.. csscpsg chronology :: Great House Farm (Tŷ Mawr), Llandough :: 148 items :: 1824 .. 20 Oct 2026 :: 40 red = not compliant with S1–S6 (tap) - C0001 1824 | 1824 | Survey of the Bute estates, plan 19 “Cedfin or Ty Mawr Farm”, 139a 3r 8p | Glamorgan Archives DB/E/1 | Glamorgan Archives DB/E/1; Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) - C0002 1876 | 1876–1912 | Bute deeds: “land (33 a.), formerly part of Great House Farm, for the Llandough Limeworks (33 a.), 1876-1912”; plan engrossed on D153/3 (1875) and 4 (1876) | National Library of Wales D153/4–8 | NLW catalogue D153/4–8 - C0003 1877-01 | 1877 | Agreement, Marquess of Bute to Daniel Thomas & Son | EV-0006 | src > SOURCE PENDING: the 1877 Bute–Daniel Thomas & Son agreement. - C0004 1877-11-06 | 6 November 1877 | Lease to John Williams | EV-0008 | src > SOURCE PENDING: the lease of 6 November 1877 to John Williams. - C0005 1905-02-23 | 23 February 1905 | Conveyance, John Marquis of Bute to Cardiff City Corporation, as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Charges Register entry 1 | src > The land tinted pink on the filed plan is subject to the rights contained in a Conveyance dated 23 February 1905 made between (1) John Marquis of Bute and Earl of Dumfries and (2) Cardiff City Corporation. NOTE 1: No copies of the plans referred to were supplied on first registration [S5] - C0006 1910 | 1910 | Valuation Office survey map, OS Glamorgan XLVII.6 (Llandough) | The National Archives IR 131/4/96 | TNA location reply, 12 Oct 2026 - C0007 1916-02 | February 1916 | Yearly agricultural tenancy, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶4 | src > Great House Farm used to belong to the Marquis of Bute, and in February 1916 the Marquis granted a yearly agricultural tenancy of the whole of the farm to a Mr John Williams, who was Mr Buckler junior's maternal grandfather. In 1938 the reversion on that tenancy was conveyed to a company called Western Ground Rents Ltd. [S1 S5] - C0008 1924-05-15 | 15 May 1924 | Drain agreement, as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Charges Register entry 2 | src > An Agreement dated 15 May 1924 made between (1) John Marquis of Bute and Earl of Dumfries and (2) James Pelham Stuart Corbett relates to the construction and maintenance of a drain. - C0009 1938 | 1938–1997 | Company file, Western Ground Rents Ltd, company no. 00342092 (wound up 1997) | Companies House 00342092; TNA BT 31 (reference not confirmed) | EV-0249 - C0010 1938-12-25 | 25 December 1938 | Contract for sale, 1965, condition F (root of title) | EV-0216: 1965 contract, condition F (Vale of Glamorgan Council, FOI 00211027 reply, 14 September 2026) | src > F. Title shall be deduced, and shall commence, as follows:- with a Conveyance on sale dated 25th December 1938 [S6] - C0011 1938-12-25 | 25 Dec 1938 | Conveyance of the Bute interest at Llandough to Western Ground Rents Ltd | NLW question ledger NLW-1019-3 (instrument not held) | NLW question ledger NLW-1019-3 [S5] - C0012 1939 | 1939 | Limitation Act 1939, as pleaded in the 1974 defence | Limitation Act 1939 | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2; EV-0049 - C0013 1939-05 | May 1939 | Agreement, Western Ground Rents to John Williams, with plan (Glamorgan Archives DBDT123/7) | EV-0023 | src > SOURCE PENDING: the 1939 agreement is held as an image; its wording is not yet transcribed. - C0014 1941 | 1941–43 | National Farm Survey, Penarth parish bundle | The National Archives MAF 32/1220/39 | TNA catalogue MAF 32/1220/39 - C0015 1949-02-02 | 2 February 1949 | Surrender and new yearly tenancy, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶5 | src > It appears that Mr Williams, who may already by then have been elderly, fell into arrears with his rent in the mid-1930s and in the late 1940s. Because of that, agreement was reached for Mr Williams' tenancy to be surrendered and for a new yearly agricultural tenancy commencing at February 2 1949 to be granted to Mr Williams' son-in-law, Mr Frederick Buckler, who was the father of Mr Buckler junior. It was intended that Mr Frederick Buckler should have a written tenancy agreement, but this did not happen because Mr Frederick Buckler also failed to pay the rent. There is a letter from the landlords' agents to their solicitors of October 10 1952 stating that they did not propose to proceed with the letting to Mr Frederick Buckler. However, the conclusion must be that, even though there was no written agreement, Mr Frederick Buckler had a periodic tenancy which was protected by the Agricultural Holdings Act. [S5] - C0016 1955-07-04 | 2 February 1955 to 4 July 1955 | High Court possession order under Order 14, as recited by the Court of Appeal (EV-0032) | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶6 | src > His tenancy was then duly terminated by a notice to quit which expired on February 2 1955. Western Ground Rents then brought proceedings for possession against Mr Frederick Buckler in the High Court and obtained a possession order, under Order 14, in respect of the whole of the farm. On July 4 1955 that possession order was enforced, and possession was taken in respect of all parts of the farm except the farmhouse and garden. The reason why the order was not enforced in respect of the farmhouse and garden was that Mrs Mary Buckler (daughter of Mr Williams, wife of Mr Frederick Buckler and mother of Mr Buckler junior) had recently come out of hospital after having had a leg amputated and was objecting very strongly to leaving the farmhouse. [S1 S2] - C0017 1958-10-31 | 31 October 1958 | The London Gazette, 31 October 1958, p. 6652 | EV-0287 (London Gazette notice) | src > the City of Cardiff (Leckwith Common) Compulsory Purchase Order, 1957, confirmed by him on the 8th September 1958, under section 5 of the Physical Training and Recreation Act, 1937 - C0018 1959 | By 1959 | Tenancy offer for the farmhouse and garden, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶7 | src > By 1959, at any rate, Mrs Mary Buckler, who was also from time to time referred to as Mrs Williams, had conceived the notion that she had a title to the ownership of Great House Farm through her own grandfather and that there were documents in existence which proved her title. No such documents were, however, ever produced. She was offered a tenancy of the farmhouse and garden by Western Ground Rents but refused to accept it. - C0019 1961-03-29 | 29 March 1961 | Deed, Western Ground Rents, South Western Brick & Tile and Cardiff City Corporation, as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Charges Register entry 3 | src > The land tinted pink on the filed plan is subject to the rights contained in a Deed dated 29 March 1961 made between (1) Western Ground Rents Limited (2) The South Western Brick & Tile Company Limited and (3) Cardiff City Corporation. - C0020 1962-12-11 | 11 December 1962 | Cardiff County Court possession order, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶9 | src > In 1962, however, Western Ground Rents brought a fresh action in Cardiff County Court against Mr Frederick Buckler and Mrs Buckler for possession of the farmhouse and garden and mesne profits since 1955. On December 11 1962 a possession order was made by Judge Temple Morris QC together with an order for payment of mesne profits. The latter was to some extent enforced, in that there seems to have been a suspended committal order against Mr Frederick Buckler in June 1963, but nothing was done before 1974 to enforce the 1962 possession order. - C0021 1965 | 1965 | Commons Registration Act 1965 | Commons Registration Act 1965 (VG 41 registered under it) | EV-0263 - C0022 1965-06-11 | 11 June 1965 | Conveyance, Lakeside & Llandough Development Co and Western Ground Rents to Glamorgan County Council | EV-0042 (Vale of Glamorgan Council, FOI 00211027) | src > ALL THAT piece or parcel of land situate at Llandough … Three Point Three Five Two acres … part of Enclosure 106 on the Ordnance Survey Map Glamorgan Sheet XLVII.6 (1941 Edition) - C0023 1969-02-15 | 15 Feb 1969 | Agreed bid, British Petroleum for Western Ground Rents Ltd | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) | src - C0024 1969-12 | December 1969 | Sale, Western Ground Rents to BP Pension Trust Ltd, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶9 | src > In the meantime Mr Frederick Buckler died at some time in the period 1965-67, and in December 1969 Great House Farm, including the farmhouse and garden, was sold by Western Ground Rents to BP Pension Trust Ltd. [S5] - C0025 1969-12-31 | 31 Dec 1969 | Conveyance, Western Ground Rents Ltd to BP Pension Trust Ltd (recited root of title, WA231076 and WA240304) | HMLR letter 19 Apr 2026, ref WA231076/A/216/CT | EV-0045 [S5] - C0026 1970-06-16 | 16 June 1970 | VG41 village green registration | EV-0044 | src > SOURCE PENDING: the VG41 register entry, map and ownership section. - C0027 1971 | 1971 | Abstract of title, “lodged with the application for first registration” (WA231076); “had sight of a copy of a 1971 abstract of title” (WA240304) | HMLR letter 19 Apr 2026, ref WA231076/A/216/CT | EV-0045 [S5 S6] - C0028 1974-04-26 | 26 Apr 1974 | Measured survey notes and plan of the farmhouse, annotated “House demolished Nov. 1988” | RCAHMW ST 1681 7331 | Cadw review report, 10 Aug 2026 (appendix) - C0029 1974-07-02 | 3 July 1974 | Defence of Mrs Buckler in the 1974 county court action | EV-0049 | src > SOURCE PENDING: the defence pleading ownership; only the Court of Appeal’s summary of it. - C0030 1974-07-03 | 1974 (part heard 3 July 1974) | BP Pension Trust Ltd v Mrs Buckler, Cardiff County Court, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶11 | src > In 1974 BP Pension Trust Ltd started a fresh action in the Cardiff County Court for possession and mesne profits against Mrs Buckler (sued as Mrs Williams) and various members of her family, including Mr Buckler junior. This was adjourned part heard on July 3 1974 for a formal defence to be filed on behalf of Mrs Buckler, and a defence was filed asserting that BP Pension Trust's claim was barred by adverse possession under the Limitation Act 1939; so far as Mr Buckler junior is concerned, it was pleaded that he occupied the property as licensee of Mrs Buckler. That action has never been finally heard. However, on September 17 1974 BP Pension Trust Ltd gave notice of an application by them as successors in title to Western Ground Rents for leave to enforce the possession order of December 11 1962 (the order of Judge Temple Morris QC) and on September 19 1974 Judge Watkin Powell on that application gave BP Pension Trust Ltd leave to execute the order for possession of December 11 1962. He ordered that the possession warrant do issue forthwith but be not enforced until October 31 1974. [S5] - C0031 1974-10-31 | 31 October 1974 | Letter, BP Pension Trust Ltd to Mrs Buckler, as quoted by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶15 | src > We have been advised that you are making an application to the Court for a Stay of Execution of the Order for Possession which was recently confirmed, and that you are proposing to apply to have the judgment of the Court, which we were seeking to enforce, set aside. You will, we hope, understand that the Trustees of The British Petroleum Pension Trust are not, and never have been, unsympathetic to your position, but they are bound in law to have a prime regard for the interests of their Pensioners and they had no alternative but to exercise remedies against you which the law provides. The only way in which they could safeguard your future occupation of Great House Farm is by selling the property to a purchaser who is not bound by similar constraints. We are now pleased to advise you that we have found such a purchaser in BP Properties Ltd, who have agreed to buy the property from the Trust. Accordingly, the instructions given to the Bailiff to execute the judgment of the Court have been withdrawn. As the Possession Order will not now be executed, your application for a Stay of Execution becomes unnecessary. Your Solicitors are immediately being advised accordingly. [S6] - C0032 1974-10-31 | 31 October 1974 | Letter, BP Properties Ltd to Mrs Buckler, as quoted by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶16 | src > You will be hearing separately from our Pension Trust that they are selling Great House Farm to BP Properties Ltd. As BP Properties is not obliged by the same constraints as the Pension Trust and since we wish to help you as much as possible, we are prepared to allow you to remain in occupation of the house and garden rent free for as long as you may wish and for the rest of your life if you so desire. I am pleased accordingly to confirm that we will not require you to give possession during your lifetime or until such time as you may choose no longer to live in the house, and we have given the necessary instructions so that no proceedings will be commenced until you personally no longer live there. I do hope that by making this gesture you will accept the situation and that no further problems will arise in the future. [S3 S6] - C0033 1974-11-04 | 4 November 1974 | Hearing and withdrawal of the warrant, as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶13; ¶16 | src > Both are addressed to Mrs Buckler (described again as Mrs Williams), but both were in fact sent not to her but to her solicitor, who seems to have received them on the morning of November 4, immediately before he made his application to Judge Watkin Powell in the Cardiff County Court. Because of these two letters the landlords' solicitors did not attend the appointment before the judge on November 4 1974. Mrs Buckler's solicitors produced the letters to the judge, and he stayed execution on the warrant for possession pending Mrs Buckler's agreement to the proposals in the letters. Her solicitor then telephoned Mrs Buckler, told her of the letters and sought her instructions. Before she had given any instructions, however, the landlords' solicitors themselves wrote to the county court, at some date prior to November 25 1974 and withdrew the warrant for possession. Mrs Buckler therefore never expressly accepted or rejected the terms of the two letters. She was left in undisturbed possession of the farmhouse and garden, rent free, until her death, which occurred in March 1983. [S2 S3] - C0034 1975-05-23 | 23 May 1975 | Conveyance, The British Petroleum Pension Trust Limited and BP Trustees Limited to B.P. Properties Limited, as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Charges Register entry 4 | src > A Conveyance of the land tinted blue on the filed plan and other land dated 23 May 1975 made between (1) The British Petroleum Pension Trust Limited (Vendors) (2) BP Trustees Limited and (3) B.P. Properties Limited (Purchaser) contains covenants details of which are set out in the schedule of restrictive covenants hereto. - C0035 1975-12-01 | 1 Dec 1975 | Compulsory registration of title begins in the Vale of Glamorgan | SI 1975/160 | EV-0265 - C0036 1980-05-22 | 22 May 1980 | House of Commons, Hansard, HC Deb 22 May 1980, vol. 985 (Ted Rowlands MP) | EV-0057 | src > the most rapacious ground landlord, Western Ground Rents, has been bought by the BP pension fund, which is behaving in the same rapacious and, at times, unfeeling and uncaring way in handling the genuine requests of householders. - C0037 1982-10 | Oct 1982 | GGAT recommendation: archaeological investigation before development | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) | src - C0038 1982-11-19 | 19 November 1982 | Conveyance, BP Pension Trust Ltd and BP Trustees Ltd to B.P. Properties Ltd, as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Charges Register entry 6 | src > A Conveyance of the land tinted pink on the filed plan and other land dated 19 November 1982 made between (1) The British Petroleum Pension Trust Limited (2) B.P.Trustees Limited and (3) B.P. Properties Limited contains restrictive covenants. - C0039 1982-11-30 | 30 Nov 1982 | Application for first registration, WA231076, BP Properties Ltd (lodged by Linklaters & Paines) | HMLR letter 23 Mar 2026, ref WA231076/A/216 | EV-0147 [S6] - C0040 1983-02-23 | 23 February 1983 | HM Land Registry, first registration of the farmhouse and garden (WA240304), as listed in HM Land Registry’s letter of 30 July 2026 (ref N610CGV) | HMLR letter, 30 July 2026, WA240304 schedule, items 10–13 | src > (10) Copy of Register edition date 23 February 1983 … (11) Form 1C application form from Linklaters & Paines … (12) Conveyance 23 May 1975 (13) Plan to conveyance dated 23 February 1975 [S2 S6] - C0041 1984-05-22 | 22 May 1984 | Writ for possession, as recorded by the European Commission of Human Rights | European Commission of Human Rights, Decision as to the admissibility of Application No. 14464/88, 14 April 1989, The Facts, p. 2 | src > On 22 May 1984, the applicant was served with a writ by B.P. (Properties) Limited for possession of Great House Farm and adjourning lands to which it held the title. This property had been occupied by the applicant's family since 1916 and on his mother's death on 26 March 1983, the applicant had inherited her estate and continued to live on the farm. [S6] - C0042 1986-07-24 | 24 July 1986 | Judgment of Hollis J (Queen’s Bench Division, Cardiff), as recited by the Court of Appeal | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶23 | src > The judge rejected the primary claim on the ground that Mr Frederick Buckler's possession during his lifetime was not 'adverse', and so time did not begin to run against the landlords until after his death. On the second argument he held that the effect of the letters of October 31 1974 was to constitute Mrs Buckler the licensee of BP Properties Ltd, and thus no longer in adverse possession, even though the letters were written unilaterally and without any agreement with her. The defence under the 1939 and 1980 Acts therefore failed. [S3] - C0043 1987-02-02 | 2 Feb 1987 | Amalgamation application and supporting plan, WA231076 / WA240304 | HMLR schedule 30 Jul 2026; FC-004 | HMLR schedule 30 Jul 2026 - C0044 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: the parties and the title | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶2 | src > The action concerns a farm known as Great House Farm at Llandough near Penarth in South Glamorgan. The plaintiffs, BP Properties Ltd, have the paper title to the farm, and indeed since November 1982 they have been the registered proprietors of it at HM Land Registry following first registration. [S5 S6] - C0045 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: Limitation Act 1939, section 13, as cited | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶8 | src > 'no person shall be deemed to have been in possession of any land by reason only of having made a formal entry thereon, and no continual or other claim upon or near any land shall preserve any right of action to recover the land'. - C0046 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: Limitation Act 1980, section 15(1), as cited | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶19 | src > no action shall be brought by any person to recover any land after the expiration of 12 years from the date on which the right of action accrued to him, or, if it first accrued to some person through whom he claims, to that person. - C0047 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: the enforcement point | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶32 | src > It follows that enforcement of the judgment for possession of December 11 1962 was still open to the landlords at October 31 1974, and their title to the farmhouse and garden had not been extinguished. I would accordingly reject the contention that Mrs Buckler had acquired a title by adverse possession before October 31 1974. [S5] - C0048 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: the "wrong company" argument | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶22 | src > I see nothing in this rather technical point; the letters record sufficiently that BP Properties Ltd had agreed to buy the property from the Pension Trust, and BP Properties Ltd was therefore prima facie in a position to grant a licence to Mrs Buckler. [S5] - C0049 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: repudiation | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶38 | src > It may be that the result would have been different if Mrs Buckler had, as soon as she learned of the letters, plainly told BP Properties Ltd that she did not accept the letters, and maintained her claims to be already the owner of the property; she did not, however, do that. [S3] - C0050 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: the licence | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶40–41 | src > The nature of Mrs Buckler's possession after receipt of the letters cannot be decided just by looking at what was locked up in her own mind. It must depend even more, on this aspect of the case, on the position as seen from the standpoint of the person with the paper title. What could that person have done? The rule that possession is not adverse if it can be referred to a lawful title applies even if the person in possession did not know of the lawful title; the lawful title would still preclude the person with the paper title from evicting the person in possession. So far as Mrs Buckler was concerned, even though she did not 'accept' the terms of the letters, BP Properties Ltd would, in the absence of any repudiation by her of the two letters, have been bound to treat her as in possession as licensee on the terms of the letters. They could not have evicted her (if they could have done so at all) without determining the licence. I can see no escape therefore from the conclusion that, whether she liked it or not, from the time of her receipt of the letters, Mrs Buckler was in possession of the farmhouse and garden by the licence of BP Properties Ltd, and her possession was no longer adverse within the meaning of section 10 of the 1939 Act. [S3 S6] - C0051 1987-07-31 | 31 July 1987 | Court of Appeal: order | BP Properties Ltd v Buckler [1987] EWCA Civ 2, Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, Dillon LJ, BAILII text ¶42–43 | src > Accordingly I would dismiss this appeal. MUSTILL LJ and SIR EDWARD EVELEIGH agreed and did not add anything. - C0052 1987-12-17 | 17 Dec 1987 | Council minutes: request for VG 41 to be “extended up to the farm wall”; Penlan Road licence recorded as terminated by Debenham Tewson | Vale of Glamorgan Council minutes, 17 Dec 1987 | EV-0214 - C0053 1988 | 1988 | Cadw-to-Minister spot-listing letter (Welsh Office) | GHF-E152 (catalogue placeholder; original not held) | GHF-E152 [S5] - C0054 1988-03-03 | 3 Mar 1988 | House of Lords: leave to appeal refused, BP Properties Ltd v Buckler | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) | src - C0055 1988-07-29 | 29 Jul 1988 | Cadw listing inspection of the farmhouse; two exterior photographs | ATISN 27021 (reply 11 Jun 2026) | EV-0094; EV-0095 - C0056 1988-12-05 | 5 Dec 1988 | Cadw: farmhouse not listed | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33); ATISN 27021 | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) [S5] - C0057 1988-12-06 | 3 March 1988 to 6 December 1988 | House of Lords refusal, eviction attempt, possession and demolition, as recorded by the European Commission of Human Rights | European Commission of Human Rights, Decision as to the admissibility of Application No. 14464/88, 14 April 1989, The Facts, p. 2 | src > The applicant applied to the House of Lords, which on 3 March 1988 refused him leave to appeal. A stay of execution of 28 days was ordered to enable the applicant to make alternative arrangements for accommodation. On 29 April 1988, B.P. (Properties) Ltd attempted to evict the applicant and his family. The applicant refused to leave the property however and the bailiffs were obliged to withdraw. On 29 November 1988 the company obtained possession of the property and on 6 December demolition of the farmhouse began. - C0058 1989-01 | Jan 1989 | Summons (threatening behaviour, arising from 29 Apr 1988) withdrawn as out of time | Press (Legal Wiki, Master Timeline) | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) - C0059 1989-03 | March 1989 | Sites and Monuments Record card PRN 02038s (Heneb HER, Archwilio GGAT02038s) | EV-0118 | src > building destroyed by owners [S4] - C0060 1989-04-06 | 6 Apr 1989 | Cadw Llandough community resurvey list (13430, 13431; church 13432 dated 4 Jun 1989) | Cadw list entries 13430, 13431, 13432 | EV-0272 - C0061 1989-04-14 | 14 April 1989 | European Commission of Human Rights: Article 8 and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 | European Commission of Human Rights, Decision as to the admissibility of Application No. 14464/88, 14 April 1989, The Law, paras 2–3, pp. 3–4 | src > The Commission notes that the applicant has lived in the property in question since his birth and that the decision of the court giving possession to B.P. (Properties) Ltd could be considered as an interference with the applicant's right to respect for his home. The Commission finds however that the order, pursuant to court proceedings, was in accordance with law and was "necessary in a democratic society" for the legitimate aim of protecting the rights of 14464/88 ■r 4 - Other, namely, the rights of B.P. (Properties) Ltd, who were held to be owner of the property. The Commission accordingly finds any interference justified within the meaning of Article 8 para. 2 of the Convention. It follows that this complaint is manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 27 para. 2 of the Convention. 3. The applicant has complained that the decisions have interfered within his rights under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention, which provides: "Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law. The preceding provisions shall not, however, in any way impair the right of a State to enforce such laws as it deems necessary to control the use of property in accordance with the general interest or to secure the payment of taxes or other contributions or penalties." The Commission recalls however that the courts held that the applicant had no right to occupy the property, which belonged to another. The Commission finds, therefore, that there has been no interference with the applicant's possessions within the meaning of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.. [S4] - C0062 1989-04-14 | 14 April 1989 | European Commission of Human Rights: decision | European Commission of Human Rights, Decision as to the admissibility of Application No. 14464/88, 14 April 1989, p. 4 | src > For these reasons, the Commission DECLARES THE APPLICATION INADMISSIBLE. - C0063 1989-10-10 | 10 October 1989 | Transfer, B P Properties Limited to [private individuals], as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Property Register entry 3 | src > The land has the benefit of the following rights reserved by a Transfer of land adjoining the Southern boundary of the land in this title dated 10 October 1989 made between (1) B P Properties Limited and (2) [private individuals]:- - C0064 1989-11-08 | 8 November 1989 (application) | Outline planning permission 89/01396/OUT, Great House Farm, Leckwith Road | EV-0124 | src > The Council in pursuance of its powers under the above mentioned Act and Order hereby GRANTS OUTLINE PERMISSION for the carrying out of the proposed development as described above - C0065 1990-02-08 | 8 Feb 1990 | GGAT further comments, Appendix B, on the redevelopment application | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33) | src [S5] - C0066 1990-03-13 | 13 Mar 1990 | Outline planning permission, housing on the farm land, 18 conditions (89/01396/OUT) | 89/01396/OUT | Legal Wiki, Master Timeline (page 33); EV-0124 - C0067 1990-10-30 | 30 Oct 1990 | Old Barry Road, Llandough stopping-up order: proposed 30 Oct 1990; inquiry 5 Nov 1991; made 18 Mar 1992 (Welsh Office) | Welsh Office stopping-up order, Old Barry Road, Llandough | EV-0275 - C0068 1992-09-03 | 3 September 1992 | Approved planning drawings 92/00671/RES | EV-0129 | src > BOROUGH OF THE VALE OF GLAMORGAN TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING ACT, 1990 APPROVED SUBJECT TO COMPLIANCE WITH CONDITIONS IF ANY 3 SEP 1992 ... SCREEN WALL DETAIL ... THIS COURSE ONLY TO BE CONTRASTING BRICK - C0069 1993-12-03 | 3 Dec 1993 | Transfer, BP Properties Ltd to Ideal Homes, registered on WA231076 | HMLR schedule 30 Jul 2026 - C0070 1994-01-12 | 12 January 1994 | Ideal Homes Wales, Llandough Farm: Village Green planting plan (received stamp) | EV-0133 | src > Villge Green to be maintained by LLANDOUGH COMMUNITY COUNCIL and to form part of project GATEWAY TO THE VALE. IDEAL HOMES WALES LLANDOUGH FARM, LLANDOUGH VILLAGE GREEN PLANTING. 3024.VG.01 [S5] - C0071 1994-07-28 | 28 Jul 1994 | Donation of human remains, “Great House Farm, Llandough” (95.56H): “Ideal Homes Wales Ltd. should be acknowledged as the donor” | Amgueddfa Cymru – Museum Wales accession 95.56H | EV-0293 - C0072 1994-11-10 | 10 November 1994 | Transfer, Ideal Homes Wales Limited to Forest of Cardiff, as recorded on the register | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Charges Register entry 8 | src > A Transfer of the land in this title dated 10 November 1994 made between (1) Ideal Homes Wales Limited (Transferor) and (2) Forest of Cardiff (Transferee) contains covenants details of which are set out in the schedule of restrictive covenants hereto. - C0073 1994-11-25 | 25 November 1994 | Proprietorship Register entry 1 | HM Land Registry title register WA735527 (Land lying on the North East side of Leckwith Road, Llandough), accessed 18 September 2026, Proprietorship Register entry 1 (entry date 1994-11-25) | src > PROPRIETOR: FOREST OF CARDIFF (Co. Regn. No. 2591796) of The Wales Conservative Centre, Forest Farm Road, Whitchurch, Cardiff, CF4 7JH. - C0074 1997-05-16 | 16 May 1997 | Final meetings, winding-up of Western Ground Rents Ltd and other BP pension companies | London Gazette notices | EV-0249; EV-0277 - C0075 2000 | 2000 | Freedom of Information Act 2000, ss. 9, 10, 12, 14(2), 21 | Freedom of Information Act 2000 | FOI replies 2026 (Cadw, Llandough CC, TNA) - C0076 2004 | 2004 | Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (SI 2004/3391), regs 5(2), 11(4), 12(4)(b) | SI 2004/3391 | EIR replies 2026 (Vale, Dŵr Cymru, Heneb) - C0077 2005 | 2005 | Transfer, part of WA735527, Forest of Cardiff to Goldsworthy Homes | HM Land Registry WA735527 | GHF-E150 - C0078 2018 | 2018 | Data Protection Act 2018; UK GDPR art. 12(3) (subject access, one month) | Data Protection Act 2018; UK GDPR art. 12(3) | SAR acknowledgements 2026 (HMLR D260928) - C0079 2025-11-20 | 20 Nov 2025 | Llandough Community Council reply: “unable to assist with the matter you raise” | Llandough Community Council | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0080 2026-01-31 | 31 Jan–8 Feb 2026 | The National Archives, records enquiry | CAS-313954-Y6C0H3 | TNA RESO Records Enquiries - C0081 2026-02-02 | 2–13 Feb 2026 | HM Land Registry Customer Support enquiry; Wales Office letter | 260202-5732372; WA231076/A/216/LG | HMLR letters 2–13 Feb 2026 - C0082 2026-03-23 | 23 Mar 2026 | HM Land Registry: “No evidence of a mistake in the register” | WA231076/A/216 | EV-0147 [S6] - C0083 2026-04-13 | 13 Apr 2026 | HM Land Registry FOI response | FOI F260213 | EV-0148 - C0084 2026-04-19 | 19 Apr 2026 | HM Land Registry complaint, stage 1 decision | WA231076/A/216/CT | EV-0045 - C0085 2026-05-22 | 22 May 2026 | Heneb: “Heneb is not subject to FOI requests as we are a Limited company.” | Heneb (formerly GGAT), records request | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) [S6] - C0086 2026-05-25 | 25 May 2026 | HM Land Registry complaint, stage 2 “second and final response” | WA231076/A/216 | EV-0153 - C0087 2026-06-11 | 11 Jun 2026 | Cadw reply: 1988 listing file assessed, “did not meet the listing criteria”; only two photographs survive | ATISN 27021 | EV-0094; EV-0095 [S5] - C0088 2026-06-14 | 14 Jun 2026 | Llandough Community Council FOI reply: s.21, minutes from 1982 deposited at Glamorgan Archives in 2002 | FOIA s.21 (request of 18 May 2026) | LCC M06 - C0089 2026-06-20 | 20 Jun 2026 | Internal review asked, WhatDoTheyKnow FOI “BP vs Buckler 1987” (Ministry of Justice / HMCTS) | WhatDoTheyKnow FOI, internal review | WhatDoTheyKnow - C0090 2026-07-02 | 2, 10, 29 Jul 2026 | Cadw internal review outcomes (listing-file responses) | Cadw internal reviews | Cadw review report, 10 Aug 2026 - C0091 2026-07-07 | 7 Jul 2026 | Vale of Glamorgan Council, EIR internal review asked | 00210772 (EIR reg. 11) | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0092 2026-07-16 | 16 Jul 2026 | South Wales Police FOI reply: “hold no information” (1988 enforcement) | FOI 719/26 | EV-0159 [S5] - C0093 2026-07-30 | 30 Jul 2026 | HM Land Registry schedule of first-registration files: 30 items (WA231076), 13 items (WA240304); copies £11 each, form OC2 | WA231076; WA240304 | HMLR letter 30 Jul 2026 [S5 S6] - C0094 2026-08-04 | 4 Aug 2026 | Cardiff County Court reply: no records held, because of the case’s age (1955–1988 proceedings) | HMCTS, Cardiff County Court enquiries | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) [S5] - C0095 2026-08-10 | 9/10 Aug 2026 | Cadw review report (record correction request) | Cadw review report | Cadw review report, 10 Aug 2026 - C0096 2026-08-13 | 13 Aug 2026 | Dŵr Cymru EIR reply (data-subject-rights team): no records (request 7 Jun 2026) | EIR reg. 5(2) | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0097 2026-08-13 | 13 Aug 2026 | Ministry of Justice FOI internal review | FOI 260813002 | MoJ letter 9 Oct 2026 - C0098 2026-08-25 | 25 Aug 2026 | BP Archive: holds material to end-1954; post-1954 not open externally; no pre-1955 documents on the property | BP Archive enquiry | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0099 2026-08-25 | 25 Aug 2026 | Museum Wales: other discoveries at Great House Farm and Church Farm treated as not in scope | FOI 2026-024 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) [S1] - C0100 2026-08-27 | 27 Aug 2026 | Cadw Chief Inspector letter | Cadw | Cadw letters 27 Aug, 4 Sep 2026 - C0101 2026-09-02 | 2 Sep 2026 | The National Archives, WhatDoTheyKnow FOI: Great House Farm and BP Properties Ltd v Buckler (1987) | FOI (FOIA s.10) | WhatDoTheyKnow - C0102 2026-09-03 | 3 Sep 2026 | Dŵr Cymru review: treated as an enquiry about the 1988 supply | Dŵr Cymru Customer Care | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) [S4] - C0103 2026-09-04 | 4 Sep 2026 | Cadw Chief Inspector letter | Cadw | Cadw letters 27 Aug, 4 Sep 2026 - C0104 2026-09-07 | 7 and 24 Sep 2026 | Glamorgan Archives: £60 for 53 images (ACA/8/2); £50 rate-book search; £50 planning-minutes search | Glamorgan Archives ACA/8/2 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0105 2026-09-08 | 8 Sep 2026 | RCAHMW requests (four) | RC26-0375 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0106 2026-09-11 | 11 Sep 2026 | Vale of Glamorgan Council: further historical documentation found and being sifted, “clearer timeframe” to follow | 00210772 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0107 2026-09-14 | 14 Sep 2026 | Vale of Glamorgan Council reply: 11 Jun 1965 conveyance and 1965 contract released | 00211027 | EV-0042; EV-0216 - C0108 2026-09-20 | 20 Sep 2026 | Llandough Community Council (Chair): “We have nothing more to add” | Llandough Community Council | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0109 2026-09-22 | 22 Sep 2026 | Vale of Glamorgan Council, internal review asked | WDTK 2020 01590 HYB | WhatDoTheyKnow - C0110 2026-09-22 | 22 Sep 2026 | Museum Wales FOI disclosure | FOI 2026-032 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0111 2026-09-27 | 27 Sep 2026 | South Wales Police internal review (of 719/26) | Internal review 1188/26 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0112 2026-09-27 | 27 Sep 2026 | Heneb formal complaint (acknowledged 30 Sep 2026) | Heneb complaints procedure | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0113 2026-09-28 | 28 Sep 2026 | HM Land Registry subject access request (acknowledged 1 Oct under UK GDPR) | SAR D260928 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0114 2026-09-28 | 28 Sep 2026 | HM Land Registry Independent Complaints Reviewer, allocated | ICR/090/26 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0115 2026-09-28 | 28 Sep 2026 | Cadw FOI request: July–December 1988 listing papers | ATISN 27589 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0116 2026-09-28 | 28 Sep 2026 | Vale of Glamorgan Council request: section 52 and land charges, planning register, EIA screening, conditions 16–18, 92/00671/RES | 00211557 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0117 2026-09-28 | 28 Sep, 16 Oct 2026 | Preservation notices to BP (farm, 1982–83 registrations, 1987 case) | Preservation notices | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0118 2026-09-29 | 29 Sep 2026 | South Wales Police FOI response by attachment | FOI 1040/26 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0119 2026-09-29 | 29 Sep 2026 | South Wales Police subject access request | Subject access (UK GDPR) | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0120 2026-10-05 | 5 Oct 2026 | Museum Wales FOI disclosure: Ref 13.2 (waterwheel), page of MS 3360/3 | FOI 2026-036 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0121 2026-10-06 | 6 Oct 2026 | Heneb: EIR applicability “a matter of legal determination” | Heneb, HER source file GGAT02038s | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0122 2026-10-07 | 7 Oct 2026 | The National Archives internal review | CAS-347296-M0V4Y1 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0123 2026-10-07 | 7–12 Oct 2026 | Museum Wales: no search log, file note or other document of the “not in scope” assessment is held; “No records remain withheld.” | FOI 2026-024, item 7 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) [S5] - C0124 2026-10-09 | 9 Oct 2026 | Ministry of Justice letter (FOI internal review outcome) | FOI 260813002 | MoJ letter 9 Oct 2026 - C0125 2026-10-10 | 10 Oct 2026 | HM Land Registry internal application “to investigate and correct any error that may have been made” | N610CGV | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0126 2026-10-10 | 10 Oct 2026 | Cadw FOI request: inventory, closure note, transfer list, disposal authority, destruction record (1988 file) | ATISN 26-0009 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0127 2026-10-10 | 10 Oct 2026 | Welsh Government FOI request: retention and destruction schedules (pre-1997 files); records on the farm, Western Ground Rents Ltd, BP Properties Ltd | ATISN 26-0010 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0128 2026-10-10 | 10 Oct 2026 | South Wales Police FOI request: non-personal operational records, Nov–Dec 1988 (logged 12 Oct) | FOI 1264/26 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0129 2026-10-10 | 10 Oct 2026 | HM Land Registry title enquiries: “Already been raised” | Enquiry 260917-6718215 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0130 2026-10-11 | 11 Oct 2026 | Llandough Community Council (Clerk): refused under s.12 (cost) | FOIA s.12 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) [S6] - C0131 2026-10-11 | 11 Oct 2026 | Llandough Community Council EIR request: VG 41 / St Dochdwy’s verge / 89/01396/OUT | EIR | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0132 2026-10-11 | 11 Oct 2026 | Llandough Community Council subject access request | Subject access (UK GDPR) | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0133 2026-10-11 | 11 Oct 2026 | Vale of Glamorgan Council Democratic Services: Task and Finish review declined | Vale of Glamorgan Council Scrutiny | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0134 2026-10-12 | 12 Oct 2026 | The National Archives location reply: map identified; access by visit, paid staff search, or independent researcher | IR 131/4/96 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0135 2026-10-14 | 14 Oct 2026 | Heneb: HER source file digitised to Archwilio | GGAT02038s | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0136 2026-10-15 | 15 Oct 2026 | Application to alter the register lodged | Z084NQV | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0137 2026-10-16 | 16 Oct 2026 | Heneb point-by-point reply to schedule | GHF/HENEB/2026-09-20 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0138 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | Cadw: refused under FOIA s.14(2) as “substantially similar” to 27021 | ATISN 27589; FOIA s.14(2) | EV-0245 [S1] - C0139 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | Welsh Government reply: no files found; records “would have been destroyed in line with the corporate retention schedule applied at the time” | ATISN 26-0010 | EV-0244 [S5] - C0140 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | Internal review asked: ATISN 27589 (reconsider under the EIR) and 26-0010 | Cadw / Welsh Government internal review | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0141 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | Records enquiry to BP: custodian of BP Properties / BP Pension Trust records 1969–1993 | BP group legal | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0142 2026-10-19 | 19–20 Oct 2026 | Preservation notice to HMCTS: index entries, warrants or bailiff returns | Preservation notice | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0143 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | NLW LibAnswers enquiry: D153/4–8, D219, the 1938 conveyance | NLW LibAnswers | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0144 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | The National Archives follow-up: IR 58 entries for the HMLR titles; BT 31 reference | TNA follow-up | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0145 2026-10-19 | 19 Oct 2026 | Glamorgan Archives ‘County Treasures’ inventory request | Glamorgan Archives | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0146 2026-10-20 | 20 Oct 2026 | HM Land Registry EIR request (first-registration and amalgamation documents) | EIR (D260928 thread) | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0147 2026-10-20 | 20 Oct 2026 | Llandough Community Council narrowed FOI request | FOI | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) - C0148 2026-10-20 | 20 Oct 2026 | Llandough Community Council agenda: 22 Oct 2026 meeting remote | LCC agenda, 22 Oct 2026 | case mailbox (email.bucklerfamily.estate) :S1: Scope: the operative noun phrase covers more (or other) land than the instrument it rests on evidences :S2: Party: the person most affected is not a party, not the addressee, or not shown to have been served :S3: Agency: the operative effect is imposed without any act or consent of the person it binds :S4: Term shift: a key word (possession, owner, proprietor, possessions) changes meaning between documents :S5: Text gap: the operative text is known only from a later recital or summary :S6: Inconsistency: dates, years or descriptions conflict between records of the same act .. data: /data/chronology.json :: rule set: /data/model.json v1.0.0 :: earlier view: /v2/