EV-0051 — “Grievous loss”: letter from William Rees opposing demolition of Great House Farm
| EV ID | EV-0051 |
|---|---|
| Title | “Grievous loss”: letter from William Rees opposing demolition of Great House Farm |
| Date of document | 19 November 197? (year unclear: 1974 or 1977) |
| Type | press |
| Evidence label | PRESS REPORT |
| Repository / reference | Western Mail (publication). Cutting held as family scrapbook item, Buckler family evidence repository. Catalogue GHF-E090-N04. |
| Status | PUBLISHED — open the scan (image) |
| Provenance | Cutting pasted on family scrapbook page beside Daily Telegraph open-day report (GHF-E090-N03); Transcript legible apart from last digit of year. |
| Wiki catalogue page | GHF-E090-N04 |
| Claims that rely on this | Media Gallery, Press Archive — Newspaper Transcripts, Press Articles Index — every newspaper cutting and press extract, one page each, The Restoration Campaign, GHF-E090-N03 — 16 April 1974: “‘Open day’ to save ancient Welsh house” (Daily Te |
About this page type → Read the Docs
Quotation: the farmstead of Great House, or Ty Mawr, which still embodies some of its earlier features, serving as the manorhouse of Llandough.
Proves: A letter signed “William Rees, Penarth” published in the Western Mail opposes demolition of Great House Farm and calls it “the manorhouse of Llandough”.
Does not prove: Not a title record; Each step of the manorial chain needs separate primary sources. Says nothing of family tenure or the 1877 arrangement. Writer’s identity and exact year (1974 or 1977) unconfirmed.
File stored in the wayback archive: EV-0051 in the artifact index.
Interpretation: working hypotheses
Working hypotheses, kept apart from the record above. The record text on this page is unchanged. None of these is a finding: each line is labelled as inference, theory, a reading that cuts against the case, or a discarded theory, and names the evidence it rests on and what would confirm or refute it, so the reader can test it. Updated 25 Oct 2026 (v2: ingredients wording).
The 1974 licence letters
THEORY · L-02Ground R2: the decisive finding was that she never repudiated the letters ("she did not, however, do that"). The family's account, as read here, is that she rejected the permission offered. A letter from her or her solicitors to BP after 31 Oct 1974 rejecting the licence would meet the exact point the court said might have changed the result.
Rests on: EV-0050 · EV-0049 · EV-0051 (this page) · EV-0080 · EV-0073 · ground R2
Would be confirmed by: Such a letter in the family solicitors' 1984–87 file, BP's list of documents, or a reply to the Western Mail letter of 19 Nov 1974.
Would be refuted by: A complete solicitors' file with no rejection. The 1974 defence alone does not help: the court recited it and still found no repudiation (E130).
Status: Open (ground R2, scores a1 b5 c1 d1)
Demolition, archaeology and the green
DISCARDED THEORY · H-05DISCARDED: the theory that the "1978 article" was an ownership assertion made after the licence letters. Reason: it is the Daily Telegraph of 16 Apr 1974, before the letters; the companion letter is the Western Mail of 19 Nov 1974.
Rests on: EV-0048 · EV-0051 (this page) · research log E04
Would be confirmed by: Would be revived by a dated 1978 item.
Would be refuted by: Refuted by the handwritten date and archive stamp.
Status: Discarded
Cited on
14 pages link here.
- EV-0048 — Daily Telegraph report: ‘Open day’ to save ancient Welsh house (Ty Mawr, Llandough)
- EV-0049 — Mary (Nancy) Williams’s plea of ownership in BP Pension Trust’s 1974 county-court action
- EV-0050 — Licence letters from BP Pension Trust and BP Properties to Mrs Buckler (Mrs Williams)
- EV-0073 — Family / solicitors’ litigation file, 1984–87 proceedings
- EV-0080 — Court of Appeal judgment: BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2
- Evidence Register
- Wayback artifact index
- FC-005 — Family / Solicitors’ 1984–87 Litigation File
- GHF-E090-N03 — 16 April 1974: “‘Open day’ to save ancient Welsh house” (Daily Telegraph)
- GHF-E090-N04 — 19 November 197?: “Grievous loss” (Western Mail, letter from William Rees)
- GHF-E135 — 3 July 1974 Mary (Nancy) Williams’s plea of ownership and the pleadings in BP Pension Trust’s county-court action
- GHF-E136 — 31 October 1974 licence letters (BP Pension Trust and BP Properties)
- GHF-E141 — 31 July 1987 Court of Appeal judgment: BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2
- Master Timeline