. This is a documented transfer in the older lease chain and a concrete route for tracing who held the interest before Bute's later estate records. The next step is to match the named fields and follow subsequent assignments, rentals and conveyances into the Cydfin/Ty Mawr farm and the later parcels.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Farm freehold: the Vaughans · lordship of the manor: the Herberts · in the house: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The Vaughan lease chain has no relevance once later estate papers call the land Ty Mawr.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The L 11 catalogue records Edmond Vaughan's 1739/40 assignment of the 1,000-year Cydwin lease to Thomas Mathews for £1,066 13s. 4d. The assignment offers a concrete transfer point for reconstructing the older interest. Follow its named fields and later assignments into the Cydfin/Ty Mawr records and the eventual Bute estate acquisition.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "National Library of Wales, L 11 — assignment of a lease for 1,000 years of Cydwin in the manor of Llandough", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchifau.llyfrgell.cymru%2Findex.php%2Fassignment-of-lease-for-1000-years-of-cydwin-in-manor-of-llandough" }, { "type": "Estate papers", "title": "National Library of Wales, Bute Estate Records D 219 — Llandough manorial leases and agreements", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchives.library.wales%2Findex.php%2Fllandough-manorial-leases-and-agreements" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "GHF-E179 — Cydfin / Ty Mawr names in Bute records", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/ghf-e173-cedwyn-cwm-cedwyn-place-name-notes/ghf-e179-1552-1824-bute-records-call-it-cedfin-cydfin-ken-fin-farm-or-ty-mawr-farm/" }, { "type": "Research annex", "title": "Cedwyn Estate — title-chain reconstruction", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/research/cedwyn-estate-title-chain.html" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-17400213-1" }, { "order": 10, "ref": "P.10", "id": "ghf-18000101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1800-01-01", "when": "1793 – early 19th century", "title": "The Bute Estate", "place": "Great House", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "The historical account places Bute's acquisition of the lordship of Llandough in 1793 and its acquisition of the Great House freehold in the early 19th century; the manorial courts of Llandough and Leckwith were held at the house. The missing control point is the instrument that carried the farm freehold from the Vaughan line into Bute's estate. The Cydwin lease and its 1739/40 assignment, and the Bute catalogue heading for Cydfin or Ty Mawr leases (none of them a record of Tŷ Mawr before 1824; all under forensic examination) give the affirmative reconstruction a named chain to investigate alongside the manor's later ownership. A manorial interest, a long lease, and a farm freehold must be mapped separately before the later corporate titles can be treated as the originating chain for every parcel.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [ "Great House (one farm)" ], "received_account": "Bute owned the farm, and everything after descends from Bute.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The historical account places the manorial lordship in Bute's hands from 1793 and the Great House farm freehold in the early 19th century. The deed that moved the farm freehold from the Vaughan line is the key missing control point. The L 11 lease assignment and D 219 farm records provide older property and tenure references against which Bute's acquisition, rentals and subsequent 1877 division must be tested. The house was also a centre for the Llandough and Leckwith manorial courts; that administrative role must not be confused with ownership of each parcel.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Bute Estate", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bute-estate/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Llandough (Penarth): Cydfin / Tŷ Mawr and pre-1877 manorial evidence", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/anomalies-register/llandough-penarth-cydfin-ty-mawr-manorial-evidence/" }, { "type": "Estate papers", "title": "National Library of Wales, Bute Estate Records R1: Glamorgan Estate rentals", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchives.library.wales%2Findex.php%2Fglamorgan-estate-rentals" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Name & Location Variations (Stewart survey, D/d B E/1–2)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/great-house-farm/name-variations/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-17700101-1", "ghf-17940101-1", "ghf-18180101-2", "ghf-18180101-1", "ghf-18200101-1", "ghf-18210101-1", "ghf-18240101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18000101-1" }, { "order": 11, "ref": "P.11", "id": "ghf-18240101-2", "act": "P", "date": "1824-01-01", "when": "1824", "title": "The Stewart survey", "place": "Cedfin or Ty Mawr Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Estate papers", "narration": "David Stewart surveys the Bute estates in Glamorgan. Plan 19 is \"Cedfin or Ty Mawr Farm\". Its reference table enters John Gedrick (reading uncertain) as occupier of the main farm, 107 acres 1 rood 24 perches, and beside it the land of \"late Thos. Williams\", 10 acres 3 roods 39 perches, with about 20 acres of woods: close to 140 acres in all. A Williams name stands on the farm's own plan almost a century before the 1916 tenancy.", "family_case": "The family reads the separate entry for the late Thomas Williams's land as a Williams holding inside Tŷ Mawr that Bute surveyed but did not let with the main farm.", "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Bute owned and let the whole farm; the Williamses were later arrivals.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Bute's own 1824 survey of Cedfin or Ty Mawr Farm lists the land of the late Thomas Williams as a separate entry beside the main farm.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Estate papers", "title": "EV-0211 — Glamorgan Archives DB/E/1, plan 19: \"Cedfin or Ty Mawr Farm\", Stewart survey and reference table (1824)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0211-db-e-1-plan-19-cedfin-ty-mawr-1824/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Name & Location Variations (Stewart survey)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/great-house-farm/name-variations/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18240101-2" }, { "order": 12, "ref": "P.12", "id": "ghf-18400101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1840-01-01", "when": "c. 1840", "title": "Great House Farm", "place": "Census and tithe records", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "Census and tithe records begin to describe the house as \"Great House Farm\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "It was always just a farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Great House Farm\"", "note": "A name that reduced the manor's court house to a farmhouse." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The first change in how the place was described. Later descriptions, especially \"the whole farm\", decide the case.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Farmhouse Nomenclature", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/great-house-farm/farmhouse-nomenclature/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Name & Location Variations", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/great-house-farm/name-variations/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-18800101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18400101-1" }, { "order": 13, "ref": "P.13", "id": "ghf-18550101-1", "act": "P", "date": "1855-01-01", "when": "1855", "title": "John Williams succeeds his father", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "John Williams succeeds his father as occupier of the farm under the Bute Estate. Reporting the Bute rent audit dinner of July 1904, the Cardiff Times reports that he \"succeeded his father in the tenancy of the farm in 1855\", and that it was \"his 102nd rent audit\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "One newspaper line, written 49 years later, gives 1855 as the start of John Williams's tenancy and says he took it over from his father; the 1841 tithe already has a John Williams holding about 120 acres at Tŷ Mawr. Against it: the 1904 report calls him \"of Llandough Farm\", the name of the Rees family's separate farm, so reading it as Great House rests on the directories, which put him at \"Great House\" in 1891 and 1901 (an inference, not proof). The Bute rent audits that would confirm 1855 have not been seen.", "cast": [ "john", "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Cardiff Times, 16 July 1904, p.1 — Bute rent audit dinner (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3427270%2F3427271%2F13%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0227 — Cardiff Times, 16 July 1904: John Williams, tenancy since 1855 (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0227-cardiff-times-1904-john-williams-tenancy-since-1855/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "EV-0215 — Tithe apportionment: John Williams, c. 1841", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0215-tithe-apportionment-john-williams-c1841/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18550101-1" }, { "order": 14, "ref": "I.1", "id": "ghf-18641223-1", "act": "I", "date": "1864-12-23", "when": "23 December 1864", "title": "Death of Amy Williams of Great House", "place": "Llandough", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Amy Williams dies at Llandough, aged 65. The death notices call her \"relict of the late Mr. John Williams, Great House farm\": the widow of the elder John Williams, whose son John had taken over the tenancy in 1855.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"relict of the late Mr. John Williams, Great House farm\"", "note": "The notice's own words: the elder John Williams was dead by December 1864, and was remembered as \"of Great House farm\"." } ], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (two contemporary death notices, read on Welsh Newspapers Online). They fit the 1904 report that the younger John Williams \"succeeded his father in the tenancy of the farm in 1855\". Not yet found: the elder John Williams's own death or burial entry, and Amy's maiden name.", "cast": [ "john" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Cardiff Times, 30 December 1864, p.5 — deaths: \"at Llandough, near Cardiff, Amy, relict of the late Mr. John Williams, Great House farm, aged 65 years\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3383386%2F3383391%2F14%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Cardiff and Merthyr Guardian, 30 December 1864, p.5 — deaths: \"WILLIAMS.—Dec. 23, at Llandough, near Cardiff, Amy, relict of the late Mr. John Williams, Great House farm, aged 65\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3094324%2F3094329%2F21%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0246 — the death notices on the wiki (evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0246-cardiff-times-1864-death-of-amy-williams-great-house-farm/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18641223-1" }, { "order": 15, "ref": "I.2", "id": "ghf-18680101-1", "act": "I", "date": "1868-01-01", "when": "1868 – 1901", "title": "\"Williams John, Great house\"", "place": "Trade directories", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Publication", "narration": "The trade directories list the farmers of Llandough parish. Every edition from 1868 to 1901 has \"Williams John, Great house\", from 1887 \"Great House farm, Llandough\". Thomas Rees, and later Evan Rees, are listed separately, at Llandough Farm, a different Bute farm.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Six directories over 33 years put the same John Williams at Great House and the Rees family at Llandough Farm, so the two farms, and the two families, were distinct. Against it: directories copy from one edition to the next and record what the compiler was told; none uses the name \"Home Farm\"; and the press of 1895 and 1904 sometimes calls a Williams \"of Llandough Farm\", so that name in a source does not always mean the Rees farm.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Publication", "title": "Slater's Directory 1868, p.902, Llandough: \"Williams John, Great house\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F91309" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Worrall's Directory 1875, p.324, farmers in Llandough parish: \"Williams John, Great house\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F348840" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Slater's Directory 1880, p.533, farmers in Llandough: \"Williams John, Greathouse\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F90316" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Owen's Cardiff Directory 1887, p.209: \"Williams John, Great House farm, Llandough\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F92950" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Owen's Cardiff Directory 1891, p.237: \"Williams John, overseer, Great House farm, Llandough\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F93394" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Cardiff Directory 1901, p.309: \"Williams John, Great House farm, Llandough\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F95085" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "EV-0225 — Trade directories 1868–1901: \"Williams John, Great house\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0225-trade-directories-1868-1901-john-williams-great-house/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Weekly Mail, 6 November 1886 — Thomas Rees, aged 89, of Llandough Farm, \"rented from the Marquess of Bute\"", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3365383%2F3365390%2F150%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0228 — Llandough Farm and the Rees family, 1841–1910: a separate Bute farm (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0228-llandough-farm-rees-family-1841-1910/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18680101-1" }, { "order": 16, "ref": "I.3", "id": "ghf-18700101-1", "act": "I", "date": "1870-01-01", "when": "c. 1870", "title": "The armour under the floor", "place": "Great House — dining room", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Source pending", "narration": "Family tradition records a soldier in armour, with his horse, a lance and a shield, found beneath the dining-room floor. The account is in a Royal Commission record (NMR 6048942) and the Daily Telegraph of 16 April 1974. No primary record of a find has been located.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Family folklore.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"reported\"", "note": "The word the records use, which keeps it at a distance." } ], "what_we_now_know": "An account on public record since 1974, never investigated before the house was demolished.", "cast": [ "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Daily Telegraph, 16 April 1974 (dates the find to \"about 1870\")", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n03" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-18800101-2" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18700101-1" }, { "order": 17, "ref": "I.4", "id": "ghf-18700101-2", "act": "I", "date": "1870-01-02", "when": "1870 — Pwllypant probate and estate papers", "title": "A Williams estate bequest to Bute: tracing the land", "place": "Pwllypant / Llandough title research", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Probate and estate catalogue leads", "narration": "The National Library of Wales catalogue lists the 1870 will of William Evans Williams of Pwllypant as bequeathing his real and personal estate to the Marquis of Bute, and separately catalogues papers about his real and personal estate. The affirmative title inquiry is parcel-specific: did any land he owned, benefited from, or had let through Bute connect to the 33-acre Llandough Limeworks block or Great House Farm? The will's headline bequest does not identify those acres by itself. The family's research also points to a Clock Tower dispute and newspaper coverage that may have complicated the relationship between Williams and Bute; the precise contemporary reports and wording must be located before using that dispute as proof of motive. Estate schedules, title deeds, rent books and the 1876–1912 limeworks accounts are the route to answer the question.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "William Evans Williams left his fortune to Bute, so the land history is settled.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The catalogued 1870 will is a lead to the estate's disposition, not a parcel schedule for Great House Farm. Test whether land or rights connected with Llandough's 33-acre limeworks block appear in William Evans Williams's title papers, rentals or correspondence. The reported Clock Tower dispute should be linked to its exact contemporary newspaper source before it is used to characterise the relationship.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "National Library of Wales, D242/17 — probate of the will of William Evans Williams of Pwllypant (1870)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchives.library.wales%2Findex.php%2Fdeeds-and-documents-relating-mainly-to-title-of-pwllypant-estate-including-copy-probate-of-will-of-david-evan%253Bisad%3Fsf_culture%3Den" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "National Library of Wales, D258 — papers relating to the personal and real estates of William Evans Williams", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchives.library.wales%2Findex.php%2Fpapers-relating-to-personal-and-real-estates-of-william-evans-williams-dec-including-account-of-aberdare-iron-co" }, { "type": "Historical context", "title": "History Points — Former Pwllypant House, Caerphilly", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fhistorypoints.org%2Findex.php%3Fpage%3Dformer-pwllypant-house-caerphilly" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Llandough Limeworks — the 33-acre block", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/llandough-limeworks/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Bute Estate — unresolved early title", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bute-estate/" }, { "type": "Research annex", "title": "Cedwyn Estate — title-chain reconstruction", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/research/cedwyn-estate-title-chain.html" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18700101-2" }, { "order": 18, "ref": "I.5", "id": "ghf-18760101-1", "act": "I", "date": "1876-01-01", "when": "1876 – c. 1912", "title": "The limeworks", "place": "Llandough Limeworks", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Estate papers", "narration": "The Wiki's archive lead identifies about 33 acres used by the Llandough Limeworks from 1876 to about 1912, with Bute papers D153/4–8 to be obtained and inspected. The block's precise boundaries and title line remain to be matched to the 1877 plan and the estate schedules. For the Cedwyn reconstruction, this is a critical parcel-control point: identify who owned the freehold, who granted the quarrying rights, who received rent, and whether all four descriptions refer to the same acres.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Great House (one farm)": "Lordship of the manor (1793) and farm freehold (early 19th century): the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Part of the farm let for quarrying.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The archive lead identifies a 33-acre quarrying block in Bute records from 1876 to about 1912, but its exact parcel and chain of authority need to be established from D153/4–8, the 1877 plan and the estate schedules. The key affirmative question is who held the underlying freehold and who merely let or administered the quarrying rights.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0280 — Llandough Lime Works and quarry, 1876–1947: contemporary record set", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0280-llandough-lime-works-and-quarry-1876-1947-daniel-thomas-s-kilns-quarry-workers-kel/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Llandough Limeworks", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/llandough-limeworks/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18760101-1" }, { "order": 19, "ref": "I.6", "id": "ghf-18770101-1", "act": "I", "date": "1877-01-01", "when": "1877", "title": "Division of the farm", "place": "Bute Estate Office", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement records that in 1877 the Bute Estate sold the farmhouse, buildings and about 10 acres to Daniel Thomas, and kept about 9 acres. The Williamses remained the occupiers of both. The deed is missing.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title", "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "Nothing changed: Bute went on owning the farm, and the Williamses went on renting it.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "On Mary's statement, from 1877 there are two parcels with two owners: Parcel A, the house, owned by Thomas; Parcel B, the fields, kept by Bute. Anything Bute sells after 1877 can only be Parcel B. Her statement says the freehold of the house was to pass to the Williamses when quarrying ended. The deed is missing; the wiki notes that whether the 1877 deal was a sale or a quarry lease is still to be tested against the Bute papers.", "cast": [ "mary", "thomas", "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0278 — NLW Bute records: Llandough manor rentals 1808–1881 and presentments 1793–1934 (catalogue entries)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0278-nlw-bute-estate-records-llandough-manor-rentals-1808-1881-r-6-27-45-and-presentmen/" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — the sale", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#sale-1877" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — plan", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#plan" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Two Parcels", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/the-two-parcels/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — Bute lease", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#sale-1877" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Forensic Master Chronology (6 October 2026)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/forensic-master-chronology-authoritative-corrected-6-october-2026/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-18771106-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18770101-1" }, { "order": 20, "ref": "I.7", "id": "ghf-18810403-1", "act": "I", "date": "1881-04-03", "when": "3 April 1881", "title": "The 1881 census: \"Llandough Home Farm\"", "place": "Census, Llandough (RG11/5288 p.2)", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "The 1881 census records \"Llandough Home Farm\": John Williams, 53, \"Farmer of 170 [? or 120] ac. employing 1 man and 1 boy\", born at Leckwith; his wife Mary, 51, born at Cogan; their children Ellen, 14, John, 13, and David, 9; a boarder and a servant. Per Sion Buckler, this is Great House Farm entered under the wrong name. The directories of 1880 and 1887 place the same John Williams at Great House.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Llandough Home Farm\"", "note": "The enumerator's label. No other source found uses it: no newspaper (Welsh Newspapers Online, 1804–1919), directory or Ordnance Survey map." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The household is the John Williams whom the directories place at Great House before and after 1881. The Rees family were at Llandough Farm. On identity the record supports Sion Buckler's reading. Against it: \"Home Farm\" appears nowhere else, so it cannot be offered as a second name for the farm; and the acreage is hard to read: 170 would fit Llandough Farm (166 acres in 1824–32) better than Great House (about 120 acres in the 1841 tithe), while 120 fits Great House. Folio and enumeration district: source pending. EV-0223 records a different, dictated reading of the farm name that this page does not show.", "cast": [ "mary", "john" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0224 — 1881 census, Llandough, RG11/5288 p.2 (photograph and transcription)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0224-1881-census-llandough-rg11-5288/", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1881-census-rg11-5288-p2.jpg" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Slater's Directory 1880, p.533, farmers in Llandough: \"Williams John, Greathouse\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F90316" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Owen's Cardiff Directory 1887, p.209: \"Williams John, Great House farm, Llandough\" (University of Leicester Historical Directories)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fleicester.contentdm.oclc.org%2Fdigital%2Fcollection%2Fp16445coll4%2Fid%2F92950" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "EV-0225 — Trade directories 1868–1901: \"Williams John, Great house\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0225-trade-directories-1868-1901-john-williams-great-house/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0228 — Llandough Farm and the Rees family, 1841–1910: a separate Bute farm (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0228-llandough-farm-rees-family-1841-1910/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "EV-0223 — 1881 census: a dictated variant of the farm name (pending)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0223-1881-census-name-variant/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1881-census-rg11-5288-p2.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18810403-1" }, { "order": 21, "ref": "I.8", "id": "ghf-18871215-1", "act": "I", "date": "1887-12-15", "when": "15 December 1887 (obituary)", "title": "Death of Daniel Thomas", "place": "Penylan, Cardiff", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Daniel Thomas of Penylan dies. His obituary in Tarian y Gweithiwr describes him as a contractor under Lord Bute and the owner of \"valuable lime kilns at Llandough\". In April 1888 a local man is described as \"a labourer at Llandough Quarry\": the quarry beside the farm is still worked.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Daniel Thomas held the Llandough lime kilns under the 1877 arrangement with Bute; the works passed to his family and continued after his death.", "cast": [ "thomas", "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0280 — Llandough lime works and quarry, 1876–1947: Daniel Thomas’s kilns and quarry workers", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0280-llandough-lime-works-and-quarry-1876-1947-daniel-thomas-s-kilns-quarry-workers-kel/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18871215-1" }, { "order": 22, "ref": "I.9", "id": "ghf-18890811-1", "act": "I", "date": "1889-08-11", "when": "11 August 1889", "title": "Apples from the orchard", "place": "Great House Farm — the orchard by the railway", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Four boys climb \"over the hedge from the railway\" into \"the orchard of Great House Farm\" and take apples, \"the property of John Williams\". John Williams junior helps the constable catch three of them, and tells the Penarth magistrates that about half the apples in his father's orchard have gone.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A minor court report.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the property of John Williams\"", "note": "The apples were his; the report is silent on who owned the land." } ], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (Barry Dock News, 16 August 1889, read on Welsh Newspapers Online; EV-0279). Contemporary record that John Williams held Great House Farm in 1889, with his grown son John Williams junior working it, and that the orchard lay against a railway hedge.", "cast": [ "john" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0279 — Barry Dock News, 16 August 1889, p.2: \"the orchard of Great House Farm … the property of John Williams\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0279-barry-dock-news-16-aug-1889-p-2-apples-taken-from-the-orchard-of-great-house-farm/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Barry Dock News, 16 August 1889, p.2 — \"A Batch of Orchard Looters at Llandough\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4594680%2F4594682%2F18%2F" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18890811-1" }, { "order": 23, "ref": "I.10", "id": "ghf-18911111-1", "act": "I", "date": "1891-11-11", "when": "11 November 1891", "title": "Theft of geese", "place": "Llandough — court report", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Three geese are taken from \"Mr. John Williams, Great House Farm, Llandough\". The theft is reported from court.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A minor court report.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Contemporary proof that John Williams lived at the house in 1891.", "cast": [ "john" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "1891 court report — farmyard theft", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n01", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n01-1891-farmyard-theft.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Star, 10 June 1892 — geese \"the property of Mr. John Williams, Great House Farm, Llandough, on November 11, 1891\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3019697%2F3019705%2F78%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0226 — South Wales Star, 10 June 1892: \"Mr. John Williams, Great House Farm, Llandough\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0226-south-wales-star-1892-john-williams-great-house-farm/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n01-1891-farmyard-theft.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18911111-1" }, { "order": 24, "ref": "I.11", "id": "ghf-18920101-1", "act": "I", "date": "1892-01-01", "when": "1892", "title": "Signals across the water: Preece at Lavernock", "place": "Lavernock Point and Flat Holm", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The Post Office engineer William Preece stretches long parallel wires on the shore at Lavernock and on Flat Holm, 3.3 miles out, and sends messages between them by induction, with no wire across the water. Five years later Marconi comes to the same shore.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED that the 1892 messages were reported in 1897 in Preece's own words (South Wales Daily Post, 5 June 1897). The details (wire lengths, 3.3 miles, the failed attempt to Steep Holm) are SECONDARY, from Fahie's history of 1899/1901. This is the Lavernock background to Marconi.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Daily Post, 5 June 1897, p.3 — Preece's Royal Institution lecture: \"In 1892 distinct messages were sent across a portion of the Bristol Channel between Penarth and the Flat Holm, a distance of over three miles\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3356360%2F3356363%2F20%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Cardiff Times, 13 March 1897, p.2 — \"No Use for Wires\": the \"wonderful doings\" of Mr Preece \"at Lavernock and the Flat Holm\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3431204%2F3431206%2F41%2F" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] J. J. Fahie, A History of Wireless Telegraphy (1899; 2nd ed. 1901), chapter on Preece's induction method: the Lavernock–Flat Holm trials", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fearlyradiohistory.us%2F1901fa21.htm" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18920101-1" }, { "order": 25, "ref": "I.12", "id": "ghf-18940731-1", "act": "I", "date": "1894-07-31", "when": "Week of 30 July 1894", "title": "Swine fever at Great House", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Swine fever breaks out at Llandough. Five pigs belonging to Mr Williams of Great House are slaughtered. On the Tuesday morning one of his herd of 23 is reported affected, and it is feared the whole herd will have to go.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (two newspapers, 3 August 1894). Most likely the John Williams whom the directories place at Great House Farm, Llandough (1868–1901). Against it: there is another Great House at Llandough near Cowbridge, and the report pairs Llandough with Rhoose, so the parish is not certain. The herd of 22–23 pigs shows a working farm.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Barry Dock News, 3 August 1894, p.5 — \"Swine fever at Llandough and Rhoose\": \"Five pigs belonging to Mr Williams, Great House, have been slaughtered\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4596799%2F4596804%2F24%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Glamorgan Gazette, 3 August 1894, p.5 — the same report (herd given as 22) (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3874190%2F3874195%2F53%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0247 — the swine-fever reports on the wiki (evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0247-barry-dock-news-1894-swine-fever-great-house-llandough/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18940731-1" }, { "order": 26, "ref": "I.13", "id": "ghf-18970501-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-01", "when": "Late April – early May 1897", "title": "Marconi comes to Lavernock", "place": "Lavernock Point", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The Cardiff papers announce that the young Italian Guglielmo Marconi, 23, will come to Cardiff \"in a few weeks\" to signal across the Bristol Channel without wires, with the Post Office's staff and apparatus at his disposal. At Lavernock Point the receiving station goes up on the cliff: a tall pole with a zinc cylinder at the top (120 feet in the Evening Express; 30 yards in Preece's account). The press names the man who put it up only as \"Mr. Williams (of the engineering department, Cardiff)\". The sending station is on Flat Holm.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Marconi's Welsh trials were a Post Office affair.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Mr. Williams (of the engineering department, Cardiff)\"", "note": "The only Williams in any 1897 report read. He is a Post Office engineer in Cardiff. No initial or address is given." } ], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED: the trials, the date (Evening Express, 15 May 1897, p.4) and \"Mr. Williams (of the engineering department, Cardiff)\". The wiki's undated cutting EV-0011 is that Evening Express report; the same text is in the Western Mail of the same day. Sion Buckler's position (request to The National Archives, 16 July 2026) is that this Mr Williams was his forebear Mr Williams of Great House Farm, that Marconi stayed with the family at the farm in 1897, and that Thomas Williams of Great House carted Marconi's equipment. Link to Great House: evidence being added. The photograph that the wiki's Media Gallery captioned \"Marconi wireless telegraph at Great House Farm\" (caption corrected 19 October 2026) is the Flat Holm photograph of 13 May 1897 (see 13 May). Next records: Post Office establishment books (BT Archives, POST 59) for a Williams in the Cardiff engineering district in 1897; the 1901 census.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "national-archives" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 26 April 1897, p.2 — \"Wireless Telegraphy … Coming to Cardiff in a Few Weeks to Experiment Across the Bristol Channel\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3270301%2F3270303%2F28%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Weekly Mail, 1 May 1897, p.4 — the same report (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3370882%2F3370886%2F79%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 15 May 1897 (Extra Special), p.4 — \"Wireless Telegraphy. Marconi Invention Tested at Lavernock\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3270811%2F3270815%2F108%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Western Mail, 15 May 1897, p.6 — \"Telegraphy without wires. Marconi invention tested at Lavernock\" (same report) (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4313747%2F4313753%2F61%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0011 — the same cutting on the wiki (catalogued there as undated; identified here as the Evening Express, 15 May 1897, p.4)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0011-marconi-lavernock-wireless-cutting-1897/", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n02-1897-marconi-lavernock.jpg" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] J. J. Fahie, A History of Wireless Telegraphy (1899; 2nd ed. 1901), chapter on Marconi's method, drawing on Preece's Royal Institution lecture of 4 June 1897", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fearlyradiohistory.us%2F1901fa23.htm" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Sion Buckler, records request to The National Archives, 16 July 2026, \"Mr. Williams, Cardiff Post Office Engineering Department, 1897 Marconi Lavernock Experiments\" (TNA replied 30 July 2026 that it is not the right place to ask)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/?p=5363" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0248 — Marconi in Wales, April–July 1897: the contemporary press record on the wiki (evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0248-marconi-in-wales-may-1897-contemporary-press/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n02-1897-marconi-lavernock.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970501-1" }, { "order": 27, "ref": "I.14", "id": "ghf-18970510-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-10", "when": "10 May 1897", "title": "Preece's method tried again", "place": "Lavernock Point and Flat Holm", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Publication", "narration": "Before Marconi's own trials begin, the Post Office repeats Preece's induction method between Lavernock and Flat Holm. It works.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "SECONDARY (Fahie, 1899/1901, from Preece's account). No 1897 newspaper read here mentions 10 May.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] J. J. Fahie, A History of Wireless Telegraphy (1899; 2nd ed. 1901), chapter on Marconi's method, drawing on Preece's Royal Institution lecture of 4 June 1897", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fearlyradiohistory.us%2F1901fa23.htm" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] BBC Wales History blog, \"Marconi's Welsh wireless revolution\" (May 2012), quoting the same account", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.co.uk%2Fblogs%2Fwaleshistory%2F2012%2F05%2Fmarconi_wireless_open_sea_lavernock_point_flat_holm.html" }, { "type": "Diary", "title": "EV-0256 — George Kemp’s diary, 6–15 May 1897 (Bodleian MS. Marconi 89, extracts quoted by G. R. M. Garratt): Lavernock p", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0256-kemp-diary-lavernock-1897-bodleian-ms-marconi-89/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970510-1" }, { "order": 28, "ref": "I.15", "id": "ghf-18970511-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-11", "when": "11–12 May 1897", "title": "Two days of failure", "place": "Lavernock Point", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Marconi's first attempts to receive signals from Flat Holm at the Lavernock cliff-top station fail. The Evening Express reports that the experiments on Tuesday \"were not so successful as might have been desired\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED that Tuesday 11 May went badly (Evening Express, 15 May 1897). Fahie says 11 and 12 May both failed, but the Evening Express calls Wednesday and Thursday \"most satisfactory\". The 1947 plaque gives 11 May as the day messages were first exchanged with Flat Holm. The sources conflict on 11–13 May.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 15 May 1897 (Extra Special), p.4 — \"Wireless Telegraphy. Marconi Invention Tested at Lavernock\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3270811%2F3270815%2F108%2F" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] J. J. Fahie, A History of Wireless Telegraphy (1899; 2nd ed. 1901), chapter on Marconi's method, drawing on Preece's Royal Institution lecture of 4 June 1897", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fearlyradiohistory.us%2F1901fa23.htm" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "[SECONDARY] Rotary Club of Cardiff plaque, St Lawrence's churchyard, Lavernock (transcription): \"BETWEEN LAVERNOCK AND FLAT HOLM 11th MAY, LAVERNOCK AND BREAN DOWN 18th MAY 1897 … ERECTED BY THE ROTARY CLUB OF CARDIFF 1947\"", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Freadtheplaque.com%2Fplaque%2Fmarconi-s-first-radio-transmissions-across-water" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970511-1" }, { "order": 29, "ref": "I.16", "id": "ghf-18970513-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-13", "when": "13 May 1897", "title": "Signals across the sea", "place": "Lavernock Point and Flat Holm", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The receiver is carried down to the beach below the cliff and joined to the pole by another 20 yards of wire. Signals from Flat Holm, 3.3 miles away, now print clearly on the Morse inker at Lavernock. The Evening Express reports that on Wednesday and Thursday \"the results were most satisfactory\". Watching are Preece, his second engineer Mr Gavey (late of Cardiff), the Cardiff postmaster Mr Fardo and other officials. The German Professor Slaby is there too.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Marconi sent the first radio message over open sea, from Lavernock to Flat Holm, on 13 May 1897.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Are you ready?\"", "note": "A later account of the first words. Another later account gives \"CAN YOU HEAR ME\" and \"YES LOUD AND CLEAR\". No 1897 source read here records the words." } ], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED: success by midweek (Evening Express: Wednesday 12 and Thursday 13 May \"most satisfactory\"); Preece, Gavey and Fardo present. SECONDARY: the date 13 May, the 20 extra yards of wire, and Slaby's presence (Fahie). Direction: in Preece's account (via Fahie) Flat Holm sent and Lavernock received; some modern accounts reverse it. The photograph is captioned by its source as Flat Holm, 13 May 1897. Its date and place rest on that caption. Link to Great House: evidence being added.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 15 May 1897 (Extra Special), p.4 — \"Wireless Telegraphy. Marconi Invention Tested at Lavernock\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3270811%2F3270815%2F108%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Western Mail, 15 May 1897, p.6 — \"Telegraphy without wires. Marconi invention tested at Lavernock\" (same report) (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4313747%2F4313753%2F61%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Echo, 17 May 1897, p.2 — \"The Man About Town\": \"Lavernock and the Flat Holm will stand out in the history of electrical science\"; the messages were recorded, not just heard (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4604986%2F4604988%2F5%2F" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] J. J. Fahie, A History of Wireless Telegraphy (1899; 2nd ed. 1901), chapter on Marconi's method, drawing on Preece's Royal Institution lecture of 4 June 1897", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fearlyradiohistory.us%2F1901fa23.htm" }, { "type": "Photograph", "title": "[SECONDARY: date and place as captioned by the source] Post Office engineers inspect Marconi's apparatus on Flat Holm, 13 May 1897. Photo: Cardiff Council Flat Holm Project, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Post_Office_Engineers.jpg)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fcommons.wikimedia.org%2Fwiki%2FFile%3APost_Office_Engineers.jpg", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1897-05-13-flat-holm-post-office-engineers-marconi.jpg" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY — conflicting] Later accounts give the first words as \"Are you ready?\" (We Are Cardiff, 13 May 2016) or \"CAN YOU HEAR ME\" / \"YES LOUD AND CLEAR\" (BBC Wales History, 2012). No 1897 source read here gives the words.", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwearecardiff.co.uk%2F2016%2F05%2F13%2Fmarconis-first-wireless-message-transmitted-over-sea-from-flat-holm-to-lavernock-point%2F" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1897-05-13-flat-holm-post-office-engineers-marconi.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970513-1" }, { "order": 30, "ref": "I.17", "id": "ghf-18970514-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-14", "when": "14 May 1897 (Friday)", "title": "The demonstration at Lavernock", "place": "Lavernock Point", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On Friday afternoon Marconi gives a semi-public demonstration. A select company of local scientists and engineers watches his system explained in miniature, with a transmitter facing a receiver about twenty yards away, and messages written by the Morse self-inker without a connecting wire.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (Evening Express, 15 May 1897; Carnarvon and Denbigh Herald, 21 May 1897). The guests are not named.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 15 May 1897 (Extra Special), p.4 — \"Wireless Telegraphy. Marconi Invention Tested at Lavernock\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3270811%2F3270815%2F108%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Carnarvon and Denbigh Herald, 21 May 1897, p.4 — \"Telegraphing without wires\": Preece \"during last week\" testing Marconi's invention between Lavernock Point and the Flat Holme; a select company of local scientists and engineers invited (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3603309%2F3603313%2F23%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Weekly Mail, 22 May 1897, p.8 — \"Wireless Telegraphy. Marconi Invention Tested at Lavernock\" (same report) (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3370921%2F3370929%2F162%2F" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970514-1" }, { "order": 31, "ref": "I.18", "id": "ghf-18970518-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-18", "when": "18 May 1897", "title": "Lavernock to Brean Down", "place": "Lavernock Point and Brean Down (Somerset)", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The range is pushed across the whole Channel. A message sent from Lavernock Point, through a wire carried 220 feet up on a kite, is received at Brean Down, near Weston-super-Mare, about eight and a half miles away. Marconi signs the paper tape. That week he works on Brean Down with Preece and Gavey.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED: the 18 May date, the kite at 220 ft and Marconi's signature are all on the framed tape, as transcribed by the South Wales Echo on 27 May 1897. The Echo of 20 May has messages going from Brean Down to Lavernock that week; the tape reads Lavernock to Brean Down. Fahie dates the Brean Down link to the day after the Flat Holm success. Brean Down is in Somerset and is included only as the far end of the Welsh link.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Echo, 27 May 1897, p.4 — \"First wireless telegram\": \"Sent from Lavernock Point through a kite at an elevation of 220ft., and received at Brean Down, May 18th, 1897 … (Signed) G. Marconi\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4605031%2F4605035%2F99%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Echo, 20 May 1897, p.3 — \"The Marconi experiments\": Marconi, with Mr Preece and Mr Gavey, \"has this week been at work on Brean Down\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4605001%2F4605004%2F57%2F" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "[SECONDARY] Rotary Club of Cardiff plaque, St Lawrence's churchyard, Lavernock (transcription): \"BETWEEN LAVERNOCK AND FLAT HOLM 11th MAY, LAVERNOCK AND BREAN DOWN 18th MAY 1897 … ERECTED BY THE ROTARY CLUB OF CARDIFF 1947\"", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Freadtheplaque.com%2Fplaque%2Fmarconi-s-first-radio-transmissions-across-water" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] J. J. Fahie, A History of Wireless Telegraphy (1899; 2nd ed. 1901), chapter on Marconi's method, drawing on Preece's Royal Institution lecture of 4 June 1897", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fearlyradiohistory.us%2F1901fa23.htm" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970518-1" }, { "order": 32, "ref": "I.19", "id": "ghf-18970527-1", "act": "I", "date": "1897-05-27", "when": "Late May – July 1897", "title": "The first wireless telegram goes on show", "place": "Cardiff Central Free Library", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The framed tape of the Brean Down message goes on view in the hall of the Cardiff Central Free Library. Work at Lavernock goes on \"for a few days longer\". On 4 June Preece describes the Penarth–Brean Down signals to the Royal Institution in London. Marconi leaves England for Italy on Monday 5 July 1897.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED. Not found: the day Marconi left South Wales. The last Welsh press notice of the work found is the South Wales Echo of 20 May 1897. In 1897 Marconi's next move was to London, and then Italy (Spezia trials, 10–18 July 1897, per Fahie).", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Echo, 27 May 1897, p.4 — the framed tape on view at the Cardiff Central Free Library (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4605031%2F4605035%2F99%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Echo, 20 May 1897, p.3 — \"Work is still progressing at Lavernock, and will be continued for a few days longer\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4605001%2F4605004%2F57%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] South Wales Daily Post, 5 June 1897, p.3 — Preece's Royal Institution lecture: signals \"between Penarth and Brean Down … a distance of nearly nine miles\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3356360%2F3356363%2F20%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Carnarvon and Denbigh Herald, 9 July 1897, p.2 — Preece: \"Marconi only left England on Monday\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3603372%2F3603374%2F10%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Y Negesydd, 23 July 1897, p.1 — \"Pellebru heb wifrau\": experiments \"yn agos i Benarth, Caerdydd\" by Mr Preece and Marconi (Welsh) (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F3819134%2F3819135%2F2%2F" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-18970527-1" }, { "order": 33, "ref": "I.20", "id": "ghf-19021129-1", "act": "I", "date": "1902-11-29", "when": "29 November 1902", "title": "Coppice woods offered at auction", "place": "Cwm Cydfin Wood, Leckwith and Llandough", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Sale particulars", "narration": "Stephenson & Alexander offer the Marquess of Bute's coppice woods at auction, including \"Cwm Cydfin Wood, Leckwith and Llandough\", the woodland north of the house (particular 192). The particulars do not state whether the land or only the coppice is offered.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The woodland north of the house was managed by Bute as coppice in 1902; whether the land itself changed hands then is not shown.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Sale particulars", "title": "EV-0219 — Bute coppice woods sale, 1902: Cwm Cydfin Wood", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0219-bute-coppice-woods-sale-1902-cwm-cydfin-wood/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19021129-1" }, { "order": 34, "ref": "I.21", "id": "ghf-19070401-1", "act": "I", "date": "1907-04-01", "when": "1 April 1907", "title": "Air-rifle meeting at Great House Farm", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The Llandough Air-rifle Club holds its Easter Monday meeting at Great House Farm: ten shots at twenty yards. A Llandough man, J. Griffiths, comes third.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: Daniel Thomas (bought from Bute) · tenants: the Williamses, promised the freehold when quarrying ends", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenants: the Williamses" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (two notices). The reports do not name the farmer.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0282 — Evening Express 1907–1908: air-rifle meeting and poacher at Great House Farm (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0282-evening-express-27-mar-and-2-apr-1907-air-rifle-meeting-at-great-house-farm-llando/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 27 March 1907, p.3 — notice: an air-rifle shooting competition \"at the Great House Farm, Llandough, on Monday next\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4174604%2F4174607%2F109%2F" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 2 April 1907, p.4 — \"Air-rifle shooting. The Llandough meeting … held on Monday at Great House Farm, Llandough\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4174794%2F4174798%2F123%2F" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19070401-1" }, { "order": 35, "ref": "I.22", "id": "ghf-19080101-1", "act": "I", "date": "1908-01-01", "when": "1908", "title": "John Williams", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "Mary's grandfather dies. John Williams takes over the house from the Thomases and the fields from Bute.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Thomases · tenant: John Williams", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title", "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "John Williams became the tenant of the farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the tenant\"", "note": "Singular, as if there were one tenancy of one farm." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Two tenancies from two landlords: Parcel A from the Thomases, Parcel B from Bute.", "cast": [ "mary", "john", "thomas", "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0283 — Bute Court Leet at Llandough 1904–1917: “John Williams” on the 1910 jury (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0283-bute-court-leet-at-llandough-press-reports-1904-1917-john-williams-on-the-1910-gra/" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "John Williams — 1908", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/john-williams/#y1908" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — deeds before registration (1905 Bute conveyance)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#deeds-before-registration" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0243 — Barry Dock News, 23 Oct 1908, p.3: court leet vote of sympathy with \"the family of the late Mr. John Williams, Great House, Llandough\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0243-barry-dock-news-1908-court-leet-john-williams-great-house/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19050223-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19080101-1" }, { "order": 36, "ref": "I.23", "id": "ghf-19080106-1", "act": "I", "date": "1908-01-06", "when": "6 January 1908", "title": "A poacher caught on Great House Farm", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Shortly before three in the morning two keepers on their round at Llandough see a man net two rabbits on Great House Farm and catch him before he leaves the field. At Barry he is sent to gaol for two months.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Thomases · tenant: John Williams", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (Evening Express, 10 January 1908). The keepers are not said to be the farm's own. John Williams of Great House died later in 1908 (EV-0243).", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0282 — Evening Express 1907–1908: air-rifle meeting and poacher at Great House Farm (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0282-evening-express-27-mar-and-2-apr-1907-air-rifle-meeting-at-great-house-farm-llando/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "[VERIFIED] Evening Express, 10 January 1908, p.3 — \"Two months for a poacher\": \"poaching on Great House Farm, Llandough\" (Welsh Newspapers Online)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnewspapers.library.wales%2Fview%2F4184741%2F4184744%2F84%2F" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19080106-1" }, { "order": 37, "ref": "I.24", "id": "ghf-19130810-1", "act": "I", "date": "1913-08-10", "when": "10 August 1913", "title": "Birth of Mary (Nancy) Williams", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams is born in the farmhouse on 10 August 1913.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Thomases · tenant: John Williams", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A tenant's daughter.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The owner of Parcel A from 1928 by her family's title. She lived in the house until her death in 1983.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams/" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19130810-1" }, { "order": 38, "ref": "II.1", "id": "ghf-19160201-1", "act": "II", "date": "1916-02-01", "when": "February 1916", "title": "The 1916 tenancy", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "Bute grants John Williams a yearly tenancy described as \"the whole farm\". The document has not been found.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Thomases · tenant: John Williams", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "The Williamses were yearly tenants of the whole farm from 1916, and every later right flows from that tenancy.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the whole farm\"", "note": "Quoted by the Court of Appeal in 1987 as the start of the history." }, { "said": "\"since 1916\"", "note": "The European Commission's date for the family's occupation." } ], "what_we_now_know": "In 1916 Bute owned only Parcel B. It could not let the house, which Thomas owned. \"The whole farm\" is a landlord's description of land it did not own: the birth of a single, synthetic farm that existed only on paper. Every later case was fought over that synthetic farm.", "cast": [ "john", "bute" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1916 Tenancy", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1916-tenancy/#grant" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Farm / Whole Farm Nomenclature", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/the-two-parcels/whole-farm-nomenclature/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19160201-1" }, { "order": 39, "ref": "II.2", "id": "ghf-19230101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1923-01-01", "when": "1923", "title": "Esther Williams signs for peace", "place": "Llandough", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "The Llandough sheet of the 1923 Welsh Women's Peace Petition carries 36 signatures. Line eight reads \"Esther Williams\", \"Llandough\". Her neighbours sign from Llwyn-yr-Eryr, The Post Office, Lewis Road, the brickworks and the Toll House, \"Llandough Near Cardiff\". The Court of Appeal later records Mr Williams and his wife Mrs Esther Williams living at the farm in 1955. The sheet names no farm: that she is the Esther Williams of Great House Farm is our reading. The date is the National Library of Wales catalogue date; the sheet carries none.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Thomases · tenant: John Williams", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The Court of Appeal records Mr Williams and his wife Mrs Esther Williams living at the farm in 1955. The petition is a peace petition, not a land document, and gives no house name; the 1921 census and the 1923–24 register of electors for Llandough would show whether this Esther Williams is the farmer's wife.", "cast": [ "courts" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Archival catalogue", "title": "National Library of Wales, Petition 1/92: Welsh Women's Peace Petition, Llandough sheet (1923): page images and transcription (wayback WB-0039)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/artifacts/#WB-0039" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0294 — Welsh Women’s Peace Petition 1923, Llandough sheet (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0294-welsh-womens-peace-petition-1923-llandough-nlw-petition-1-92/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19230101-1" }, { "order": 40, "ref": "II.3", "id": "ghf-19271214-1", "act": "II", "date": "1927-12-14", "when": "14 December 1927", "title": "Death of Lord Pontypridd", "place": "Cardiff", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Alfred Thomas, Lord Pontypridd, son of Daniel Thomas of the Llandough lime works, dies unmarried. The next year the last quarry machinery leaves and the final rent on the house is paid.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Thomases · tenant: John Williams", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The death of Daniel Thomas's son and heir in December 1927 comes after the quarry had stopped (its plant was catalogued for sale in November 1925) and just before the last rent on the house, which Mary recalled as 1928.", "cast": [ "thomas" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0284 — Alfred Thomas, Lord Pontypridd, son of Daniel Thomas of the Llandough lime works, dies 1927", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0284-alfred-thomas-lord-pontypridd-son-of-daniel-thomas-of-the-llandough-lime-works-die/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19271214-1" }, { "order": 41, "ref": "II.4", "id": "ghf-19280101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1928-01-01", "when": "1928", "title": "Last rent on the house", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement records that in 1928 the last quarry machinery left, and John Williams paid a final rent of about £4 to Alfred Thomas. She saw the receipt. It is missing. The quarry's plant and tramlines had already been catalogued for sale in November 1925 (Glamorgan Archives DSA/12/4888).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Bute → Thomas → Williams)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "Nothing happened in 1928. The tenancy of the whole farm carried on.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "On Mary's statement, the bargain of 1877 came due: the quarrying ended and the freehold of the house passed to the Williamses, and they never paid rent on it again. The wiki treats 1928 as the strongest evidence-based date for the Williams freehold. The freehold line of the house: the Vaughans, then Bute (by the early 19th century), then Daniel Thomas (1877), then the Williamses (1928).", "cast": [ "mary", "john", "thomas" ], "institutions": [ "glamorgan-archives" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Biography", "title": "EV-0284 — Alfred Thomas, Lord Pontypridd, died 14 Dec 1927; estate report (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0284-alfred-thomas-lord-pontypridd-son-of-daniel-thomas-of-the-llandough-lime-works-die/" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — takes effect 1928", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#takes-effect" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — deeds before registration (15 May 1924 agreement)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#deeds-before-registration" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Forensic Master Chronology (6 October 2026)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/forensic-master-chronology-authoritative-corrected-6-october-2026/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Two Parcels", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/the-two-parcels/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19240515-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19280101-1" }, { "order": 42, "ref": "II.5", "id": "ghf-19360101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1936-01-01", "when": "1936", "title": "Marriage", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams marries Frederick Buckler, who comes to live at the farmhouse. They have seven children. The Western Mail of 5 August 1936 reports the wedding of Mr. Fred Buckler of Barry and Miss Mary Doreen (Nancy) Williams of Great House Farm (snippet only).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Bute → Thomas → Williams)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: the Bute Estate · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Frederick joined the tenant family on the farm.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Frederick married into the house, which was Mary's family's. His later tenancy was of the fields only.", "cast": [ "mary", "frederick" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0230 — Western Mail, 5 August 1936, p.10: \"Llandough Bride\", Buckler–Williams wedding (SNIPPET ONLY; wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0230-western-mail-1936-llandough-bride-buckler-williams/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Frederick Buckler — marriage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/frederick-buckler/#marriage" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Frederick Buckler", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/frederick-buckler/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19100101-1", "ghf-19370101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19360101-1" }, { "order": 43, "ref": "II.6", "id": "ghf-19380101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1938-01-01", "when": "1938", "title": "Sale to Western Ground Rents", "place": "Bute Estate Office", "parcel": "B", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "The Bute Estate conveys its reversion on the 1916 tenancy to Western Ground Rents Ltd.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Bute → Thomas → Williams)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents (from Bute, 1938) · tenant: John Williams" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "Western Ground Rents bought the farm, and became the Williamses' landlord for all of it.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the reversion\"", "note": "Read later as the reversion on the whole farm." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Bute could only convey what it owned: Parcel B and its landlord's interest in the fields. Western Ground Rents acquired no deed to Parcel A, then or ever.", "cast": [ "bute", "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0285 — Western Mail snippets 1925–1939: Great House Farm under John Williams (sheep 1925, pony 1937, gun lost Feb 1939)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0285-snippets-only-western-mail-1925-1939-naming-great-house-farm-llandough-john-willia/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "1938–39: Sale to WGR and the Revised Tenancy", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1939-revised-tenancy/#y1938" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0257 — Glamorgan Archives D696: Western Ground Rents Ltd records 1938–44 (a syndicate headed by Lord Kennet; Bute urb", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0257-glamorgan-archives-d696-western-ground-rents-records-custodial-history/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0262 — TNA LT 13/3048: Western Ground Rents Ltd v the Lord Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of the City of Cardiff, Lands", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0262-tna-lt-13-3048-western-ground-rents-v-cardiff-lands-tribunal-1967/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19380101-1" }, { "order": 44, "ref": "II.7", "id": "ghf-19390501-1", "act": "II", "date": "1939-05-01", "when": "May 1939", "title": "The 1939 tenancy", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "B", "basis": "Document", "narration": "Western Ground Rents grants John Williams a revised tenancy, with a plan.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Bute → Thomas → Williams)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: John Williams (1939 plan: fields only)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "A renewal of the farm tenancy.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The plan shows the fields east of the house only: Parcel B. The landlord's own document leaves the house out. It is the last written tenancy.", "cast": [ "john", "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "1938–39: the 1939 tenancy", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1939-revised-tenancy/#y1939" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1939 tenancy plan", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1939-revised-tenancy/#plan" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19390501-1" }, { "order": 45, "ref": "II.8", "id": "ghf-19400101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1940-01-01", "when": "c. 1940", "title": "Twelve years", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Family case", "narration": "By 1940, twelve years after 1928, no rent has been paid on the house.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses, by the 1877 bargain and by title by possession (twelve years rent-free, 1928–1940)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: John Williams (1939 plan: fields only)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "Not an event. The family were tenants throughout.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Twelve years' rent-free possession from 1928 gives the family title to Parcel A by possession by 1940, in addition to the 1877–1928 title. The wiki notes this depends on what title the Thomases held. On either footing, from 1940 there was no basis for treating the family's occupation of the house as permission from Western Ground Rents, which never owned it.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "1938–39 — c. 1940", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1939-revised-tenancy/#c1940" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Forensic Master Chronology (6 October 2026)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/forensic-master-chronology-authoritative-corrected-6-october-2026/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19400101-1" }, { "order": 46, "ref": "II.9", "id": "ghf-19420401-1", "act": "II", "date": "1942-04-01", "when": "1940 – April 1942", "title": "The gift of Leckwith Woods", "place": "Leckwith Woods", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "Western Ground Rents gives about 109 acres of Leckwith Woods to Cardiff council. The gift is offered and accepted in 1940 and completed in April 1942. Whether it takes in any of the woodland beside the farm is a question for the 1942 conveyance plan.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses, by the 1877 bargain and by title by possession (twelve years rent-free, 1928–1940)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: John Williams (1939 plan: fields only)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The extent of the 1940–42 gift is not yet laid over the farm's boundaries; the 1942 conveyance and its plan would settle it.", "cast": [ "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "Cardiff Parks Committee minutes, 1940–42 (Glamorgan Archives BC/C/6/79)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fcanfod.glamarchives.gov.uk%2Fen%2Frecords%2FBC%2FC%2F6%2F79" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Master Timeline", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/timeline/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19420401-1" }, { "order": 47, "ref": "II.10", "id": "ghf-19440101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1944-01-01", "when": "1944", "title": "Farm management", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "B", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "The War Agricultural Executive Committee is dissatisfied with the farm. Frederick Buckler takes over running it as manager for John Williams.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses, by the 1877 bargain and by title by possession (twelve years rent-free, 1928–1940)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: John Williams (1939 plan: fields only)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The tenant farm was failing.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Frederick managed the fields, Parcel B.", "cast": [ "john", "frederick" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0286 — Western Mail, 17 Nov 1942: farm stock sale at “Great House Farm, Llandough” (snippet; parish unverified)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0286-snippet-only-western-mail-17-nov-1942-p-2-important-sale-of-live-and-dead-farming/" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "John Williams — 1944", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/john-williams/#y1944" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0241 — National Farm Survey 1941–43, Penarth parish, TNA MAF 32/1220/39 (catalogue entry; that the farm's form is in it is an inference; not seen) (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0241-tna-maf-32-1220-39-national-farm-survey-penarth-1941/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19440101-1" }, { "order": 48, "ref": "II.11", "id": "ghf-19470101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1947-01-01", "when": "1947", "title": "The Lavernock plaque", "place": "St Lawrence's churchyard, Lavernock", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "The Rotary Club of Cardiff puts up a bronze plaque at St Lawrence's, Lavernock: \"Near this spot the first radio messages were exchanged across water by Guglielmo Marconi and George Kemp.\"", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses, by the 1877 bargain and by title by possession (twelve years rent-free, 1928–1940)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: John Williams (1939 plan: fields only)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "SECONDARY: the plaque's wording is from a published transcription, and the BBC gives the unveiling as 1948. It names George Kemp.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "[SECONDARY] Rotary Club of Cardiff plaque, St Lawrence's churchyard, Lavernock (transcription): \"BETWEEN LAVERNOCK AND FLAT HOLM 11th MAY, LAVERNOCK AND BREAN DOWN 18th MAY 1897 … ERECTED BY THE ROTARY CLUB OF CARDIFF 1947\"", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Freadtheplaque.com%2Fplaque%2Fmarconi-s-first-radio-transmissions-across-water" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "[SECONDARY] BBC Wales History blog (2012): the plaque \"unveiled by the Cardiff Rotary Club\" in 1948 (the plaque itself reads 1947)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.co.uk%2Fblogs%2Fwaleshistory%2F2012%2F05%2Fmarconi_wireless_open_sea_lavernock_point_flat_holm.html" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19470101-1" }, { "order": 49, "ref": "II.12", "id": "ghf-19480101-1", "act": "II", "date": "1948-01-01", "when": "c. 1948 – 49", "title": "Birth of William Buckler", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Source pending", "narration": "William (Billy) Buckler is born at the farm on 25 August 1948 (the date given in the 1987 Court of Appeal judgment).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses, by the 1877 bargain and by title by possession (twelve years rent-free, 1928–1940)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Seed (a landlord's wording, not the family's): the words \"the whole farm\" in a Bute tenancy (Bute can only let Parcel B)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: John Williams (1939 plan: fields only)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Mary's son and heir, who defended the house in court and was evicted in 1988.", "cast": [ "billy", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family — William", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19480101-1" }, { "order": 50, "ref": "III.1", "id": "ghf-19490202-1", "act": "III", "date": "1949-02-02", "when": "2 February 1949", "title": "The 1949 tenancy", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "B", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "John Williams surrenders his tenancy. Frederick Buckler's yearly tenancy from Western Ground Rents begins on 2 February 1949. It is not put in writing.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses, by the 1877 bargain and by title by possession (twelve years rent-free, 1928–1940)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 1 to make Mary look permitted: her house spoken of as part of Frederick's unwritten fields tenancy (no 1949 offer to Mary concerning Parcel A, or reply from her, has been found; she still holds the paper title)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: Frederick Buckler (unwritten, from 1949)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A", "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "Frederick became the tenant of the farm, and the family lived in the farmhouse under his tenancy.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the farm\"", "note": "Used for Frederick's tenancy in every later account." } ], "what_we_now_know": "An unwritten tenancy of the fields, Parcel B. Mary was not a party and rejected any suggestion that the house was in it; she then held the paper title to Parcel A. Describing it as a tenancy of \"the farm\" was the first attempt to make her occupation of her own house look permissive.", "cast": [ "john", "frederick", "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "Frederick Buckler — the 1949 tenancy", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/frederick-buckler/#tenancy-1949" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Two Parcels", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/the-two-parcels/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Case Analysis — Connections, Patterns and Questions", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/case-analysis-connections-patterns-questions/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19490202-1" }, { "order": 51, "ref": "III.2", "id": "ghf-19500601-1", "act": "III", "date": "1950-06-01", "when": "June 1950 – c. 1952", "title": "The blanket box", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Mary's statement", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement records that in June 1950 Mr Knapp, a Penarth estate agent, placed a lodger, Bruce Sutherland, at the farmhouse. He stayed about two years, and later told her he had taken \"the papers which were in the blanket box including the agreement relating to the farm\" and given them to Mr Knapp.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses · their deeds taken from the blanket box (missing from now on; title buried, not extinguished)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 1 to make Mary look permitted: her house spoken of as part of Frederick's unwritten fields tenancy (no 1949 offer to Mary concerning Parcel A, or reply from her, has been found; she still holds the paper title)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: Frederick Buckler (unwritten, from 1949)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "If the family ever had documents, they could not produce them.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"No such documents were, however, ever produced.\"", "note": "Court of Appeal, 1987." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The papers that proved the family's title, kept in a blanket box, were carried out of the house by a lodger an estate agent had placed under their roof, and handed to that agent. It happened a year after Mary refused a tenancy of the farmhouse and asserted ownership, and within three years of the landlord's first court case; Mary believed the two were connected. For the rest of her life she was told to produce documents that had been taken from her. The title was never extinguished. Only its proof was taken.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — papers taken", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#papers-taken" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Case Analysis — Connections, Patterns and Questions", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/case-analysis-connections-patterns-questions/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Register Additions — 6 October 2026 (A-080: Mr Knapp)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/master-scrutiny-issue-register/additions-2026-10-06/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19500601-1" }, { "order": 52, "ref": "III.3", "id": "ghf-19521010-1", "act": "III", "date": "1952-10-10", "when": "1952 – 53", "title": "Last rent on the fields", "place": "Landlords' agents", "parcel": "B", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 10 October 1952 the landlord's agents write that they will not proceed with a letting to Frederick. He pays his last rent in 1953.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses · their deeds taken from the blanket box (missing from now on; title buried, not extinguished)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 1 to make Mary look permitted: her house spoken of as part of Frederick's unwritten fields tenancy (no 1949 offer to Mary concerning Parcel A, or reply from her, has been found; she still holds the paper title)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: Western Ground Rents · tenant: Frederick Buckler (unwritten, from 1949)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The tenant stopped paying rent on the farm.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Rent stopped on the fields, Parcel B. No rent had been paid on Parcel A since 1928.", "cast": [ "frederick" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "Frederick Buckler — 1952 letter", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/frederick-buckler/#tenancy-1949" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Master Timeline", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/timeline/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19530101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19521010-1" }, { "order": 53, "ref": "III.4", "id": "ghf-19550202-1", "act": "III", "date": "1955-02-02", "when": "2 February – 4 July 1955", "title": "The 1955 possession order", "place": "High Court / Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 2 February 1955 a notice to quit served on Frederick Buckler expires. Western Ground Rents then obtains a High Court order for possession against him, by summary judgment, described as \"the whole of the farm\". On 4 July 1955 possession is taken of everything except the farmhouse and garden; the 1987 judgment attributes the exception to Mary's recent return from hospital and her strong objection.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 2: High Court order against the fields tenant for \"the whole of the farm\" (house not taken; Mary never heard)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title", "Synthetic Parcel A", "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "The landlord recovered the farm in 1955; the family stayed on in the house only through the landlord's forbearance, and from 1955 their occupation was adverse to the landlord.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the whole of the farm\"", "note": "The order's description, quoted in 1987." }, { "said": "adverse possession from 1955", "note": "The clock the courts later counted on the house." } ], "what_we_now_know": "An order against a tenant of the fields can only give back the fields, and that is what was taken. Mary was not a party and was never heard. She had just come home from hospital and stood her ground for her house. Any clock that started in 1955 was a clock on the fields. That the order reached the house was an insinuation, later read as fact. Per the Buckler case, the woodland of Parcel A was taken in 1955 too, passing to a couple in Llandough and later to the Forest of Cardiff. (SOURCE PENDING: not yet recorded on the wiki.)", "cast": [ "mary", "frederick", "wgr", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts", "forest-of-cardiff" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1955 Possession Order", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1955-possession-order/#order" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1955 Possession Order — enforcement", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1955-possession-order/#enforcement" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Case Analysis — Connections, Patterns and Questions", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/case-analysis-connections-patterns-questions/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0258 — Glamorgan Archives ACA/2, ACA/3 and ACA/6: Cardiff County Court ordinary actions, plaint and minute books and ", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0258-glamorgan-archives-aca-2-3-6-cardiff-county-court-survival-map/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19550202-1" }, { "order": 54, "ref": "III.5", "id": "ghf-19550318-1", "act": "III", "date": "1955-03-18", "when": "18 March 1955", "title": "Leckwith Woods leased to the Forestry Commission", "place": "Leckwith Woods", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "In March 1955 the Western Mail reports that Cardiff holds a 176-acre Leckwith Woods, bought for a nominal sum in 1942, and leases 106 acres to the Forestry Commission for 999 years. Measured against today's boundaries, that wood lies wholly in Leckwith, about 1.2 km from the farmstead, so it is not Great House Farm land.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 2: High Court order against the fields tenant for \"the whole of the farm\" (house not taken; Mary never heard)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The forest taken in 1955 was the farm's own woodland.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"bought … for a nominal sum in 1942\"", "note": "How the Western Mail describes Cardiff's acquisition of Leckwith Woods." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The 1955 lease concerns Cardiff's Leckwith Woods, which measures wholly outside Llandough; the woods near the farm are Coed Creigiaidd and Reservoir Wood.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "nrw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0259 — Western Mail 1955: Leckwith Woods lease; boundary measurement", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0259-leckwith-woods-1955-cardiff-forestry-commission-lease-and-boundary-measure/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19550318-1" }, { "order": 55, "ref": "III.6", "id": "ghf-19580506-1", "act": "III", "date": "1958-05-06", "when": "6 May 1958", "title": "The Leckwith Common inquiry", "place": "Public inquiry into the City of Cardiff (Leckwith Common) order", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "At the inquiry into Cardiff's plan to take Leckwith Common for playing fields, Mrs Mary Doreen Buckler of Great House Farm tells the inspector that she does \"not oppose the proposal so long as it applied only to playing fields\", and that about 130 years ago Lord Bute allowed her family \"a slice of land\" which is now Leckwith Common. The order is confirmed on 8 September 1958 under the Physical Training and Recreation Act 1937, the playing-fields statute. Her words concern Leckwith Common, not Parcel A.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 2: High Court order against the fields tenant for \"the whole of the farm\" (house not taken; Mary never heard)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "She did not oppose Cardiff's plan.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"did not oppose\"", "note": "Cut short, it reads as consent. The full sentence is conditional: \"so long as it applied only to playing fields\"." } ], "what_we_now_know": "VERIFIED (Western Mail OCR, EV-0035; London Gazette, EV-0287). Her statement was conditional on recreational use, the order was made under the playing-fields statute, and it concerned Leckwith Common, not Parcel A.", "cast": [ "mary", "bute" ], "institutions": [ "cardiff-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0035 — Western Mail, 7 May 1958, p.7, \"City wants common for play-field\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0035-western-mail-1958-leckwith-common-hearing/" }, { "type": "Official notice", "title": "EV-0287 — London Gazette, 31 Oct 1958, p.6652: City of Cardiff (Leckwith Common) Compulsory Purchase Order, 1957, confirmed 8 Sep 1958 (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0287-london-gazette-31-oct-1958-p-6652-the-city-of-cardiff-leckwith-common-compulsory-p/" }, { "type": "Official notice", "title": "London Gazette 41537, p.6652 (page PDF)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.thegazette.co.uk%2FLondon%2Fissue%2F41537%2Fpage%2F6652%2Fdata.pdf" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19580506-1" }, { "order": 56, "ref": "III.7", "id": "ghf-19581119-1", "act": "III", "date": "1958-11-19", "when": "19 November 1958", "title": "\"A Welsh case of Crichel Down\"", "place": "Glamorgan County Council planning committee, Cardiff", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams, as Mrs M. D. Buckler, objects to Glamorgan County Council's planning committee about industrial development beside Tŷ Mawr. The Western Mail reports that land \"farmed by her family since 1667\" had been \"wrongfully appropriated\", that \"This is a Welsh case of Crichel Down\", that \"the water was cut off from her house and grounds for nearly 10 years by order of Western Ground Rents\", and that \"The Glamorgan County Council, Penarth Urban and Cardiff Rural Councils and Western Ground Rents have walked in and taken\" (the search text ends there).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 2: High Court order against the fields tenant for \"the whole of the farm\" (house not taken; Mary never heard)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The only record of the time so far that the water was cut off: Mrs Buckler's own claim in 1958, as the Western Mail reported it. It names the landlord, Western Ground Rents, not a council. Crichel Down (1954) was the national scandal over farmland the state kept after requisition; a minister resigned over it. \"Nearly 10 years\" would put the start around 1948–49 (an inference). Per Branwen Buckler (voice testimony, relayed by Sion Buckler, 19 October 2026), the council cut the water over bills it said were unpaid, which Mary (Nancy) Williams insisted had been paid; dairy cattle drowned in the River Ely trying to reach water, a baby daughter had to live elsewhere, and the matter was raised in Parliament. What cuts against that version: the 1958 report names Western Ground Rents, not a council or a water bill; no report of cattle drowning has been found; no Commons or Lords debate or written answer has been found for 1946–92 (committee proceedings and MPs' letters are not searchable this way); and Dŵr Cymru's 2026 replies speak of a disconnection in the 1980s, so there may have been two cut-offs. The article has been read only as search snippets; the full page is still to be obtained.", "cast": [ "mary", "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "glamorgan-county-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Western Mail, 20 November 1958, p.7, \"It's a Crichel Down, says woman farmer\" (SNIPPET ONLY: read from British Newspaper Archive search text; the page itself not yet seen)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk%2Fsearch%2Fresults%2F1950-01-01%2F1965-12-31%3Fbasicsearch%3Dbuckler%2B%2522western%2Bground%2Brents%2522%2Bwater%26exactsearch%3Dfalse%26retrievecountrycounts%3Dfalse" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0037 — Western Mail, 20 Nov 1958: \"Crichel Down\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0037-western-mail-1958-crichel-down/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0239 — TNA BD 28/177: verbatim record of the Glamorgan Development Plan inquiry, 19 Nov–11 Dec 1958 (catalogue entry; not yet read; date match only) (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0239-tna-bd-28-177-glamorgan-development-plan-inquiry-verbatim-1958/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0240 — TNA BD 28/133, BD 28/198, HLG 119/3181, HLG 119/3187, MAF 112/1108: files on the Glamorgan (Area No. 2) plan and the Penarth town map (catalogue entries) (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0240-tna-bd-28-133-hlg-119-maf-112-glamorgan-development-plan-files/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0242 — Western Mail, 9 Oct 1957, p.6: \"Mrs. M. D. BUCKLER … Llandough\" (SNIPPET ONLY; content unknown) (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0242-western-mail-1957-mrs-m-d-buckler-snippet/" }, { "type": "Testimony", "title": "Testimony — Branwen Buckler", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/testimony/branwen-buckler/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19581119-1" }, { "order": 57, "ref": "III.8", "id": "ghf-19590101-1", "act": "III", "date": "1959-01-01", "when": "1959", "title": "1959 tenancy offer", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "Western Ground Rents offers Mary a tenancy of the farmhouse and garden. She refuses, stating that the house is hers through her grandfather and that documents prove it.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 3: tenancy of her own farmhouse and garden offered to Mary (refused)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "The landlord offered the occupier a tenancy, and she refused it.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the farmhouse and garden\"", "note": "The landlord's description of what it offered to let." } ], "what_we_now_know": "\"The farmhouse and garden\" is Parcel A (farmhouse, buildings, yard and garden), less the woodland to the north and the land to the south already taken. The landlord named the house parcel on its own, which shows it knew it was separate. An owner does not need its occupier to accept a tenancy. Third attempt to make her occupation look permissive.", "cast": [ "mary", "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1962 Possession Order — 1959 refusal", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/#refusal-1959" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19590101-1" }, { "order": 58, "ref": "III.9", "id": "ghf-19610329-2", "act": "III", "date": "1961-03-29", "when": "29 March 1961", "title": "The 1961 deed", "place": "Woodland (later title WA735527)", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Deed", "narration": "Western Ground Rents, South Western Brick & Tile Co Ltd and Cardiff City Corporation sign a deed with a plan. The woodland register WA735527 later recites it against land coloured pink, now in the woodland title. The deed and plan have not yet been seen, so what land it touches and what it did are not known. It is not a Buckler family sale.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 3: tenancy of her own farmhouse and garden offered to Mary (refused)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A deed of 1961 is part of how the woodland left the farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"deed\"", "note": "Known only from a recital on the woodland register. The deed itself has not been seen." } ], "what_we_now_know": "PENDING (EV-0040). Parties: Western Ground Rents, South Western Brick & Tile Co Ltd, Cardiff City Corporation. Land and effect unknown until the deed and plan are read.", "cast": [ "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Deed", "title": "EV-0040 — Deed with plan between WGR, South Western Brick & Tile and Cardiff City Corporation, 29 March 1961 (recited on WA735527; not yet held) (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0040-1961-wgr-brick-tile-deed/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19610329-2" }, { "order": 59, "ref": "III.10", "id": "ghf-19621211-1", "act": "III", "date": "1962-12-11", "when": "11 December 1962", "title": "The 1962 possession order", "place": "Cardiff County Court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 11 December 1962 Cardiff County Court (Judge Temple Morris QC) orders possession of the farmhouse and garden, with mesne profits from 1955, against Frederick and Mary, in Western Ground Rents' action. The order is not enforced.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 4: county court possession order for the farmhouse and garden, treating Mary as holding over (no deed proven; never enforced)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "The court confirmed the landlord's right to the house in 1962, and that order kept the landlord's title alive.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the farmhouse and garden\"", "note": "Again named on its own." }, { "said": "\"mesne profits since 1955\"", "note": "Money for occupation, as if the house had been the landlord's since 1955." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A possession order, not a decision on title. It treated Mary as holding over from a tenancy she was never in. No deed to the house was proved, because Western Ground Rents had none. It was left unenforced, and in 1987 it was used to stop the clock. Fourth attempt.", "cast": [ "mary", "frederick", "wgr", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1962 Possession Order", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/#order" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — deeds before registration (29 March 1961 deed)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#deeds-before-registration" }, { "type": "Parliamentary record", "title": "EV-0261 — Hansard, 29 January and 5 February 1963 (with 14 November 1946): Western Ground Rents Ltd and ministers: a WGR", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0261-hansard-1963-western-ground-rents-ministers/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19610329-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19621211-1" }, { "order": 60, "ref": "III.11", "id": "ghf-19630601-1", "act": "III", "date": "1963-06-01", "when": "June 1963", "title": "Committal proceedings", "place": "Cardiff County Court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "The mesne profits under the 1962 order are partly enforced against Frederick, and committal proceedings follow.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 4: county court possession order for the farmhouse and garden, treating Mary as holding over (no deed proven; never enforced)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A tenant in arrears was pursued for the money.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The money was enforced; possession of the house was not.", "cast": [ "frederick" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1962 Possession Order — committal", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/#committal" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19630101-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19630601-1" }, { "order": 61, "ref": "III.12", "id": "ghf-19650301-1", "act": "III", "date": "1965-03-02", "when": "January – March 1965", "title": "1965 tenancy offer", "place": "Landlords' agents", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Document", "narration": "On 2 March 1965 the landlord's agents offer \"Mrs Williams\" a weekly tenancy of the farmhouse and garden at £2 a week. It is not signed or returned and no rent is paid.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 5: weekly tenancy offered to \"Mrs Williams\" (not signed; her occupation now treated as adverse)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "Another offer refused by an occupier with no title.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Mrs Williams\"", "note": "Offered as to a tenant." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The same offer as 1959. The estate's own records treat her occupation as adverse from this date. Fifth attempt. An owner holding a deed would sue on it; Western Ground Rents never did.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1965 offer", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/#offer-1965" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams — 1965 offer", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams/#chronology" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19650301-1" }, { "order": 62, "ref": "III.13", "id": "ghf-19640101-1", "act": "III", "date": "1965-06-01", "when": "1964 – 68", "title": "Reported sale by the eldest son", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Source pending", "narration": "A cousin's account states that the eldest son sold \"our land parcel\" through a solicitor without his parents' knowledge. No document has been found. In 1968 his household leaves the farm.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 5: weekly tenancy offered to \"Mrs Williams\" (not signed; her occupation now treated as adverse)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents (fields taken 4 July 1955)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "What was sold, if anything, is unknown.", "cast": [ "eldest" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family — rumoured sale", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19680901-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19640101-1" }, { "order": 63, "ref": "III.14", "id": "ghf-19670101-1", "act": "III", "date": "1967-01-01", "when": "1967", "title": "Death of Frederick Buckler", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Source pending", "narration": "Frederick Buckler dies, aged 58; his death is registered in the first quarter of 1967 (GRO death index, East Glamorgan 8b 364). Mary takes back the name Williams and remains in the farmhouse.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 5: weekly tenancy offered to \"Mrs Williams\" (not signed; her occupation now treated as adverse)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "The tenant died; his widow stayed on.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"widow\"", "note": "As though her right in the house came through him." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The only tenant there had ever been, of the fields, died. Mary remained the owner in occupation of Parcel A.", "cast": [ "mary", "frederick" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Frederick Buckler — death", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/frederick-buckler/#death" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19670101-1" }, { "order": 64, "ref": "IV.1", "id": "ghf-19690215-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1969-02-15", "when": "15 February 1969", "title": "BP bids for Western Ground Rents", "place": "London", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "British Petroleum makes an agreed bid for the whole of Western Ground Rents Ltd, wanting its \"shops, offices, houses in London and South Wales — for their pension fund\", after rival bids from Amalgamated Investment & Property and Great Portland Estates. The December 1969 sale of the farm to BP Pension Trust follows.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 5: weekly tenancy offered to \"Mrs Williams\" (not signed; her occupation now treated as adverse)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold and possession: Western Ground Rents" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "From 1969 the landlord that brought the 1955 and 1962 actions and the buyer of the farm were in the same group.", "cast": [ "wgr", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0288 — Press on the 1968–69 takeover contest for Western Ground Rents Ltd (snippets)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0288-snippets-only-press-on-the-1968-69-takeover-battle-for-western-ground-rents-ltd-en/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19690215-1" }, { "order": 65, "ref": "IV.2", "id": "ghf-19691231-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1969-12-31", "when": "31 December 1969", "title": "Conveyance to BP Pension Trust", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "In February 1969 British Petroleum agrees to buy the whole of Western Ground Rents for its pension fund. On 31 December 1969 Western Ground Rents conveys Parcel B, and an interest in the 1962 order on Parcel A, to BP Pension Trust Ltd. The 1987 judgment calls it a sale of \"Great House Farm, including the farmhouse and garden\"; no deed to Parcel A has been found. The conveyance is not on the Land Registry files.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel B: the fields", "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "BP bought Great House Farm. This deed is the root of BP's title.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Great House Farm\"", "note": "One estate, in one phrase." }, { "said": "\"root of title\"", "note": "How BP's later deeds recite it." } ], "what_we_now_know": "By deed, Parcel B passed (Bute, Western Ground Rents, BP). For Parcel A there was no deed to pass; what passed was the 1962 order and the case against Mary. The root deed is now missing.", "cast": [ "wgr", "bp", "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — conveyances", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#conveyances" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0288 — Press snippets, Nov 1968 – Feb 1969: BP buys Western Ground Rents for its pension fund (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0288-snippets-only-press-on-the-1968-69-takeover-battle-for-western-ground-rents-ltd-en/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19691231-1" }, { "order": 66, "ref": "IV.3", "id": "ghf-19710101-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1971-01-01", "when": "1971", "title": "The 1971 abstract of title", "place": "BP Pension Trust", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "An abstract of title is prepared for BP Pension Trust. In 2026 HM Land Registry writes that an abstract \"dated 1971 was lodged with the application for first registration\" of WA231076, and that for WA240304 \"we had sight of a copy of a 1971 abstract of title\". It is not listed among the surviving records, and its contents are not held.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The 1971 abstract was the paper on which both first registrations rested; HM Land Registry no longer lists it among the surviving file items.", "cast": [ "bp", "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "HM Land Registry correspondence — letter of 19 April 2026 (M39)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/hm-land-registry-correspondence/#m39" }, { "type": "Evidence catalogue", "title": "EV-0045 — HM Land Registry letter, 19 April 2026", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/artifacts/#EV-0045" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19710101-1" }, { "order": 67, "ref": "IV.4", "id": "ghf-19710101-2", "act": "IV", "date": "1971-01-02", "when": "1971", "title": "A name on the map", "place": "Ordnance Survey sheet, Llandough", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Map", "narration": "On the Ordnance Survey's earlier sheets the name is \"Ty-mawr\", printed just east of the farm buildings, towards the fields: on the 25-inch map of about 1900 and again on the six-inch National Grid map of 1949–70. Neither adds \"Farm\". A year later planning permission is granted for about thirteen houses at the farm.", "family_case": "The family's account: in 1971 the name moved off the eastern fields (Parcel B) onto the house plot (Parcel A) and became \"Great House Farm\", so that one name on the map covered house and fields alike — a year before the 1972 permission and three years before the 1974 attempt to remove Mary. The 1971 sheet itself (1:2,500 ST 1673–1773; six-inch ST 17 SE) is the record that shows where the name went. Trade directories already wrote \"Great House farm\" from 1887.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A routine map revision.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Great House Farm\"", "note": "The name the farm had carried in directories since the 1880s." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Before 1971 the Ordnance Survey printed \"Ty-mawr\" beside the buildings on the side of the eastern fields. The family's account is that the 1971 revision moved the name onto the house plot and added \"Farm\". The 1971 sheet will show it.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Map", "title": "National Library of Scotland, georeferenced Ordnance Survey maps: 25-inch County Series (Glamorgan XLVII.6, c. 1900) and six-inch National Grid (ST 17 SE, 1949–70); \"Ty-mawr\" east of the farm buildings on both", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fmaps.nls.uk%2Fgeo%2Fexplore%2F" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Name & Location Variations", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/great-house-farm/name-variations/" }, { "type": "Planning file", "title": "EV-0046 — Outline planning permission 3/8996/3337 for about 13 houses (1972)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0046-1972-outline-planning-permission-ownership-certificate/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19710101-2" }, { "order": 68, "ref": "IV.5", "id": "ghf-19720101-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1972-01-01", "when": "1972 (re-notified 9 December 1985)", "title": "Cwm Cydfin SSSI", "place": "Cwm Cydfin, Leckwith", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "Cwm Cydfin, the wooded valley at Leckwith, is notified as a Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI 0524). It is re-notified on 9 December 1985.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · woodland: per the Buckler case, taken in 1955 (SOURCE PENDING: not yet on the wiki)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The SSSI notification file would list the owners and occupiers notified in 1972 and 1985; that list has not been seen.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0218 — Cwm Cydfin SSSI 0524: citation and boundary", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0218-cwm-cydfin-sssi-0524-citation-and-boundary/" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0221 — NRW SSSI 0524 notification file", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0221-nrw-sssi-0524-notification-file/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19720101-1" }, { "order": 69, "ref": "IV.6", "id": "ghf-19720725-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1972-07-25", "when": "1970 – 72", "title": "Village green and planning permission", "place": "Planning office", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "On 16 June 1970 land beside Leckwith Road is provisionally registered as village green VG41 (the date stamped on the VG 41 provisional register map). On 25 July 1972 planning permission is granted for housing on the site, while Mary lives in the farmhouse.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · land beside Leckwith Road provisionally registered as village green VG41 (16 June 1970)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "Ordinary planning of an under-used farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the site\"", "note": "Both parcels treated as one development site." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Permission was granted over a house whose ownership was disputed, while its owner lived in it. In 1990 a condition of the outline permission provided for a 0.25-acre village green beside the site. Per the Buckler case, the land south of the farmhouse, part of Parcel A, was taken by the council and laid out as a green in the 1980s. (SOURCE PENDING: not yet recorded on the wiki.)", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Master Timeline", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/timeline/" }, { "type": "Legislation", "title": "Commons Registration (Glamorgan) Act 1983 (c. ix): validates the registers of common land only; village greens are not covered", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.legislation.gov.uk%2Fukla%2F1983%2F9" }, { "type": "Legislation", "title": "EV-0232 — Commons Registration (Glamorgan) Act 1983: common land registers only (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0232-commons-registration-glamorgan-act-1983/" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0263 — Commons Registration Act 1965 s.5 and SI 1968/989: registrations were publicised by public notice only; Glamor", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0263-commons-registration-1965-publicity-glamorgan-notices-vg41/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19700616-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19720725-1" }, { "order": 70, "ref": "IV.7", "id": "ghf-19720731-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1972-07-31", "when": "31 July 1972", "title": "Village green objections close", "place": "Leckwith Road, Llandough", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "The second objection period under the Commons Registration Act 1965 ends. It covers VG41, the land by Leckwith Road provisionally registered as a village green on 16 June 1970. Notice of the registration is given to the public; no personal notice to the occupiers of the farm is required.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · land beside Leckwith Road provisionally registered as village green VG41 (16 June 1970)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "VG41's objection window closed with public notice only; whether the occupiers of the farmhouse ever knew of it is not recorded.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0263 — Commons registration 1965: publicity and Glamorgan notices (VG41)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0263-commons-registration-1965-publicity-glamorgan-notices-vg41/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19720731-1" }, { "order": 71, "ref": "IV.8", "id": "ghf-19740415-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-04-15", "when": "15 April 1974", "title": "Open day", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 15 April 1974 Mary opens the farmhouse to the public. The Daily Telegraph reports her saying ownership has been disputed for 25 years and her solicitors tell her she has a valid case.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · land beside Leckwith Road provisionally registered as village green VG41 (16 June 1970)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A campaign to save an old building.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"valid claim\"", "note": "Reported as a claim, not a title." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A woman of sixty, who had lost a leg, opened her home to the nation. Hundreds came. A thousand signed. She told a national newspaper the house was hers. The public stood with Mary. It changed nothing.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Daily Telegraph, 16 April 1974, 'Open day to save ancient Welsh house'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n03", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n03-1974-open-day-telegraph.jpg" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#action" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n03-1974-open-day-telegraph.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19740415-1" }, { "order": 72, "ref": "IV.9", "id": "ghf-19740101-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-04-26", "when": "26 April 1974", "title": "Royal Commission survey", "place": "Great House — interior", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "Ten days after the open day, H. J. Thomas of the Royal Commission measures the ground floor; his plan is dated 26 April 1974. The Commission's 1988 report records that the house \"was surveyed in unusual circumstances in 1974\", that \"much detail was then concealed\", that \"it was not possible to examine the first floor and roof trusses\", and that it \"remained partially recorded because of problems of access created by an ownership dispute\". The upper floor and roof, where the dating evidence lay, are never seen.", "family_case": "The family's reading: Mary had opened her doors to the public that month to save the house, so the access problem came from the paper owner, not from her. A full record of a sub-medieval house would have strengthened the case for its protection. The Commission's file holds no correspondence that shows who limited access.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold: the Williamses (Mary in the house) · land beside Leckwith Road provisionally registered as village green VG41 (16 June 1970)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A routine, incomplete survey.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "A public body recorded in 1974 that the ownership of the house was disputed.", "cast": [ "mary", "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "RCAHMW reply RC26-0375, 29 September 2026, quoting the unpublished 1988 report (archive 6048945) — wiki page", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/rcahmw-correspondence/" }, { "type": "Evidence catalogue", "title": "GHF-E137 — 1974 H. J. Thomas / RCAHMW architectural survey and floor plan", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/ghf-e137-1974-h-j-thomas-rcahmw-architectural-survey-and-floor-plan/" }, { "type": "Evidence catalogue", "title": "GHF-E183 — Heneb / HER source-file request and replies, September–October 2026", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/ghf-e183-heneb-her-source-file-request-and-replies-september-october-2026/" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19740101-1" }, { "order": 73, "ref": "IV.10", "id": "ghf-19740703-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-07-03", "when": "3 July 1974", "title": "1974 possession action", "place": "County court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "BP Pension Trust brings a county court action for possession. On 3 July 1974 the case is part heard and adjourned for a formal defence to be filed; Mary's defence then pleads that the action is barred under the Limitation Act 1939. Her statement describes the 1877 sale. The case is never relisted.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "An action that went nowhere.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"part-heard\"", "note": "Treated afterwards as if nothing had been decided because nothing needed deciding." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The only time Mary's title to Parcel A was put before a court. It was never decided, and so never extinguished. Her statement set out the two parcels; no lawyer of hers ever built a case on it.", "cast": [ "mary", "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters — the action", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#action" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19740703-1" }, { "order": 74, "ref": "IV.11", "id": "ghf-19740919-2", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-09-19", "when": "17 – 19 September 1974", "title": "The 1962 order revived", "place": "Cardiff County Court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "BP Pension Trust's own action is still waiting for Mary's defence. On 17 September 1974 it gives notice that it will ask, \"as successors in title to Western Ground Rents\", to enforce the twelve-year-old possession order of 11 December 1962. Two days later Judge Watkin Powell gives leave: the warrant is to issue at once but not be enforced until 31 October 1974. On 30 October Mary's solicitors appeal: she \"had had insufficient notice of the application and therefore had had no opportunity of presenting her case\".", "family_case": "The 12 years from the 1962 order would run out on 11 December 1974. The family's case is that the order was revived on two days' notice to beat that date, while BP Pension Trust's fresh action, which put the same question, was left unheard.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The owner enforced a court order it already held.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"successors in title\"", "note": "How BP Pension Trust described itself to the court." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A twelve-year-old order, never enforced, was revived seven weeks before the twelve years ran out, while BP Pension Trust's own action on the same question waited unheard. Mary's appeal said she had no chance to put her case.", "cast": [ "mary", "wgr", "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1962 Possession Order", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters — the action", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#action" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19740919-2" }, { "order": 75, "ref": "IV.12", "id": "ghf-19741015-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-10-15", "when": "Autumn 1974", "title": "Mary", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "Mary is 61, a widow since Frederick's death, a pensioner, living in the farmhouse where she was born in 1913. After the order is revived, a press campaign starts in South Wales, with some support on television. The Court of Appeal later records how the papers describe her: \"an elderly widow, confined to a wheelchair, who was being thrown out of the cottage her family had occupied for centuries, so that the historic cottage could be bulldozed to the ground and developers could build executive houses on the site.\"", "family_case": "The family's account: Mary was an amputee. By 1974 the north and south thirds of her parcel had gone, and the house with its garden was the last third she held, against two companies of one of the largest groups in the country.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Held by BP Pension Trust: the 1962 order and the case against Mary (no deed to Parcel A; the 1969 root conveyance now missing)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "An old lady who had to move on.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"elderly widow, confined to a wheelchair\"", "note": "The press, autumn 1974, as recorded by the Court of Appeal." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A widowed pensioner of 61, born in the house, holding the last of her family's land against a pension fund and a property company.", "cast": [ "mary", "frederick", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#letters" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19741015-1" }, { "order": 76, "ref": "IV.13", "id": "ghf-19741031-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-10-31", "when": "31 October 1974", "title": "The licence letters", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "Two letters are dated Thursday 31 October 1974, the day the hold on the warrant runs out. BP Pension Trust writes that the bailiff's instructions \"have been withdrawn\" and that her stay application \"becomes unnecessary\", because BP Properties \"have agreed to buy the property\". BP Properties writes that it will \"allow you to remain in occupation of the house and garden rent free for as long as you may wish and for the rest of your life\", adding: \"I do hope that by making this gesture you will accept the situation.\" Both are addressed to \"Mrs Williams\", but neither is sent to her: both go to her solicitor. BP Properties does not yet own the house; the purchase completes on 23 May 1975.", "family_case": "The family's account: Mary had sought an audience with the judge because BP had crossed a line; the court clerk called the press and two articles followed; the letters were backdated.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 6: BP's \"licence\" letters to Mary, 31 October 1974 (never accepted); 1962 warrant withdrawn before 25 November 1974", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "BP kindly let an elderly, ill woman stay in the house rent free.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"licence\"", "note": "BP's letters, as the courts later described them." }, { "said": "\"because of her ill health\"", "note": "BP's explanation to the press in 1988." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A woman in a wheelchair, who had lost a leg, was told by an oil company's pension fund that she could stay in her own house under licence. She never asked for it. She never accepted it. It arrived while her claim to own the house stood undecided before the county court. Thirteen years later the Court of Appeal relied on it to give BP possession.", "cast": [ "mary", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#letters" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters — the warrant", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#warrant" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19741031-2", "ghf-19740919-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19741031-1" }, { "order": 77, "ref": "IV.14", "id": "ghf-19741104-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-11-04", "when": "Monday 4 November 1974", "title": "Monday 4 November", "place": "Cardiff County Court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "Her solicitor receives the letters \"on the morning of November 4, immediately before he made his application\". The landlords' solicitors do not attend. The judge stays the warrant \"pending Mrs Buckler's agreement to the proposals in the letters\". Her solicitor telephones her and asks for instructions. \"Before she had given any instructions, however,\" the landlords' solicitors write to the court \"at some date prior to November 25 1974\" and withdraw the warrant. The Court of Appeal's conclusion: \"Mrs Buckler therefore never expressly accepted or rejected the terms of the two letters.\"", "family_case": "Dated on a Thursday, received on the Monday morning minutes before the hearing, and withdrawn before she could answer: the family's case is that Mary was given no time to respond, and that the order was dropped the same day the offer was made.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 6: BP's \"licence\" letters to Mary, 31 October 1974 (never accepted); 1962 warrant withdrawn before 25 November 1974", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The case was settled amicably.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"pending Mrs Buckler's agreement\"", "note": "The terms of the judge's stay." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The letters arrived minutes before the hearing; the landlords stayed away; the warrant was withdrawn before Mary had given her solicitor any instructions. The court itself recorded that she never accepted.", "cast": [ "mary", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters — the warrant", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#warrant" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19741104-1" }, { "order": 78, "ref": "IV.15", "id": "ghf-19741119-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-11-19", "when": "19 November, 1970s (year unclear)", "title": "Letter to the Western Mail", "place": "Western Mail — letters", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "A letter to the Western Mail, dated 19 November (year unclear), traces the land's descent.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 6: BP's \"licence\" letters to Mary, 31 October 1974 (never accepted); 1962 warrant withdrawn before 25 November 1974", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A local antiquarian's objection.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The chain of title and the site's importance were in print before the demolition.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Western Mail, 'Grievous loss' (letter)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n04", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n03-n04-1974-open-day-and-grievous-loss-page.jpg" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Restoration Campaign", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/restoration-campaign/#open-day-1974" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19741119-1" }, { "order": 79, "ref": "IV.16", "id": "ghf-19741125-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1974-11-25", "when": "November 1974 onward", "title": "Mary's answer", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "Mary pays no rent and stays in the house until her death in March 1983. In 1987 the Court of Appeal accepts that she did not accept: \"BP Properties Ltd neither sought nor waited for her acceptance.\" It still holds that, \"in the absence of any repudiation\", \"whether she liked it or not\", her possession ceased to be adverse from the day the letters arrived. It adds: \"It may be that the result would have been different if Mrs Buckler had, as soon as she learned of the letters, plainly told BP Properties Ltd that she did not accept the letters ... she did not, however, do that.\" This one-sided licence is the point the family disputes.", "family_case": "The family's account: Mary wrote back rejecting the letters; it has been family testimony ever since, and it may be recorded in William Buckler's diaries. She had said publicly in April 1974 that her solicitors told her she had a valid case, and she went on acting as owner of the house. Not answering an offer is not accepting it.", "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Attempt 6: BP's \"licence\" letters to Mary, 31 October 1974 (never accepted); 1962 warrant withdrawn before 25 November 1974", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Mary accepted a licence and lived rent free as BP's licensee.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"in the absence of any repudiation\"", "note": "The Court of Appeal, 1987." }, { "said": "\"whether she liked it or not\"", "note": "The Court of Appeal, 1987." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The court agreed she never accepted the letters, and still treated them as binding on her. A written rejection sent to BP would have met the exact point the court said might have changed the result.", "cast": [ "mary", "billy", "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#letters" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19741125-1" }, { "order": 80, "ref": "IV.17", "id": "ghf-19750523-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1975-05-23", "when": "23 May 1975", "title": "The 1975 conveyance", "place": "BP Pension Trust / BP Properties", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 23 May 1975 BP Pension Trust conveys property at Great House Farm, with a plan, to BP Properties Ltd. The Court of Appeal later calls it \"the actual conveyance of the farmhouse and garden\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: conveyance BP Pension Trust → BP Properties of \"the farmhouse and garden\" (no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "An internal transfer within the BP group.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the actual conveyance of the farmhouse and garden\"", "note": "Court of Appeal, 1987." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A conveyance of Parcel A between two BP companies, while Mary lived in it and claimed it, with no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it. It shows BP treated the house as a separate parcel. From here the synthetic Parcel A has a deed.", "cast": [ "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — conveyances", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#conveyances" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19750523-1" }, { "order": 81, "ref": "IV.18", "id": "ghf-19751201-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1975-12-01", "when": "1 December 1975", "title": "Compulsory registration begins", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "From 1 December 1975 a sale of land in the Vale of Glamorgan must be registered at HM Land Registry. The 1969 and May 1975 conveyances come before this date; the November 1982 sale of the fields falls after it and is lodged within eleven days. The February 1983 application for the farmhouse was most likely voluntary.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: conveyance BP Pension Trust → BP Properties of \"the farmhouse and garden\" (no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Every transfer of the farm had to be registered at once.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Registration became compulsory in the Vale only on 1 December 1975, so the earlier conveyances were not void for want of registration. The Gazette notice series ended about May 1975, so the absence of a 1982–83 notice is not evidence of concealment.", "cast": [ "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0265 — Compulsory registration 1 Dec 1975; solicitor’s certificate; Gazette notices", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0265-hmlr-registration-background-compulsory-1975-r29-certificate/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19751201-1" }, { "order": 82, "ref": "IV.19", "id": "ghf-19800522-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1980-05-22", "when": "22 May 1980", "title": "Hansard", "place": "House of Commons", "parcel": "", "basis": "Parliament", "narration": "On 22 May 1980 Ted Rowlands MP tells the House of Commons that Western Ground Rents, \"the most rapacious ground landlord\" in South Wales, has been bought by the BP pension fund.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: conveyance BP Pension Trust → BP Properties of \"the farmhouse and garden\" (no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Western Ground Rents, which brought the 1955 and 1962 actions, and BP, which relied on them, were by 1980 the same group.", "cast": [ "wgr", "bp", "mps" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Hansard, 22 May 1980", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n16", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n16-1980-hansard-rowlands.jpg" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n16-1980-hansard-rowlands.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19800522-1" }, { "order": 83, "ref": "IV.20", "id": "ghf-19810207-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1981-02-07", "when": "7 February 1981", "title": "Ground rents sold", "place": "South Wales", "parcel": "", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "BP Pension Trust sells its residential freehold ground rents in South Wales to Cefn Estates.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: conveyance BP Pension Trust → BP Properties of \"the farmhouse and garden\" (no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "BP Pension Trust kept the Great House Farm land when it sold its South Wales ground rents in 1981.", "cast": [ "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0289 — BP Pension Trust in South Wales, 1981–83: sale of its residential ground rents (snippets)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0289-snippets-only-bp-pension-trust-in-south-wales-1981-83-sale-of-its-residential-grou/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19810207-1" }, { "order": 84, "ref": "IV.21", "id": "ghf-19821001-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1982-10-01", "when": "1 October 1982", "title": "GGAT advice", "place": "GGAT", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "On 1 October 1982 GGAT advises the planners that occupation may continue in the area and asks for investigation before development.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: conveyance BP Pension Trust → BP Properties of \"the farmhouse and garden\" (no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Freehold: BP Pension Trust (Bute → WGR → BP, by deed)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Routine archaeological advice.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The warning that came true in 1994.", "cast": [ "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Neath Guardian, 17 April 1980 (Roman villa, a separate site)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n05" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 18 March 1983 — burnt relics (Roman villa finds, a separate site)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n06", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n06-1983-echo-burnt-relics.jpg" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19780101-1", "ghf-press-19800417-n05", "ghf-19830313-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19821001-1" }, { "order": 85, "ref": "IV.22", "id": "ghf-19821119-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1982-11-19", "when": "19 – 30 November 1982", "title": "First registration", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 30 November 1982 Linklaters & Paines apply to register BP Properties as owner of the land, title WA231076. Mary is living in the farmhouse.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: conveyance BP Pension Trust → BP Properties of \"the farmhouse and garden\" (no earlier deed to Parcel A behind it)", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel B: the fields" ], "received_account": "BP registered the land it owned.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"registered proprietor\"", "note": "The status the courts later relied on." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Nothing on the file shows the occupier being asked what she claimed.", "cast": [ "mary", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — first registration", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "1982–83 Registration & Opportunity to Object", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/procedural-fairness-notice/1982-83-registration-opportunity-to-object/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19821119-1" }, { "order": 86, "ref": "IV.23", "id": "ghf-19830223-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1983-02-23", "when": "23 February 1983", "title": "Farmhouse title", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 23 February 1983 BP's solicitors apply to register the farmhouse and garden as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance, certifying they know of no question or doubt affecting the title.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claimed by Mary, in occupation · ownership pleaded in her defence after the 3 July 1974 adjournment (never decided)", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [ "Synthetic Parcel A" ], "received_account": "A routine second registration.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"no question or doubt\"", "note": "The solicitors' certificate." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The synthetic Parcel A became a registered title. The certificate was given while the owner who had pleaded ownership in 1974 lived in the house. The Land Registry now held the fields and the house as two titles: it knew they were two.", "cast": [ "bp" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — first registration", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19830223-1" }, { "order": 87, "ref": "IV.24", "id": "ghf-19830326-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1983-03-26", "when": "26 March 1983", "title": "Death of Mary (Nancy) Williams", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Source pending", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams dies in the farmhouse on 26 March 1983. Her son William inherits her estate.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "The licensee died and the licence ended.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"licensee\"", "note": "How BP would describe her." } ], "what_we_now_know": "She died in the house she was born in, aged sixty-nine, still saying it was hers. She never signed a tenancy, never accepted a licence, and was never once heard on whether the house was her own.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams — death", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams/#death" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family — William", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19830326-1" }, { "order": 88, "ref": "IV.25", "id": "ghf-19830408-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1983-04-08", "when": "8 April – 12 May 1983", "title": "Registration correspondence", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 8 and 12 April and 12 May 1983 Linklaters and the Land Registry exchange letters on the farmhouse file, including form D23.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Routine registration correspondence.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "What the Registry asked about the occupiers, and what it was told, is in these letters. The family have asked for them.", "cast": [ "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — first registration", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19830408-1" }, { "order": 89, "ref": "IV.26", "id": "ghf-19831026-1", "act": "IV", "date": "1983-10-26", "when": "26 October 1983", "title": "Conservation reports", "place": "Llandough", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The South Wales Echo reports that the Community Council and the Vale planners have Great House Farm in view in their conservation reports as a notable building. No listing or decision follows.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The house was named as a notable building in 1983, five years before the listing decision of December 1988.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "llandough-community-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0072 — South Wales Echo, 26 October 1983, p.9 (conservation)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0072-south-wales-echo-1983-conservation/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19831026-1" }, { "order": 90, "ref": "V.1", "id": "ghf-19840522-1", "act": "V", "date": "1984-05-22", "when": "1984", "title": "The writ", "place": "BP Properties", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 22 May 1984 BP Properties issues a writ for possession of Great House Farm and adjoining land against William Buckler. The defence relies on adverse possession from 1955.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "BP, the owner, sued to recover its land from a squatter.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Great House Farm and adjoining land\"", "note": "The writ's description." }, { "said": "\"adverse possession\"", "note": "The only defence argued." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The house was wrapped back into \"the farm\" a year after BP registered it separately. BP asked for possession, not a declaration of ownership. The defence fought on BP's map: adverse possession of a synthetic farm whose real owner's title was to Parcel B only, with the clock counted from 1955, when the family's title to Parcel A dated from 1928 and by possession from 1940. In the same year the library copy of the 1877 deed was reported missing.", "cast": [ "billy", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — the writ", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#writ" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — library copy missing", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#library-1984" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19840113-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19840522-1" }, { "order": 91, "ref": "V.2", "id": "ghf-19860710-1", "act": "V", "date": "1986-07-10", "when": "10 – 24 July 1986", "title": "High Court hearing and judgment", "place": "High Court, Cardiff", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 10 July 1986 the case is heard before Mr Justice Hollis in the High Court at Cardiff. On 24 July 1986 he gives judgment for BP, holding that the 1974 letters gave Mary a licence.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The court found that BP owned the house and the family were there by BP's permission.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"licence\"", "note": "The finding." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The court decided possession. The question of who owned Parcel A was not put to it, and the 1877, 1928 and 1939 documents were not before it.", "cast": [ "mary", "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — High Court", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#high-court" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "BP v Buckler: Scope, Decided & Undecided", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/court-judicial-issues/bp-v-buckler-scope-decided-undecided/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19860710-1" }, { "order": 92, "ref": "V.3", "id": "ghf-19860711-1", "act": "V", "date": "1986-07-11", "when": "1986 – 87", "title": "Royal Commission correspondence", "place": "Royal Commission (RCAHMW)", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "During the trial and appeal, the Royal Commission's correspondence with Mrs Buckler goes missing.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Synthetic Parcel A": "Paper: registered as a separate title, WA240304, on the 1975 conveyance (\"no question or doubt\")", "Parcel B: the fields": "Registered: BP Properties, main title WA231076 (applied 30 November 1982)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "A record of Mary's own account to a public body was lost while the case was live.", "cast": [ "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — the loss pattern", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/#loss-pattern" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19860711-1" }, { "order": 93, "ref": "V.4", "id": "ghf-19870202-1", "act": "V", "date": "1987-02-02", "when": "2 February 1987", "title": "Amalgamation of titles", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 2 February 1987, while the appeal is pending, an application is made to amalgamate WA240304 (the separately registered farmhouse and garden) into WA231076 (the larger field title). The register then presents the two strands as one corporate holding. The affirmative 'synthetic estate' question is whether a title originating in the Bute-to-WGR field chain was joined to a separately registered house title without the older Cydwin/Cydfin and Williams/Thomas chain being traced through the underlying instruments. The amalgamation records a registration event; its file, the 1877 documents, and the 1938 and 1969 conveyances must be read together to reconstruct the title's provenance.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim passes to Billy Buckler, in occupation · never decided, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Registered: BP Properties, WA231076 = Parcel B + synthetic Parcel A (farmhouse title folded in, 2 February 1987)" }, "title_moves": [ "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"" ], "received_account": "An administrative tidying of the register.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"amalgamation\"", "note": "The register's term." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The registration history shows two separately registered titles before the 1987 amalgamation: a larger field title and a later house title. The affirmative synthetic-estate thesis is that a corporate register view was assembled from separate strands while the older Cydwin/Cydfin and Williams/Thomas provenance remained untraced. The decisive exercise is to compare the first-registration files and the operative 1877, 1938 and 1969 instruments against the plans and schedules. The label 'synthetic' describes this unresolved reconstruction, not a statutory finding.", "cast": [ "bute", "wgr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — amalgamation", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "1987 HMLR Amalgamation During Appeal", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/procedural-fairness-notice/1987-hmlr-amalgamation-during-appeal/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Cydfin / Ty Mawr and pre-1877 manorial evidence", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/anomalies-register/llandough-penarth-cydfin-ty-mawr-manorial-evidence/" }, { "type": "Research annex", "title": "Cedwyn Estate — title-chain reconstruction", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/research/cedwyn-estate-title-chain.html" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19870202-1" }, { "order": 94, "ref": "V.5", "id": "ghf-19870731-1", "act": "V", "date": "1987-07-31", "when": "31 July 1987", "title": "Court of Appeal", "place": "Court of Appeal, London", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 31 July 1987 the Court of Appeal (Dillon LJ, Mustill LJ, Sir Edward Eveleigh) dismisses the appeal in BP Properties Ltd v Buckler. It finds adverse possession from 1955, but holds that the 1962 action stopped time and the 1974 letters made the possession permissive.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"" ], "received_account": "The courts finally settled that BP owned Great House Farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the paper title to the farm\"", "note": "The court's description of BP's position." }, { "said": "\"No such documents were, however, ever produced.\"", "note": "On Mary's title documents." }, { "said": "\"since November 1982 they have been the registered proprietors\"", "note": "The court's recital." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The court decided possession, not ownership. It counted the clock from 1955, from an order about the fields; counted from 1928, it had run out in 1940. BP's paper title was to the fields; for the house it had only a deed between two BP companies, which the court itself called the conveyance of the farmhouse and garden. Mary's documents were not produced because they had been taken from her. The family lost in the High Court, lost on appeal, and were refused by the Lords. Every defeat was on who may live in the house. Nobody ever asked who owned it.", "cast": [ "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — what it omits", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#omits" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0267 — Companies House 01379651: the appellant’s solicitors’ service company was “John Loosemore & Co. Services” unti", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0267-john-loosemore-co-loosemores-services-01379651/" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0274 — Probate calendar 1991: “BUCKLER, William Beverley … of Penarth … died 29 April 1990”, administration granted a", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0274-probate-calendar-1991-william-beverley-buckler/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0079 — South Wales Echo, 6 May 1987, front page: the dispute between the High Court judgment and the appeal", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0079-south-wales-echo-1987-may/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19870731-1" }, { "order": 95, "ref": "V.6", "id": "ghf-19871217-1", "act": "V", "date": "1987-12-17", "when": "1987 – 17 December 1987", "title": "Village green extension request", "place": "Llandough Community Council", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Council minutes", "narration": "Llandough Community Council minutes for 1987 record that there is \"no justification\" for submitting a right of way from Great House Farm to the Swiss Cottages, and name Debenham Tewson as \"the agents for BP Properties\". At the meeting of 17 December 1987 a resident's letter asks for VG41 to be \"extended up to the farm wall\"; the farm roadway is called \"an unofficial access route\", and the council's Penlan Road licence is recorded as terminated by Debenham Tewson.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "In 1987, while the appeal was decided, the council's minutes treated the farm roadway as unofficial and recorded BP Properties' agents ending its licence.", "cast": [ "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "llandough-community-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Council minutes", "title": "EV-0214 — Llandough Community Council minutes, 1987", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0214-llandough-community-council-minutes-1987/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19871217-1" }, { "order": 96, "ref": "V.7", "id": "ghf-19880303-1", "act": "V", "date": "1988-03-03", "when": "3 March 1988", "title": "House of Lords", "place": "House of Lords", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 3 March 1988 the House of Lords refuses leave to appeal. The family are given 28 days to leave.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The end of the legal road.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The end of the possession case. Ownership of Parcel A had still never been decided.", "cast": [ "courts" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — House of Lords", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#house-of-lords" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19880303-1" }, { "order": 97, "ref": "VI.1", "id": "ghf-19880429-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-04-29", "when": "29 April 1988, morning", "title": "First eviction attempt", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 29 April 1988 five bailiffs and about fifteen police arrive. William Buckler blocks the drive with a tractor and secures the house.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "An occupier resisting a lawful order.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Possession was being enforced over a house whose ownership no court had decided.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [ "south-wales-police" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "'Chainsaw farmer vows to fight on', c. 30 April 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n07", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n07-1988-police-wait-photo.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 29 April 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-01)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n07-1988-police-wait-photo.jpg", "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-01" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19880429-1" }, { "order": 98, "ref": "VI.2", "id": "ghf-19880429-2", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-04-29", "when": "29 April 1988", "title": "The chainsaw", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The bailiffs break the gate and doors. William Buckler pushes a running chainsaw through a door. After four hours the bailiffs withdraw. BP tells the press Mary had been allowed to stay rent-free because of ill health.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The \"chainsaw farmer\": a violent squatter.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"chainsaw farmer\"", "note": "The headline." }, { "said": "\"because of her ill health\"", "note": "BP's account of 1974." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Billy was a father with his three small children behind a door an axe had just come through. The papers called him the chainsaw farmer. Nobody called the men with the axes anything at all. He was defending his home, on land his family had owned since 1928 and lived on since 1667.", "cast": [ "mary", "billy", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "'Chainsaw farmer vows to fight on'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n07", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n07-1988-chainsaw-farmer.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 30 April 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-02)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n07-1988-chainsaw-farmer.jpg", "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n07", "ghf-press-n15-02" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19880429-2" }, { "order": 99, "ref": "VI.3", "id": "ghf-19880512-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-05-12", "when": "May 1988", "title": "Strasbourg and the MP", "place": "Alun Michael MP's office", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 3 May 1988 William Buckler applies to the European Commission of Human Rights. On 12 May Alun Michael MP asks the Lord Chancellor to review the case.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Both were pending when the house was demolished.", "cast": [ "billy", "mps" ], "institutions": [ "courts", "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 12 May 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-03)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — ECHR", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#echr" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-03", "ghf-19880503-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19880512-1" }, { "order": 100, "ref": "VI.4", "id": "ghf-19880729-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-07-29", "when": "29 July 1988", "title": "Cadw inspection", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Photograph", "narration": "On 29 July 1988 Cadw inspects and photographs the farmhouse and barn while considering them for listing.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Cadw looked at the house and found it not good enough to list.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Two photographs survive. There is no file, no notes and no record of who decided.", "cast": [ "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Photograph", "title": "Cadw survey photograph of the farmhouse, 29 July 1988 (released 2026, ATISN 27021)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/foi-reply-register/#R37", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-farmhouse.jpg" }, { "type": "Photograph", "title": "Cadw survey photograph of the barn, 29 July 1988 (released 2026, ATISN 27021)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/foi-reply-register/#R37", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-barn.jpg" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Cadw — Forensic Critique", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/cadw-forensic-critique-v8-0-0/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-farmhouse.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19880729-1" }, { "order": 101, "ref": "VI.5", "id": "ghf-19881007-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-10-07", "when": "October – November 1988", "title": "BP Pension Fund sells the estate land", "place": "South Wales", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "In October 1988 BP Pension Fund sells about 1,300 acres of Welsh land to Intercontinental Land & Development (Cardiff) Ltd for £29,375,400, chosen by open tender. In November the Land Authority for Wales buys sites from Lavernock to Leckwith, including plots at Llandough. The Great House Farm site stays with BP Properties Ltd.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · never adjudicated, never extinguished (judgment decides possession only)", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · right to possession upheld (1962 order + 1974 licence)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The land around the farm was quietly handed to the state.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"from Lavernock [to] Leckwith including plots at Llandough\"", "note": "South Wales Echo, 1 November 1988, on the Land Authority for Wales purchase." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The buyer was a private joint venture chosen by open tender; LAW then bought plots. The farm site itself stayed with BP Properties Ltd. LAW's Board minutes for the period are open at Kew (not yet seen).", "cast": [ "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "land-authority-wales" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0270 — Press, 1988–95: BP Pension Fund sale, LAW plots at Llandough", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0270-bp-pension-fund-1988-sale-intercontinental-law-llandough-press/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0269 — TNA WA 9/49: LAW Board minutes, Oct–Nov 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0269-tna-wa-9-49-land-authority-for-wales-board-1988/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0093 — Estates Gazette, 9 July 1988, “BP signal Welsh sales”", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0093-estates-gazette-1988-bp-welsh-sales/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881007-1" }, { "order": 102, "ref": "VI.6", "id": "ghf-19881130-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-11-30", "when": "29 – 30 November 1988", "title": "Eviction", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 29–30 November 1988 bailiffs enter the farmhouse. William Buckler is taken to Llandough Hospital. Eight other residents are made homeless.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"" ], "received_account": "The lawful owner recovered possession.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"possession\"", "note": "What BP was given." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Billy was hurt and taken to hospital. Eight people lost their homes with the family that day. A family that had lived in the house for three hundred and twenty-one years was put out in an afternoon, by an order that never said whose house it was.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo front page — 'Angry scenes as farmer evicted'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n14", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n14-1988-echo-front-page.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 30 November 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-04)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988 — 'Billy's unhappy family'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n09", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n09-1988-billys-unhappy-family.jpg" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n14-1988-echo-front-page.jpg", "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n14", "ghf-press-n15-04", "ghf-press-n09" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881130-1" }, { "order": 103, "ref": "VI.7", "id": "ghf-19881201-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-01", "when": "1 December 1988", "title": "Belongings", "place": "Llandough Hospital", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The family's belongings, including Mary's papers and photographs, are left in the house or put in the road.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Everything in the house or in the road went with it.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n08" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 13 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-11)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-11" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881201-1" }, { "order": 104, "ref": "VI.8", "id": "ghf-19881202-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-02", "when": "2 December 1988", "title": "Injunction", "place": "High Court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 2 December 1988 a High Court judge orders that the farmhouse and its contents must not be touched. BP states it plans to demolish and build homes.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The injunction lasted three days.", "cast": [ "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988 — 'History fight to save farm'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n08", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n08-1988-history-fight.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 2 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-05)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n08-1988-history-fight.jpg", "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-05", "ghf-press-n08" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881202-1" }, { "order": 105, "ref": "VI.9", "id": "ghf-19881209-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-03", "when": "3 December 1988", "title": "Charges", "place": "Llandough Hospital / magistrates", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "William Buckler is taken from hospital and charged with assaulting two bailiffs, criminal damage, and wanton or furious driving.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The violent squatter was charged.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "He was taken from his hospital bed and charged. With Billy in hospital, then in the dock, then bailed away from the site, there was no one left standing between BP and the house. Within three days it was gone.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-06)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n15" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19881130-2", "ghf-press-n15-06", "ghf-press-n15-10" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881209-1" }, { "order": 106, "ref": "VI.10", "id": "ghf-19881203-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-03", "when": "3 – 5 December 1988", "title": "Spot-listing", "place": "Cadw", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "Over the weekend of 3–5 December 1988 Cadw considers spot-listing without access to the interior.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Cadw gave the house fair consideration.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Cadw had already coded the house just below the bar in July.", "cast": [ "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Cadw — Forensic Critique", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/cadw-forensic-critique-v8-0-0/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988 — Cadw considering spot-listing", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n08" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881203-1" }, { "order": 107, "ref": "VI.11", "id": "ghf-19881204-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-04", "when": "1988 (date not established)", "title": "Cadw inspection of the house", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Witness statement", "narration": "Cadw officers come into the house, carry out a survey and report, and remark on the roof beams being high (witness statement of Branwen, who lived at the farm until 1988, given on 19 October 2026). Cadw confirms in writing that the house was visited and assessed for listing by its inspectors; its two photographs are dated 29 July 1988. A further Cadw visit was announced for the weekend of 3–4 December 1988, and Cadw declined to list on 5 December. Our case: the inspection took place in the days before that refusal; the exact date is source pending.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Cadw judged the house from the outside and found nothing worth listing.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the roof beams being high\"", "note": "What the Cadw officers remarked inside the house, as Branwen recalls (statement of 19 October 2026)." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Cadw officers came inside the house and looked at its fabric, roof beams included (witness statement of Branwen, 19 October 2026). Cadw confirms the house was visited and assessed by its inspectors, but holds only two photographs of 29 July 1988: no survey, no notes, no report and no record of the officers. The date of the visit Branwen describes is source pending; our case is that it fell in the days before the 5 December 1988 refusal.", "cast": [ "branwen", "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Witness statement", "title": "EV-0255 — Witness statement of Branwen: Cadw inspection of the house, 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0255-witness-statement-branwen-cadw-inspection-1988/" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Cadw, 21 May 2026: assessed and rejected for listing in the 1988 community survey of Llandough; photographs dated 29 July 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/cadw-welsh-government-correspondence/#m12" }, { "type": "Photograph", "title": "Cadw survey photograph of the farmhouse, 29 July 1988 (released 2026, ATISN 27021)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/foi-reply-register/#R37", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-farmhouse.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988 — inspector to visit the farmhouse 'this weekend'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n08" }, { "type": "Photograph", "title": "Roof (loft) beams at Great House Farm — undated photograph, Great House Farm Part 1, no. 080 (Wayback archive): the roof beams referred to", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/images/0000-00-00%20-%20Great%20House%20Farm%20Part%201%20-%20080%20-%20EN%20-%20V0.0.0.00.jpg", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-album-p1-080-roof-beams.jpg" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "EV-0268 — Cadw 13428, Lower Farmhouse, Rhoose: an early-19th-century Vale farmhouse listed on 12 October 1988 (“Interior", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0268-cadw-13428-lower-farmhouse-rhoose-listed-12-oct-1988/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-album-p1-080-roof-beams.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881204-1" }, { "order": 108, "ref": "VI.12", "id": "ghf-19881205-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-05", "when": "Monday 5 December 1988", "title": "Final hearing; listing refused", "place": "Cardiff", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 5 December 1988 Judge Norman Francis refuses to continue the injunction pending the European Commission. The same day Cadw states the house is not of sufficient merit to list.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler, evicted 29/30 November 1988 · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The house was not worth listing, and the courts had ruled.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"not of sufficient architectural merit\"", "note": "Cadw, 5 December 1988." } ], "what_we_now_know": "On the same day, both doors closed: the court refused to wait for Strasbourg, and Cadw refused to list. Nothing now protected the house, and everyone knew it.", "cast": [ "cadw", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "cadw", "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Western Mail, 6 December 1988 — 'Farmer fails in final eviction hearing'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n10", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n10-1988-western-mail-final-hearing.jpg" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n10-1988-western-mail-final-hearing.jpg", "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n10" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881205-1" }, { "order": 109, "ref": "VI.13", "id": "ghf-19881206-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-06", "when": "6 December 1988, 4am", "title": "Demolition", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "From about 4am on 6 December 1988 the farmhouse and buildings are demolished.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": "An old farmhouse of no special merit was cleared for housing.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Bulldozed before breakfast\"", "note": "The headline." }, { "said": "\"suddenly and completely destroyed\"", "note": "The Royal Commission's archive record (NMR 6048945)." } ], "what_we_now_know": "At four in the morning, in the dark, before anyone could stop it. Branwen and her three small children watched their home come down. A thousand people had signed to save it. An MP had asked for the case to be looked at again. Strasbourg had not yet heard it. None of it mattered by breakfast. The house was destroyed before it was ever fully recorded. The title to Parcel A was not destroyed with it.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "'Tears flow as 800 year-old farm house is razed at last'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n11", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n11-1988-tears-flow-razed.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 6 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-07)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 21 December 1988 (reader's letter on \"Bulldozed Before Breakfast\") (search extract GHF-E090-N15-12)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n11-1988-tears-flow-razed.jpg", "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n11", "ghf-press-n15-07", "ghf-press-n15-12", "ghf-19881211-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881206-1" }, { "order": 110, "ref": "VI.14", "id": "ghf-19881208-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-07", "when": "7 – 9 December 1988", "title": "Local reaction and bail", "place": "Llandough", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "A Vale of Glamorgan councillor calls the demolition \"disgusting\". Villagers meet their councillors on 8 December. On 9 December William Buckler is bailed on condition he stays away from the site.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "He was barred from the land his family had owned.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [ "vale-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 7 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-08)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 9 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-09)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 10 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-10)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "1988: Possession and Demolition", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/demolition-1988/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0111 — South Wales Echo, 21 December 1988, reader’s letter", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0111-echo-readers-letter-bulldozed-report/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-08", "ghf-press-n15-09" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881208-1" }, { "order": 111, "ref": "VI.15", "id": "ghf-19881212-1", "act": "VI", "date": "1988-12-12", "when": "December 1988", "title": "Royal Commission in the rubble", "place": "Great House Farm — rubble", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "An examination of the rubble, recorded in the heritage record, notes a fireplace jamb and an ogee-stopped beam with torus, and the loss of the carved stone capital kept by the front door.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A minor record of a lost farmhouse.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Evidence of a house of quality, recorded only after it was destroyed.", "cast": [ "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "1988: Possession and Demolition", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/demolition-1988/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19881212-1" }, { "order": 112, "ref": "VII.1", "id": "ghf-19890320-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1989-03-20", "when": "20 March 1989", "title": "Site clearance", "place": "Great House Farm", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 20 March 1989 lorries clear the site.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 20 March 1989 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-14)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-14" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19890320-1" }, { "order": 113, "ref": "VII.2", "id": "ghf-19890323-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1989-03-23", "when": "January – March 1989", "title": "Charges resolved", "place": "Court", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "In January 1989 one charge is dropped as out of time and William Buckler is barred from within half a mile of the site. On 23 March he pleads guilty to the remaining charges and is freed.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [ "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 23 March 1989 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-15)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 24 March 1989 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-16)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "'Charge against evicted farmer dropped', January 1989", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n12", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n12-1989-charge-dropped.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 6 January 1989 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-13)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-press-n15-15", "ghf-press-n15-16", "ghf-19890115-1", "ghf-press-n15-13" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19890323-1" }, { "order": 114, "ref": "VII.3", "id": "ghf-19890325-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1989-03-25", "when": "1989", "title": "Rehousing", "place": "Penarth", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "The family live with William Buckler's sister in Penarth. He plans to live in a converted bus and reports that about £30,000 of possessions were taken from the site.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The family who had lived in the Great House for three centuries were now planning to live in a bus.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 1989 — 'From farm to a bus'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n13", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n13-1989-farm-to-bus.jpg" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n13-1989-farm-to-bus.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19890325-1" }, { "order": 115, "ref": "VII.4", "id": "ghf-19890406-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1989-04-06", "when": "6 April 1989", "title": "Llandough listing survey issued", "place": "Cadw", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "On 6 April 1989 Cadw issues the list from its 1988 community survey of Llandough: Pound Cottage and the former National School (the church is dated 4 June 1989). Great House had been assessed and rejected in that survey. So when Cadw said on 3–5 December 1988 that it was considering spot-listing, the survey's list was not yet out.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The 1988 survey had already been decided and published before the demolition.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"assessed and rejected for listing in the 1988 community survey of Llandough\"", "note": "Cadw, 21 May 2026." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The survey's list bears dates in April 1989, after the demolition. That timing is our reading of the dates, not Cadw's statement. The survey itself looks routine: the whole village, three buildings listed.", "cast": [ "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "EV-0272 — Cadw 13430/13431/13432: Llandough list issued 6 April 1989", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0272-cadw-1989-llandough-resurvey-list-13430-13431-13432/" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0264 — TCPA 1971 s.54: deposit with the council and local land charge", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0264-tcpa-1971-s54-listing-deposit-local-land-charge/" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "EV-0268 — Cadw 13428 Lower Farmhouse, Rhoose (comparator, 12 Oct 1988)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0268-cadw-13428-lower-farmhouse-rhoose-listed-12-oct-1988/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0271 — TNA BD 34/114: Historic Buildings Council for Wales 1988", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0271-tna-bd-34-114-historic-buildings-council-wales-1988-1989/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19890406-1" }, { "order": 116, "ref": "VII.5", "id": "ghf-19890414-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1989-04-14", "when": "14 April 1989", "title": "European Commission decision", "place": "European Commission of Human Rights", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Court record", "narration": "On 14 April 1989 the European Commission of Human Rights declares Buckler v United Kingdom inadmissible.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Strasbourg confirmed the eviction was lawful and the property was BP's.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the property belonged to another\"", "note": "The Commission's reading of the domestic judgments." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Strasbourg relied on the British courts, which had decided possession, not ownership. It never saw a title deed. Another loss, on a question nobody had ever asked.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "bp", "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — ECHR", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#echr" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "Buckler v United Kingdom, Commission decision (PDF)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/wp-1790112811838.pdf" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19890414-1" }, { "order": 117, "ref": "VII.6", "id": "ghf-19891107-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1989-11-07", "when": "October – November 1989", "title": "Outline application", "place": "Vale of Glamorgan planning", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "BP applies for outline planning permission for housing (89/01396/OUT, received 8 November 1989). In the same document GGAT advises an archaeological assessment, prices the work at £2,000 and discloses negotiations with BP's agents; it is then commissioned to carry out the assessment. GGAT's 1989 planning report describes the farmhouse as having been listed as a \"county treasure\"; Cadw states it was never listed.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Routine planning with archaeological advice.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The adviser to the council became the developer's contractor on the same site.", "cast": [ "bp", "cadw", "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "cadw", "vale-council", "bp", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — later dealings", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#later-dealings" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19891108-1", "ghf-19891010-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19891107-1" }, { "order": 118, "ref": "VII.7", "id": "ghf-19900223-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1990-02-23", "when": "23 February 1990", "title": "Homes bid and a village-green request", "place": "Llandough", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "On 23 February 1990 the South Wales Echo's front page reports a bid to build homes on the Great House Farm land. Llandough Community Council makes no objection, but asks for the land to be registered as village green.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Nobody locally questioned the development.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"No objection has been made by Llandough Community Council\"", "note": "South Wales Echo, 23 February 1990 (snippet)." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The council did not object to the housing but wanted a village green. Snippet only; the full page and the council's minutes (free at Glamorgan Archives) are still to be read.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "glamorgan-archives", "llandough-community-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0273 — South Wales Echo, 23 Feb 1990, p.1 (snippet)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0273-south-wales-echo-23-feb-1990-great-house-farm-homes-bid-village-green/" }, { "type": "Archive catalogue", "title": "EV-0266 — Glamorgan Archives P35/11–29: Community Council minutes 1982–2000", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0266-glamorgan-archives-p35-llandough-community-council-minutes-1982-2000/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19900223-1" }, { "order": 119, "ref": "VII.8", "id": "ghf-19900313-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1990-03-13", "when": "February – March 1990", "title": "Outline permission", "place": "Vale of Glamorgan planning", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "On 13 March 1990 outline permission is granted with 18 conditions. The officer's report notes the farm buildings \"were unfortunately demolished a little while ago\". GGAT's further comments of 8 February 1990 are missing from the file.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Billy Buckler · house demolished 6 December 1988 · title never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"unfortunately demolished\"", "note": "The officer's report." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The Local Plan had required the buildings to be kept. No preservation notice had been served.", "cast": [ "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "vale-council", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19900208-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19900313-1" }, { "order": 120, "ref": "VII.9", "id": "ghf-19900529-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1990-05-29", "when": "1990", "title": "Death of William Buckler", "place": "Llandough", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Newspaper", "narration": "William Buckler dies in 1990, aged 41. The South Wales Echo of 2 June 1990 reports that \"Billy died suddenly\" and that he \"made a detour around Llandough so never had to pass the site of Great House Farm\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "He was in his forties. He died in the village where he was born, without his home, without ever having had the one question that mattered answered. Mary's claim to the house passed, undecided, to his children.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family — William", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0290 — South Wales Echo, 2 June 1990, p.2: \"Billy died suddenly this week\" (snippet; wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0290-snippet-only-south-wales-echo-2-jun-1990-p-2-billy-died-suddenly-this-week-he-made/" }, { "type": "Probate record", "title": "EV-0274 — Probate calendar 1991: William Beverley Buckler (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0274-probate-calendar-1991-william-beverley-buckler/" }, { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0274 — Probate calendar 1991: “BUCKLER, William Beverley … of Penarth … died 29 April 1990”, administration granted a", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0274-probate-calendar-1991-william-beverley-buckler/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19920515-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19900529-1" }, { "order": 121, "ref": "VII.10", "id": "ghf-19900801-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1990-08-01", "when": "August – October 1990", "title": "Evaluation trenches", "place": "Former farm site", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Archaeological record", "narration": "In August 1990 GGAT digs eight trenches for BP and finds early medieval burials. An area that could not be investigated is marked low potential. In October the council records the condition as met.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"low potential\"", "note": "GGAT's zoning." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The 1994 excavation found burials in the area marked low potential.", "cast": [ "bp", "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "vale-council", "bp", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" }, { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19901015-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19900801-1" }, { "order": 122, "ref": "VII.11", "id": "ghf-19910821-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1991-08-21", "when": "21 August 1991", "title": "Heritage record entry", "place": "Historic Environment Record", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "The regional Historic Environment Record entry for Great House Farm (GGAT02038s) is compiled on 21 August 1991. The Royal Commission's archive record (NMR 6048945) states: \"The house and farm buildings were suddenly and completely destroyed by B.P. Properties Ltd. on 6th December 1988 amid considerable local controversy.\"", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [ "ggat", "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "heneb", "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Cadw — Forensic Critique", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/cadw-forensic-critique-v8-0-0/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19910821-1" }, { "order": 123, "ref": "VII.12", "id": "ghf-19920514-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1992-05-14", "when": "14 May 1992", "title": "Reserved matters application", "place": "Vale of Glamorgan planning", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "On 14 May 1992 Ideal Homes Wales applies for approval of 20 houses (92/00671/RES).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "BP had not yet transferred the land to Ideal Homes.", "cast": [ "ideal" ], "institutions": [ "vale-council", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19920514-1" }, { "order": 124, "ref": "VII.13", "id": "ghf-19920727-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1992-07-27", "when": "27 July 1992", "title": "GGAT letter", "place": "GGAT", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "On 27 July 1992 GGAT writes to the council that the 1990 assessment showed significant deposits, including human bone, and urges mitigation. Page 2 is missing from the file.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [ "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "vale-council", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19920727-1" }, { "order": 125, "ref": "VII.14", "id": "ghf-19920903-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1992-09-03", "when": "3 September 1992", "title": "Reserved matters approved", "place": "Vale of Glamorgan planning", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Planning file", "narration": "On 3 September 1992 the 20 houses are approved without a new archaeological condition.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076, BP Properties · in possession from 29/30 November 1988" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [], "institutions": [ "vale-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19920903-1" }, { "order": 126, "ref": "VII.15", "id": "ghf-19931203-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1993-12-03", "when": "December 1993", "title": "Transfer to Ideal Homes", "place": "Former farm site", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 3 December 1993 BP transfers the site to Ideal Homes and groundworks begin. On 13 December GGAT asks the council for a breach-of-condition notice. The council accepts the developer's counsel's opinion that the condition is discharged.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 transferred by BP to Ideal Homes (December 1993); later Persimmon Homes (Wales)" }, "title_moves": [ "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"" ], "received_account": "BP sold its land to a developer.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"a difference of opinion\"", "note": "The council to the MP." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The merged title, including the synthetic Parcel A, passed to a buyer as though it were one parcel.", "cast": [ "bp", "ggat", "ideal" ], "institutions": [ "vale-council", "bp", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — later dealings", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#later-dealings" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19931213-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19931203-1" }, { "order": 127, "ref": "VII.16", "id": "ghf-19940504-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1994-03-21", "when": "March – July 1994", "title": "Cemetery excavation", "place": "Former farm site", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Archaeological record", "narration": "March–July 1994: the Cotswold Archaeological Trust excavates an early medieval cemetery on the site. Published totals reach 1,026 burials. The Home Office licence lapsed between 21 April and at least 3 May while work continued.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 transferred by BP to Ideal Homes (December 1993); later Persimmon Homes (Wales)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A successful rescue excavation.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"preservation by record\"", "note": "The agreed basis of the excavation." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The largest early medieval burial population then recovered in Wales, from ground marked low potential in 1990.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19940421-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19940504-1" }, { "order": 128, "ref": "VII.17", "id": "ghf-19940728-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1994-07-28", "when": "28 July 1994", "title": "Finds to the National Museum", "place": "National Museum of Wales", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Museum record", "narration": "On 28 July 1994 Ideal Homes Wales, as landowner, gives the human remains and finds to the National Museum of Wales (95.56H).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 transferred by BP to Ideal Homes (December 1993); later Persimmon Homes (Wales)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The landowner donated the finds.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"as landowner\"", "note": "The basis of the gift." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Ownership of finds follows ownership of land. The finds from Parcel A were given away on the strength of the merged title.", "cast": [ "ideal" ], "institutions": [ "museum-wales" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19940728-1" }, { "order": 129, "ref": "VII.18", "id": "ghf-19941110-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1994-11-10", "when": "1994 – 96", "title": "Woodland title and houses", "place": "Woodland — WA735527", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "On 10 November 1994 Ideal Homes Wales transfers the woodland to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527); no transfer from Cardiff City Corporation is on record. In 1995–96 rights are granted to South Wales Electricity. The houses of Church View Close are built.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished · woodland now registered to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527) · land to the south a village green", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [ "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"", "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The Forest of Cardiff says it bought the woodland in 1994. Per the Buckler case, this woodland, part of Parcel A, had been taken in 1955, and the charity has not used it. (SOURCE PENDING: not yet recorded on the wiki.)", "cast": [ "ideal" ], "institutions": [ "forest-of-cardiff" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Woodland", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/woodland/" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — later dealings", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#later-dealings" }, { "type": "Planning file", "title": "Redevelopment and Church View Close", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/redevelopment/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0276 — Press set, 1994–1996: Ideal Homes (Wales) built “Churchview Close”, Llandough (first buyers by January 1995); ", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0276-churchview-close-llandough-ideal-homes-persimmon-1994-1996/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "EV-0270 — Press set, 1988–1995: BP Pension Fund sold about 1,300 acres of Welsh land to Intercontinental Land & Developm", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0270-bp-pension-fund-1988-sale-intercontinental-law-llandough-press/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-19950628-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19941110-1" }, { "order": 130, "ref": "VII.19", "id": "ghf-19950101-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1995-01-01", "when": "1995 – 1996", "title": "Last dealings on the title", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "Rights are granted to South Wales Electricity, and correspondence with Persimmon follows; these are the last dealings on the registration file.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished · woodland now registered to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527) · land to the south a village green", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The registration file ends with the utility rights and the Persimmon correspondence of 1995–96.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "hmlr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Master Timeline", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/timeline/" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — later dealings", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#later-dealings" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19950101-1" }, { "order": 131, "ref": "VII.20", "id": "ghf-19970516-1", "act": "VII", "date": "1997-05-16", "when": "16 May 1997", "title": "Western Ground Rents wound up", "place": "London", "parcel": "x", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "Western Ground Rents Ltd, placed in members' voluntary liquidation with other BP pension companies in 1996, holds its final meeting on 16 May 1997, where the liquidator lays an account of how the companies' property has been disposed of.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished · woodland now registered to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527) · land to the south a village green", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Western Ground Rents simply faded away.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"how … the property of the Companies have been disposed of\"", "note": "The liquidator's s.94 notice, London Gazette, 18 April 1997." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A solvent group winding-up. The liquidator's account (in the TNA BT 31 files) would show what WGR still held and where it went.", "cast": [ "wgr", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "national-archives" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Public record", "title": "EV-0277 — London Gazette 1996–97: WGR creditors notice and final meetings", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0277-london-gazette-1996-1997-western-ground-rents-creditors-and-final-meetings/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-19970516-1" }, { "order": 132, "ref": "VII.21", "id": "ghf-20050101-1", "act": "VII", "date": "2005-01-01", "when": "2005", "title": "Publication", "place": "Medieval Archaeology", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Archaeological record", "narration": "The excavation is published in Medieval Archaeology 49 (2005): 1,026 burials, 814 articulated.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished · woodland now registered to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527) · land to the south a village green", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The publication does not mention the family or the house's demolition.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Publication", "title": "Holbrook and Thomas, Medieval Archaeology 49 (2005)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Woodland", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/woodland/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20051222-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20050101-1" }, { "order": 133, "ref": "VII.22", "id": "ghf-20051202-1", "act": "VII", "date": "2005-12-02", "when": "2 December 2005", "title": "Woodland land sold", "place": "Woodland (title WA735527)", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Company accounts", "narration": "On 2 December 2005 Forest of Cardiff transfers land to Goldsworthy Homes, and on 22 December part of the woodland title is divided off. Forest of Cardiff's accounts for the year to 30 June 2006 record \"Sale of Land — Leckwith Road, Llandough 20,000\". Which land was sold is not known until the transfer plan is read.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished · woodland now registered to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527) · land to the south a village green", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The woodland charity sold a piece of land at Leckwith Road.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"Sale of Land\"", "note": "The charity's own accounts. The land was not on its balance sheet." } ], "what_we_now_know": "HELD (EV-0217, Companies House). £20,000 received in the year to 30 June 2006. Which land, and how the charity came to hold it in 1994, are open questions.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "forest-of-cardiff" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Company accounts", "title": "EV-0217 — Forest of Cardiff accounts to 30 June 2006, note 13: \"Sale of Land — Leckwith Road, Llandough\" (wiki evidence page)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0217-forest-of-cardiff-accounts-2006-sale-of-land-leckwith-road/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20051202-1" }, { "order": 134, "ref": "VII.23", "id": "ghf-20190320-1", "act": "VII", "date": "2019-03-20", "when": "20 March 2019", "title": "1990 assessment archived", "place": "RCAHMW national archive", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Heritage record", "narration": "On 20 March 2019 GGAT's 1990 assessment is added to the national record.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's heirs · never adjudicated, never extinguished · woodland now registered to the Forest of Cardiff (WA735527) · land to the south a village green", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Twenty-nine years after it was written.", "cast": [ "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "heneb", "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20190320-1" }, { "order": 135, "ref": "VIII.1", "id": "ghf-20251117-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2025-11-17", "when": "November 2025 – January 2026", "title": "Records requests begin", "place": "Royal Commission and others", "parcel": "", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "From November 2025 Mary's grandchildren request records from public bodies. On 29 January 2026 they apply to HM Land Registry to record the interest omitted at first registration.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [ "Parcel A: the true title" ], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [ "mary", "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "rcahmw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20260123-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20251117-1" }, { "order": 136, "ref": "VIII.2", "id": "ghf-20260323-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-03-23", "when": "February – March 2026", "title": "Land Registry reply", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 23 March 2026 HM Land Registry sets out the registration history and states there is \"no evidence of a mistake in the register\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "WA231076 and the house titles carved from it (Church View Close)" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The register is right.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"no evidence of a mistake in the register\"", "note": "HMLR, 23 March 2026." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The reply treats the farm as one holding, as the 1916 wording did, and does not explain how Parcel A entered BP's title.", "cast": [ "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — 2026 complaint", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#hmlr-2026" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "HMLR holding letter, 13 February 2026 (PDF)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fgithub.com%2Funclehowell%2Fdatro%2Fblob%2Fwayback%2Fwayback%2Fpdf%2Ffoi%2F2026-02-13_hmlr_wa231076_holding-letter.pdf" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20260213-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260323-1" }, { "order": 137, "ref": "VIII.3", "id": "ghf-20260419-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-04-19", "when": "19 April – 25 May 2026", "title": "Complaint decisions", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 19 April 2026 HM Land Registry refuses the stage-one complaint. On 25 May the stage-two decision states the title is \"registered correctly\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [ "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"" ], "received_account": "The matter has been examined and closed.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"registered correctly\"", "note": "HMLR, 25 May 2026." } ], "what_we_now_know": "The decisions rely on the 1987 judgment, which decided possession, to answer a question of ownership.", "cast": [ "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — 2026 complaint", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#hmlr-2026" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260419-1" }, { "order": 138, "ref": "VIII.4", "id": "ghf-20260521-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-05-21", "when": "21 May 2026", "title": "Cadw disclosure", "place": "Cadw", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 21 May 2026 Cadw releases two photographs of 29 July 1988, coded \"YYY\", which it describes as \"marginally below the bar\"; on 10 July it states that the code meant the building did not meet the criteria. It describes its paper file as \"quite likely\" destroyed, and later \"most likely\"; it holds no destruction record.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The house was assessed and narrowly failed.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"marginally below the bar\"", "note": "Cadw's reading of YYY." } ], "what_we_now_know": "There is no record of the file's destruction.", "cast": [ "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Cadw — Forensic Critique", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/cadw-forensic-critique-v8-0-0/" }, { "type": "Photograph", "title": "Cadw survey photograph of the farmhouse, 29 July 1988 (released 2026, ATISN 27021)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/foi-reply-register/#R37", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-farmhouse.jpg" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-barn.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260521-1" }, { "order": 139, "ref": "VIII.5", "id": "ghf-20260614-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-06-14", "when": "14 June 2026", "title": "Council minutes at the archives", "place": "Llandough Community Council", "parcel": "", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "The Clerk to Llandough Community Council replies that the council's minutes from 1982 were deposited at Glamorgan Archives in 2002, and refuses the rest under section 21 of the Freedom of Information Act. The family's follow-up the same day goes unanswered.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The council's own minutes for 1982, the year of first registration, are at Glamorgan Archives.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "glamorgan-archives", "llandough-community-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Llandough Community Council correspondence (M06, M07)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/llandough-community-council-correspondence/#m07" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260614-1" }, { "order": 140, "ref": "VIII.6", "id": "ghf-20260716-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-07-16", "when": "16 July 2026", "title": "Police records", "place": "South Wales Police", "parcel": "", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "South Wales Police answer freedom of information request 719/26: they \"hold no information\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "South Wales Police hold no information in answer to request 719/26.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "south-wales-police" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "South Wales Police correspondence (M33; EV-0159)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/south-wales-police-correspondence/#m33" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260716-1" }, { "order": 141, "ref": "VIII.7", "id": "ghf-20260730-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-07-30", "when": "June – July 2026", "title": "Schedule of registration documents", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 30 July 2026 HM Land Registry supplies a schedule of 43 documents on the first-registration files. The 31 December 1969 conveyance and the 1971 abstract are not listed.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The deed recited as the root of BP's title is not on file. No document on file conveys Parcel A to Western Ground Rents or BP.", "cast": [ "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — deeds before registration", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#deeds-before-registration" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — 2026 complaint", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#hmlr-2026" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20260602-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260730-1" }, { "order": 142, "ref": "VIII.8", "id": "ghf-20260825-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-08-25", "when": "25 August 2026", "title": "Museum Wales reply", "place": "Museum Wales", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 25 August 2026 Museum Wales replies that the information is \"not held\", and in the same letter states that it has found records of other discoveries at Great House Farm, which it withholds as \"not in scope\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"not held\"", "note": "Museum Wales." } ], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [], "institutions": [ "museum-wales" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260825-1" }, { "order": 143, "ref": "VIII.9", "id": "ghf-20260908-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-08", "when": "8 September 2026", "title": "Glamorgan Archives reply", "place": "Glamorgan Archives", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 8 September 2026 Glamorgan Archives report no deeds for the 1877 sale, and identify Bute X.6(12), the trustees' 1877 book of payments, at Cardiff Library.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "A payment by Daniel Thomas recorded in that book would document the 1877 sale of Parcel A.", "cast": [ "bute" ], "institutions": [ "glamorgan-archives" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — Glamorgan Archives reply", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#glamorgan-2026-4097b" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260908-1" }, { "order": 144, "ref": "VIII.10", "id": "ghf-20260914-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-14", "when": "14 September 2026", "title": "The 1965 school-site conveyance", "place": "Vale of Glamorgan Council", "parcel": "?", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "In answer to request 00211027 the Vale of Glamorgan Council releases the conveyance of the school site dated 11 June 1965 and the 1965 contract.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The 1965 school-site conveyance is now held and can be laid against the farm's boundaries.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "vale-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Vale of Glamorgan Council correspondence (M109; EV-0042, EV-0216)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/vale-of-glamorgan-council-correspondence/#m109" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260914-1" }, { "order": 145, "ref": "VIII.11", "id": "ghf-20260917-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-17", "when": "17 – 21 September 2026", "title": "Complaints and correspondence", "place": "Cadw / Stephen Doughty MP", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "September 2026: the family make a formal complaint to Cadw (investigation commenced 29 September), write to Stephen Doughty MP on 18 and 19 September, and request records from Heneb on 20 September. On 21 September an HM Land Registry support agent states the title was \"closed in 2005\".", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The statement contradicts the Registry's own history.", "cast": [ "hmlr", "cadw", "ggat", "mps" ], "institutions": [ "cadw", "hmlr", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Restoration Campaign", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/restoration-campaign/" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — 2026 complaint", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#hmlr-2026" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20260918-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260917-1" }, { "order": 146, "ref": "VIII.12", "id": "ghf-20260923-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-23", "when": "23 September 2026", "title": "House of Lords papers", "place": "The National Archives", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 23 September 2026 The National Archives reports that the House of Lords judicial papers in BP Properties Ltd v Buckler survive (YHL/PO/JO/10/11/2536). Earlier searches had not found them.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [ "bp", "courts" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts", "national-archives" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Source Conflicts Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/source-conflicts-register/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260923-1" }, { "order": 147, "ref": "VIII.13", "id": "ghf-20260925-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-25", "when": "25 – 27 September 2026", "title": "Woodland offer", "place": "Forest of Cardiff", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 25 September 2026 the Forest of Cardiff offers the family a route to ownership of the woodland. On 27 September the family decline.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The woodland is part of Parcel A.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "forest-of-cardiff" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Woodland", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/woodland/" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260925-1" }, { "order": 148, "ref": "VIII.14", "id": "ghf-20260927-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-27", "when": "27 – 29 September 2026", "title": "Complaints to Heneb and the Reviewer", "place": "Heneb / HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "27–29 September 2026: the family's formal complaint to Heneb and GGAT Ltd about GGAT's role, 1982–1995 (an investigating officer is appointed on 29 September); HM Land Registry's handling referred to the Independent Complaints Reviewer (ICR/090/26).", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": null, "cast": [ "hmlr", "ggat" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "heneb" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Analysis", "title": "GGAT — Forensic Review", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/ggat-forensic-review-and-evidence-schedule-v4-0-3/" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Records Access Chronology", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260927-1" }, { "order": 149, "ref": "VIII.15", "id": "ghf-20260929-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-09-29", "when": "29 September – 5 October 2026", "title": "Archive releases", "place": "Cadw / RCAHMW / Museum Wales", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 29 September 2026 the Royal Commission releases its records, including the 1974 newspaper report and a note of the armour. On 5 October Museum Wales releases further records.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Both were on record before the demolition.", "cast": [ "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw", "rcahmw", "museum-wales" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Archaeology and Heritage", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/archaeology/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Where Things Stand", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/where-things-stand/" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Museum Wales reply (GHF-E106-R33)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/foi-reply-register/ghf-e106-r33-amgueddfa-cymru-reply-further-collections-search-following-8-september-2026-foi/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20261005-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20260929-1" }, { "order": 150, "ref": "VIII.16", "id": "ghf-20261006-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-10-06", "when": "September – October 2026", "title": "HER source-file digitisation and publication", "place": "Heneb / Archwilio", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "The public HER entry GGAT02038s already referred to H. J. Thomas's 1974 survey and cited R. F. Suggett's December 1988 note. Following the family's September 2026 records request, Heneb reportedly stated on 14 October that the underlying source file had been digitised and uploaded to Archwilio as PDFs in the sources section. Heneb responded to the schedule of records on 16 October. This distinguishes the earlier public citation from the later availability of the underlying source-file material; it does not by itself establish concealment or what the Strasbourg Commission received.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "No deed has been produced by which Parcel A passed from the Williamses, or from anyone, to BP.", "cast": [ "ggat", "rcahmw" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "heneb", "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" }, { "type": "Evidence catalogue", "title": "GHF-E183 — Heneb / HER source-file request and replies, September–October 2026", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/ghf-e183-heneb-her-source-file-request-and-replies-september-october-2026/" }, { "type": "Evidence catalogue", "title": "GHF-E184 — Heneb schedule of records and 16 October response", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/ghf-e184-heneb-schedule-of-records-and-16-october-response/" }, { "type": "Evidence catalogue", "title": "GHF-E145 — ECHR application 14464/88 and Commission decision, 14 April 1989", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/ghf-e145-echr-application-14464-88-and-commission-decision-14-april-1989/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [ "ghf-20260922-1", "ghf-20261003-1" ], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20261006-1" }, { "order": 151, "ref": "VIII.17", "id": "ghf-20261010-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-10-10", "when": "10 – 15 October 2026", "title": "Application to correct the register", "place": "HM Land Registry", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Land Registry record", "narration": "HM Land Registry opens internal application Z084NQV (ref N610CGV) \"to investigate and correct any error that may have been made\" on WA231076, after the family raises the matter. On 15 October the family applies to alter the register of WA240304 and WA231076.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "An application to alter the register of both titles is open at HM Land Registry.", "cast": [ "hmlr" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "HM Land Registry correspondence — application Z084NQV (M77)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/hm-land-registry-correspondence/#m77" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "HM Land Registry correspondence — application to alter the register (M78)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/hm-land-registry-correspondence/#m78" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20261010-1" }, { "order": 152, "ref": "VIII.18", "id": "ghf-20261011-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-10-11", "when": "11 – 13 October 2026", "title": "Council refuses on cost", "place": "Llandough Community Council", "parcel": "", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "The Clerk to Llandough Community Council refuses the family's request of 21 September under section 12 (cost); other matters are to be \"considered at the October meeting\". On 13 October the family asks for an internal review.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The council's records request stands refused on cost, with an internal review asked for.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "llandough-community-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Llandough Community Council correspondence (M15)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/llandough-community-council-correspondence/#m15" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Llandough Community Council correspondence (M18)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/llandough-community-council-correspondence/#m18" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20261011-1" }, { "order": 153, "ref": "VIII.19", "id": "ghf-20261019-1", "act": "VIII", "date": "2026-10-19", "when": "19 October 2026", "title": "Welsh Government and Cadw replies", "place": "Welsh Government / Cadw", "parcel": "", "basis": "Official correspondence", "narration": "On 19 October 2026 the Welsh Government answers ATISN 26-0010: searches for the farm name, Western Ground Rents and BP Properties found no files, and \"any routine records would have been destroyed in line with the corporate retention schedule applied at the time\". The same day Cadw refuses ATISN 27589 under section 14(2) of the Freedom of Information Act, as \"substantially similar\" to ATISN 27021, already answered and internally reviewed. Neither letter states when, or under which schedule, any file was destroyed.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The Welsh Government found no file for the 1988 purchase under the names searched and points to a retention schedule without dating any destruction; Cadw declined to search again. Neither reply says whether a file existed, when it ended, or who decided. SOURCE PENDING for the Land Authority for Wales file itself (EIR request held for verification).", "cast": [ "wgr", "bp", "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw", "welsh-government", "bp", "land-authority-wales" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "EV-0244 — Welsh Government ATISN 26-0010 response, 19 Oct 2026", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0244-welsh-government-atisn-26-0010-disclosure-response-19-oct-2026/" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "EV-0245 — Cadw ATISN 27589 response (s.14(2)), 19 Oct 2026", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/ev-0245-cadw-atisn-27589-response-s14-2-19-oct-2026/" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Welsh Government letter, ATISN 26-0010, 19 October 2026 (PDF)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/pdf/foi/2026-10-19_welsh-government_atisn-26-0010_disclosure-response.pdf" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Cadw letter, ATISN 27589, 19 October 2026 (PDF)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/pdf/foi/2026-10-19_cadw_atisn-27589_response-s14-2.pdf" }, { "type": "Official correspondence", "title": "Cadw / Welsh Government — correspondence (email)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence/cadw-welsh-government-correspondence/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-20261019-1" }, { "order": 154, "ref": "O.1", "id": "ghf-obvious-01", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "They were not squatters", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "The Williams family lived at Great House from 1667 to 1988.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A squatter was evicted after losing in court.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"squatter\"", "note": "How the case was understood in the press and in the street." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A squatter moves into a place that is not theirs. The Williamses were born in this house, married in it and died in it for three hundred and twenty-one years. On Mary's statement they owned it from 1928, and on the family's case by possession from 1940. Nobody who lives somewhere for three centuries is a squatter.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Williams / Buckler Family", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/williams-buckler-family/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-01" }, { "order": 155, "ref": "O.2", "id": "ghf-obvious-02", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "Mary never asked for permission", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams refused the tenancies offered in 1959 and 1965 and did not accept the 1974 letters.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "She lived there by the landlord's permission.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"licence\"", "note": "1974; relied on in 1986 and 1987." } ], "what_we_now_know": "You cannot be given permission you refuse. Every offer of a tenancy, and the licence, was an attempt to turn an owner into a guest in her own house. She said no every time.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1959 refusal", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/#refusal-1959" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1965 offer", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1962-possession-order/#offer-1965" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#letters" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-02" }, { "order": 156, "ref": "O.3", "id": "ghf-obvious-03", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "Nobody produced a deed to the house", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "No conveyance of the farmhouse parcel to Western Ground Rents or to BP, earlier than the 1975 conveyance between two BP companies, has been produced.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "BP owned the farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the paper title to the farm\"", "note": "Court of Appeal, 1987." } ], "what_we_now_know": "If Western Ground Rents or BP had a deed to the house, they would have produced it at the first hearing and the case would have been over in a day. They used tenancy offers, orders, a licence and their own conveyance instead. People with deeds don't need tricks.", "cast": [ "wgr", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — deeds before registration", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#deeds-before-registration" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — conveyances", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#conveyances" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-03" }, { "order": 157, "ref": "O.4", "id": "ghf-obvious-04", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "They knew it was two parcels", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "In 1983 BP registered the farmhouse and garden as a separate title. In 1987 it was amalgamated with the main title.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "It was always one farm.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the whole farm\"", "note": "1916 onwards." } ], "what_we_now_know": "You cannot merge two titles unless there are two. BP knew. The Land Registry knew. The court read a separate conveyance of the farmhouse and garden. The only people never told what that meant were the family.", "cast": [ "bp" ], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — first registration and amalgamation", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-04" }, { "order": 158, "ref": "O.5", "id": "ghf-obvious-05", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "Losing on possession is not losing on ownership", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "The High Court (1986), the Court of Appeal (1987), the House of Lords (1988) and the European Commission of Human Rights (1989) ruled against the family on possession.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "They lost every case, so they must have been wrong.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"lost\"", "note": "Every headline." } ], "what_we_now_know": "They lost every round of an argument about who could live in the house. Nobody ever asked who owned it. You can lose a hundred times on the wrong question and still be right about the real one.", "cast": [ "courts" ], "institutions": [ "courts", "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "BP v Buckler: Scope, Decided & Undecided", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/court-judicial-issues/bp-v-buckler-scope-decided-undecided/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-05" }, { "order": 159, "ref": "O.6", "id": "ghf-obvious-06", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "William Buckler was the last obstacle", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "William Buckler was injured during the eviction of 29–30 November 1988, charged from hospital on 3 December, and bailed on 9 December on condition he stayed away from the site. The house was demolished on 6 December.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A violent man was arrested and charged.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"chainsaw farmer\"", "note": "The headline." } ], "what_we_now_know": "He physically stood in their way, so he was removed: to hospital, to the dock, then barred from the site by his bail. With him out of the way there was nobody left between BP and the house. It came down within the week.", "cast": [ "billy" ], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo — 'Angry scenes as farmer evicted'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n14", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n14-1988-echo-front-page.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 3 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-06)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 9 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-09)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-06" }, { "order": 160, "ref": "O.7", "id": "ghf-obvious-07", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "Four in the morning was chosen", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "Listing was refused on 5 December 1988. Demolition began at about 4am on 6 December. The European Commission application was pending.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "An old building was cleared for housing.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"suddenly and completely destroyed\"", "note": "The Royal Commission's archive record (NMR 6048945)." } ], "what_we_now_know": "You don't start bulldozers at four in the morning by accident. It was done in the dark, the morning after the last protection fell and before Strasbourg could be heard, so that it could not be stopped and could never be undone.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "echr" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "'Tears flow as 800 year-old farm house is razed at last'", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n11", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n11-1988-tears-flow-razed.jpg" }, { "type": "Heritage record", "title": "Historic Environment Record GGAT 02038s (Archwilio)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Farchwilio.org.uk%2Fher%2Fchi3%2Freport%2Fpage.php%3Fwatprn%3DGGAT02038s" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-07" }, { "order": 161, "ref": "O.8", "id": "ghf-obvious-08", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "The public was on their side", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "In 1974 about 1,000 people signed a petition to save the house. In 1988 villagers protested the demolition and an MP asked for the case to be reviewed.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Nobody much cared about an old farmhouse.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The public stood with the family. A thousand signatures, an MP, a furious village. It made no difference. Where the public could not be persuaded, force and stealth were used instead.", "cast": [ "mps" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "Daily Telegraph, 16 April 1974", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-archive-transcripts/#n03", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/ghf-e090-n03-1974-open-day-telegraph.jpg" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 12 May 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-03)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" }, { "type": "Newspaper", "title": "South Wales Echo, 7 December 1988 (search extract GHF-E090-N15-08)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/evidence-library/press-articles-index/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-08" }, { "order": 162, "ref": "O.9", "id": "ghf-obvious-09", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "The papers did not leave on their own", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement records that the family papers were taken from the blanket box in 1950–52 by a lodger placed in the house by an estate agent, and given to the agent.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "If they ever had papers, they couldn't produce them.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"never produced\"", "note": "Court of Appeal, 1987." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Title deeds don't walk out of a blanket box. They were taken, by a man an estate agent put in the house, and handed to that agent. Thirty-five years later a court noted that they had never been produced.", "cast": [ "mary" ], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The 1877 Agreement — papers taken", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1877-agreement/#papers-taken" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-09" }, { "order": 163, "ref": "O.10", "id": "ghf-obvious-10", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "A decision with no file", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "Cadw holds two photographs of 29 July 1988 and no other record of its 1988 listing consideration.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "Cadw assessed the house properly and it fell just short.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"marginally below the bar\"", "note": "Cadw, 2026." } ], "what_we_now_know": "A public body decided the fate of a three-hundred-year-old house and kept no file, no notes and no name. A decision nobody can examine is a decision nobody can challenge.", "cast": [ "cadw" ], "institutions": [ "cadw" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Photograph", "title": "Cadw survey photograph of the farmhouse, 29 July 1988 (released 2026, ATISN 27021)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/records-access-chronology/foi-reply-register/#R37", "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-farmhouse.jpg" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Cadw — Forensic Critique", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/government-public-authority-involvement/cadw-forensic-critique-v8-0-0/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-10" }, { "order": 164, "ref": "O.11", "id": "ghf-obvious-11", "act": "O", "date": null, "when": "Plainly", "title": "They never asked a court who owned the house", "place": "", "parcel": "", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "BP's 1974 action, in which Mary pleaded ownership, was adjourned and not relisted. The 1984 writ sought possession, not a declaration of ownership.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "The courts settled who owned Great House Farm.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "In 1974 the question of ownership was in front of a judge, and BP walked away from it. In 1984 it asked only for possession. If you were sure you owned the house, you would ask a court to say so. They never did.", "cast": [ "mary", "bp" ], "institutions": [ "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Court record", "title": "The 1974 Licence Letters — the action", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/1974-licence-letters/#action" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler — the writ", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/#writ" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-obvious-11" }, { "order": 165, "ref": "E.1", "id": "ghf-99990101-1", "act": "E", "date": null, "when": "Today", "title": "The sequence", "place": "The two titles", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "1916 to 1987: a tenancy, two possession orders, three tenancy offers, licence letters, a conveyance, two registrations and an amalgamation.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A landlord and its successors recovered their farm from tenants who stayed on without paying, and the courts confirmed it.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the whole farm\"", "note": "1916." }, { "said": "\"the whole of the farm\"", "note": "1955." }, { "said": "\"licence\"", "note": "1974." }, { "said": "\"the paper title to the farm\"", "note": "1987." }, { "said": "\"registered correctly\"", "note": "2026." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Parcel A was the family's from 1928, and by possession from 1940. It was never shown to belong to Western Ground Rents or BP. A synthetic single farm was described in 1916; six attempts (1949, 1955, 1959, 1962, 1965, 1974) treated Mary's occupation as permissive; the woodland and the land to the south were taken; the 1975 conveyance and 1983 registration gave the synthetic Parcel A a deed and a title; the 1987 amalgamation folded it into Parcel B. The courts decided possession and never decided ownership. Possession can be awarded without ownership being tried, and land can be registered without a rival claim being decided. Neither decides the older title.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "bp" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Two Parcels — the title test", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/the-two-parcels/" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-99990101-1" }, { "order": 166, "ref": "E.2", "id": "ghf-99990101-4", "act": "E", "date": null, "when": "Today", "title": "The two parcels in the record", "place": "The two parcels", "parcel": "AB", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "Records of 1877–1987 describe the property both as one farm and as separate parts.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "It was always one farm, and nobody suggested otherwise.", "received_wording": [ { "said": "\"the whole farm\"", "note": "One farm." }, { "said": "\"the farmhouse and garden\"", "note": "One part, named on its own." } ], "what_we_now_know": "Mary's 1974 statement describes the 1877 split; no lawyer of hers built a case on it. Western Ground Rents offered tenancies of, and sued for, the farmhouse and garden alone. BP conveyed it alone in 1975, registered it alone in 1983, and merged it in 1987. The Land Registry held two titles and joined them. The Court of Appeal read a conveyance of the farmhouse and garden. Those who knew the parcels were separate treated them as one where that helped and as two where that helped. The family's case is that this was a conspiracy against them.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "hmlr", "bp", "courts" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Mary's statement", "title": "Mary (Nancy) Williams's statement (c. 1974)", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/mary-williams-statement/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "The Two Parcels — the title test", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/the-two-parcels/" }, { "type": "Land Registry record", "title": "Land Registry Titles — two titles, then one", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/land-registry-titles/#first-registration" }, { "type": "Court record", "title": "BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/bp-properties-v-buckler/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-99990101-4" }, { "order": 167, "ref": "E.3", "id": "ghf-99990101-2", "act": "E", "date": null, "when": "Today", "title": "The site today", "place": "Church View Close, Llandough", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Analysis", "narration": "Church View Close, twenty houses, stands on the site. The woodland is registered to the Forest of Cardiff. The human remains are held by the National Museum of Wales.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": "A modern estate on a former farm.", "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "The title to Parcel A has never been decided and never extinguished.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "forest-of-cardiff", "museum-wales" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Where Things Stand", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/where-things-stand/" }, { "type": "Analysis", "title": "Legal Review — Fraud, Land and Human Rights", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/scrutiny-and-accountability/legal-review-fraud-land-human-rights/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Missing Records Register", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/missing-records-register/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-99990101-2" }, { "order": 168, "ref": "E.4", "id": "ghf-99990101-3", "act": "E", "date": null, "when": "Today", "title": "Village history", "place": "Llandough Community Council", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Public record", "narration": "Llandough Community Council's page on the village's history describes the Roman villa and the 1994 burials. It does not mention Great House, the Williams family or the demolition.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "There has been no public inquiry, apology or reparation.", "cast": [], "institutions": [ "llandough-community-council" ], "evidence": [ { "type": "Public record", "title": "Llandough Community Council — About Llandough", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wayback/go/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.llandough-cc.co.uk%2FAbout_Us_20117.aspx" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Where Things Stand", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/where-things-stand/" } ], "image": null, "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-99990101-3" }, { "order": 169, "ref": "E.5", "id": "ghf-99990102-1", "act": "E", "date": null, "when": "Today", "title": "The family's requests", "place": "The family", "parcel": "A", "basis": "Family case", "narration": "The family ask for: a ruling on the ownership of Parcel A; the return of the woodland and the green, or reparation; reparation for the houses built on the land; the return of the estate's artefacts; a true heritage record; and a public inquiry.", "family_case": null, "title_ledger": { "Parcel A: the true title": "Freehold claim: Mary's grandchildren · application to the Land Registry, January 2026", "Merged title: \"Parcel A & B\"": "Land Registry, May 2026: 'registered correctly'" }, "title_moves": [], "received_account": null, "received_wording": [], "what_we_now_know": "Every body involved is being given the opportunity to put it right before the family return to court.", "cast": [], "institutions": [], "evidence": [ { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Family Reparations & Remedy Roadmap", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/family-reparations-remedy-roadmap/" }, { "type": "Wiki page", "title": "Where Things Stand", "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/wiki/where-things-stand/" } ], "image": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/media/1988-cadw-farmhouse.jpg", "previous_ids": [], "url": "https://cedwyn.bucklerfamily.estate/story/?event=ghf-99990102-1" } ] }